re: Fields isn't ready

Sure, you make a good point but isn't Chaney's contract up next year?

He'll be re-upped this year. Don't believe me just watch....

Big
Jim
Funk you up (said)
Big Jim funk you up

quote:

---

3rd and 8 Ealy up the middle... Bobo's Bread and Butter

---

Or how about him calling QB draws designed for DJ with Joe T in the '05 UF game. That still grinds my gears after all these years.

Give it a rest?

I am just illustrating you are bloviating. Essentially your argument is:

“Well clearly the coaches must not be seeing...”

“He must not be ready or...”

You don’t know what you don’t know. I am not making a declarative statement about Justin Fields - you are. Just asking you to prove yours - and you cannot - it’s unprovable because Fields hasn’t gotten to play enough to form an intelligent opinion. Just admit you don’t know and I will drop it.

Fromm is allowed to make mistakes and turn the ball over with a fumble or interception but Fields isn't allowed to make any mistake ever.

Fields has never thrown an interception or lost a fumble. The same can't be said of Fromm. Fromm always gets a pass. Fields never does.

We don't know how Fields would perform if he had more opportunities. We do know that Fromm is a damn good player. Practice observers whose time isn't restricted have been reporting that Fields is a superior passer.

I hope that Kirby is handling the QB position in the best way but I doubt that he is. In and out for single plays but not allowing Fields to pass seems stupid.

Bravo my friend. You get it. Too bad others don’t.

quote:

---

Fields has never thrown an interception or lost a fumble. The same can't be said of Fromm. Fromm always gets a pass. Fields never does.

---

Well, Fromm plays 95% of the time so of course he's going to make some mistakes. And how can you say that Fields doesn't get a pass if he hasn't had an interception or fumble?

I could have worded that better. I meant that Fields gets this heavy criticism that seems unwarranted given that he has never turned the ball over.

Fromm is ineffective at times. Fields will also be ineffective at times. Fields is on such a short leash that I don't know how he would perform with a reasonable opportunity.

99% of high school players are average to good players. .99% are very good, and that last .01% are 4* and 5* players. Those players almost all excel because they are far better physically than their opponents, not because of their football knowledge.
When they come to a top level school like Georgia, nearly every 4* and 5* needs their freshman year just to learn how to play at that level. Fromm didn't need that as much as Fields apparently does. Even Tua needed his freshman year to learn or he would have been starting by mid-season last year.
Give the coaches a break. They see every practice and every QB room meeting. I think they know when a player is ready to get real time.

If Fields were the better passer in practice then Kirby would be purposely not playing the better QB. Unless Fromm's handoffs are just so spectacular they outweigh his inferior passing. I can read just fine. You said that he's the better passer in practice. Not me. My retort was asking you what you've seen in the games that would support he's the better passer. Why can he can he only make one read in the games before tucking and looking to run? The better passer would be able to make more than one read. Nothing that has happened, when it actually matters, that would lead anyone to believe he's the better passer. Unless you want to believe third hand I formation. I trust what I can see with my actual eyes.

Stop living in a fantasy world and come back down to earth. The weather is fine.