Started By
Message
Why you will NEVER see a 16-team Playoff
Posted on 12/4/19 at 10:58 am
Posted on 12/4/19 at 10:58 am
It would be an absolute disaster for the committee. I'll show you why.
If there were a 16 team playoff as of right now, it would look like this:
First Round:
1. Ohio State vs 16. Iowa
3. Clemson vs 14. Michigan
5. Utah vs 12. Bama
7. Baylor vs 10. Penn State
8. Wisconsin vs 9. Florida
6. Oklahoma vs. 11. Auburn
4. Georgia vs 13. Oregon
2. LSU vs. 15. Notre Dame
Second Round (where the melt begins):
1. Ohio State vs 3. Clemson
12. Bama vs 10. Penn State
9. Florida vs 11. Auburn
4. Georgia vs 2. LSU
You would have 62.5% SEC teams in the 2nd round.
Third Round (where the melt grows):
1. Ohio State vs. 12. Bama
11. Auburn vs. 2. LSU
You would have 75% SEC teams in the semis.
Finals (where the melt is complete):
12. Bama vs. 2. LSU
You would have 100% SEC teams in the Final.
Then LSU wins, of course.
But that is exactly the reason you will never see a 16 team playoff. The committee has got to control who gets in.
If there were a 16 team playoff as of right now, it would look like this:
First Round:
1. Ohio State vs 16. Iowa
3. Clemson vs 14. Michigan
5. Utah vs 12. Bama
7. Baylor vs 10. Penn State
8. Wisconsin vs 9. Florida
6. Oklahoma vs. 11. Auburn
4. Georgia vs 13. Oregon
2. LSU vs. 15. Notre Dame
Second Round (where the melt begins):
1. Ohio State vs 3. Clemson
12. Bama vs 10. Penn State
9. Florida vs 11. Auburn
4. Georgia vs 2. LSU
You would have 62.5% SEC teams in the 2nd round.
Third Round (where the melt grows):
1. Ohio State vs. 12. Bama
11. Auburn vs. 2. LSU
You would have 75% SEC teams in the semis.
Finals (where the melt is complete):
12. Bama vs. 2. LSU
You would have 100% SEC teams in the Final.
Then LSU wins, of course.
But that is exactly the reason you will never see a 16 team playoff. The committee has got to control who gets in.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:01 am to Jambalaya Sauce
There are not 16 teams worthy of playing for a championship every year. I don't think there are 8 either. IMO it needs to stay at 4
This post was edited on 12/4/19 at 11:03 am
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:01 am to Jambalaya Sauce
No, we'll never see a 16 team playoff because it's impractical and unfair to the athletes.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:01 am to Jambalaya Sauce
Neeeeverr say never
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:03 am to Jambalaya Sauce
Who is arguing for more than 8?
Honestly in most years the #8 team in the country playing @#1 is pretty pointless. 6 with first round byes preserves the regular season and provides incentives to play in Conference Championship games
Honestly in most years the #8 team in the country playing @#1 is pretty pointless. 6 with first round byes preserves the regular season and provides incentives to play in Conference Championship games
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:03 am to Jambalaya Sauce
quote:
First Round:
1. Ohio State vs 16. Iowa
3. Clemson vs 14. Michigan
5. Utah vs 12. Bama
7. Baylor vs 10. Penn State
8. Wisconsin vs 9. Florida
6. Oklahoma vs. 11. Auburn
4. Georgia vs 13. Oregon
2. LSU vs. 15. Notre Dame
Second Round (where the melt begins):
1. Ohio State vs 3. Clemson
12. Bama vs 10. Penn State
9. Florida vs 11. Auburn
4. Georgia vs 2. LSU
Well you got that completely wrong. LSU would play the winner of Baylor and Penn State in the 2nd round.
I'm not a proponent of a 16 team playoff but at least get your seedings correct.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:04 am to Jambalaya Sauce
16 is too many.
8 is the way to go.
8 is the way to go.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:05 am to Jambalaya Sauce
16 team playoff would be great. Shorten the season to 10 games per. Add more off weeks for each team. No bowl games. It would increase player safety and make the game more entertaining.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:06 am to Jambalaya Sauce
Nobody calling for 16. Thread is shite.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:08 am to Jambalaya Sauce
This season is a perfect candidate for a 4-team playoff field: 3 P5 undefeateds with very little difference between 2 and 3. Let the conference championships decide who the best 1-loss team is...or are...for #4.
Unless there are 5 undefeated teams in December, there is no need to ever increase the field from 4.
Unless there are 5 undefeated teams in December, there is no need to ever increase the field from 4.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:08 am to JohnnyU
So you are saying FBS football players are not as tough as FCS players. Hmmmm it has been practical for FCS for many years...o wait they actually have 24 team playoff. Then again it is not like they are in high school....o yeah high school state champs will have played 16 games. Roll eyes at these statements.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:09 am to Jambalaya Sauce
Honestly this year that 16 team playoff would yield great matchups
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:10 am to Jambalaya Sauce
The committee would simply alter the rankings to avoid that instead of being the legit "best 16" teams. They've already kind of proved that.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:11 am to GobyGator
FCS players don't have a future in football for the most part, which is why they're FCS.
An FCS ACL is worth considerably less than a CFP ACL. It's just the way it is.
An FCS ACL is worth considerably less than a CFP ACL. It's just the way it is.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:13 am to Jambalaya Sauce
16 team playoff would work perfect
5 P5 Champions
5 G5 Champions
6 Wildcard Teams (selected the committee)
1st round hosted by higher seed. Subsequent games (7 total) would be hosted by the seven big bowls (Rose, Sugar, Peach, Fiesta, Orange, Cotton and Citrus).
Outside that, retain the remaining 10 biggest/best bowls for twenty deserving teams.
Those bowls could be the Sun, Liberty, Gator, Music City, San Diego, a couple of the other FL bowls etc.
Reduce the regular season to either 10-11 games and abolish the Conference Championship games.
So we have covered everything.
True champion and we save some of the bowls for worthy teams.
5 P5 Champions
5 G5 Champions
6 Wildcard Teams (selected the committee)
1st round hosted by higher seed. Subsequent games (7 total) would be hosted by the seven big bowls (Rose, Sugar, Peach, Fiesta, Orange, Cotton and Citrus).
Outside that, retain the remaining 10 biggest/best bowls for twenty deserving teams.
Those bowls could be the Sun, Liberty, Gator, Music City, San Diego, a couple of the other FL bowls etc.
Reduce the regular season to either 10-11 games and abolish the Conference Championship games.
So we have covered everything.
True champion and we save some of the bowls for worthy teams.
This post was edited on 12/4/19 at 11:21 am
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:14 am to Jambalaya Sauce
If the playoff was that big it would include 5 conf champs at least and probably at least 2 G5 schools.
But I think they won’t go bigger than 8 ever.
And it would actually be easier to do than now.
Your gonna have 6 teams given to your 5 P5 champs and highest rated G5 champ more than likely. And if ND is undefeated or 1 loss they are in.. so then it’s just 1-2 teams your deciding on.
But I think they won’t go bigger than 8 ever.
And it would actually be easier to do than now.
Your gonna have 6 teams given to your 5 P5 champs and highest rated G5 champ more than likely. And if ND is undefeated or 1 loss they are in.. so then it’s just 1-2 teams your deciding on.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:15 am to Jambalaya Sauce
The most we should have is 6...
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:15 am to Jambalaya Sauce
Your bracket is set up wrong. Should be:
1. Ohio St./Iowa
2. Wisconsin/Florida
3. Utah/Alabama
4. Georgia/Oregon
5. Clemson/ Michigan
6. Oklahoma/Auburn
7. Baylor/PennSt.
8. LSU/Notre Dame
1. Ohio St./Iowa
2. Wisconsin/Florida
3. Utah/Alabama
4. Georgia/Oregon
5. Clemson/ Michigan
6. Oklahoma/Auburn
7. Baylor/PennSt.
8. LSU/Notre Dame
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:19 am to Mindenfan
screw the bowls. they are the horse and buggy of postseasons. end them all. 16 team playoff would rock! Let them host on campus until the final 4 and final. The next 16 can play in the NIT of football. The 16 after that in another NIT of football. Would yield much more compelling matchups and the regular season would still be very important due to seeding and hosting a home playoff game.
Posted on 12/4/19 at 11:25 am to VFL1800FPD
quote:
There are not 16 teams worthy of playing for a championship every year. I don't think there are 8 either. IMO it needs to stay at 4
You can say there's not 65/66 teams in college basketball worthy of playing for a championship, but look how much damn fun that is.
I say go to 8 teams and it'll be good.
It's not all about them all being worthy either. It's about watching good postseason games along the way.
Too many times, bowl matchups are bad.
This post was edited on 12/4/19 at 11:29 am
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News