Started By
Message

re: Ranking SEC QBs

Posted on 9/30/26 at 9:46 am to
Posted by RTRnFlorida
Member since Mar 2024
3906 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 9:46 am to
Gunner should be Tier 1. Dude has grit and emotional intelligence. Game manager yes, but nobody from Georgia says… ahh man.. it’s almost kickoff.. what bonehead stupid arse play will he make today. He’s consistent for sure
This post was edited on 9/30/26 at 9:48 am
Posted by Demosthenian
Zetto, Granite Bowl, & points btwn
Member since Sep 2021
1069 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 10:12 am to
quote:

I’d take Byrum Brown and Faizon over Leavitt, Manning, or Curtis at the moment
Curtis outplayed Brown last Sat. Have you watched him? He may have the best pocket presence outside of Trinidad. Still just green though. He’s the real deal
Posted by Demosthenian
Zetto, Granite Bowl, & points btwn
Member since Sep 2021
1069 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 10:20 am to
quote:

Gunner should be Tier 1. Dude has grit and emotional intelligence. Game manager yes, but nobody from Georgia says… ahh man.. it’s almost kickoff.. what bonehead stupid arse play will he make today. He’s consistent for sure
No disagreement about your assessment of him. Plus he actually has explicitly won us a game putting the team on his back (TN ‘25).

That said he’s a slow passer, underthrows receivers, throws contested balls, doesn’t have the best pocket presence, has a tough time reading past his 2nd target, tends to stare down receivers, doesn’t audible well at the line, and generally doesn’t have the upside ceiling that Trinidad, Keelon, and Kamario have.

Is he a perfect fit for Kirby and UGA? Yes. Does he execute Bobo’s offense better than anyone else on the list could? Yes.
Would you pick him first on your sandlot team / would he command a higher NIL package than the guys above him? No.

I love Gunner, but I’m also astute enough to see what I see and call it fair vs. the other talented (and seemingly equally well-grounded) young men in tier I
Posted by Zgeo
Baja Oklahoma
Member since Jul 2021
4727 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 10:27 am to
Mateer is too high
Posted by Cimarron
Member since Jun 2024
1697 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 10:30 am to
quote:

Can you make a negative tier for Mateer for us?


$3mil per year. Wasted.
Posted by Prof
Member since Jun 2013
46062 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 10:34 am to
quote:

Faizon OTOH just couldn’t get anything going vs. Texas, but I thought he weathered the pressure well. Can he actually execute to lead the offense against a more attackable D? Will go a long says towards defining his ceiling.


Pretty fair assessment.
Posted by southpawcock
Member since Oct 2015
18329 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 10:38 am to
If Sellers is not in the last tier, then I'm really not understanding your criteria.
Posted by Demosthenian
Zetto, Granite Bowl, & points btwn
Member since Sep 2021
1069 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 10:42 am to
quote:

If Sellers is not in the last tier, then I'm really not understanding your criteria.
As I led with, just a best assessment, I’ve no conviction of those I’ve not watched.

Would you rather have KJ Jackson, Kenny Minchey, or Marcel Reed running plays for SC? Interested if so, based on what factors you see in them.

Sellers historically was capable of leading and playing with confidence. Mateer is similar but he’s just totally lost it. Has Sellers lost it also?
Posted by Quicksilver
Poker Room
Member since Jan 2013
13758 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 11:12 am to
I do not disagree with this list. May put Kamario over Keelon.
Posted by TexasOnTop
Member since Nov 2023
7077 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 11:17 am to
quote:

4. Gunner


He played 1 good defense this year and had a 56% completion percentage. Come on now.

quote:

7. Leavitt


This kid had not 1, not 2, but 3 interceptions against LT in the first half of their game.

Posted by Demosthenian
Zetto, Granite Bowl, & points btwn
Member since Sep 2021
1069 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 11:30 am to
quote:

Gunner He played 1 good defense this year and had a 56% completion percentage. Come on now.
Who would you put ahead of him and why? Philo’s not been asked to do anything, and he hasn’t played a D as good as Stockton did vs. OU. Stockton has a much deeper body of work proving his ability to lead and win. I also wouldn’t read too much into one quarter of football when up 28-0, then 31-6, as UGA explored some other formations and play calls to get in some deep ball reps (despite the WR coverage being good). He was 9/9 with a TD by mid-2Q (9/11 at halftime)

quote:

Leavitt This kid had not 1, not 2, but 3 interceptions against LT in the first half of their game.
I’d support flipping Manning and Leavitt. Manning’s at least won some games. All the LSU fans have come in late and downvoted me anyway for even putting him in tier III
This post was edited on 9/30/26 at 11:32 am
Posted by Quicksilver
Poker Room
Member since Jan 2013
13758 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 11:49 am to
quote:

Manning’s at least won some games.


Wins are not a QB stat.
Posted by kajunman
Member since Dec 2015
10164 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 11:59 am to
Philo is too high.
Posted by kajunman
Member since Dec 2015
10164 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 12:01 pm to
quote:

This kid had not 1, not 2, but 3 interceptions against LT in the first half of their game.

Not all ints were his fault either. People forget Leavitt didn't get to practice with the team in March.
Posted by thunderbird1100
GSU Eagles fan
Member since Oct 2007
72994 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 12:08 pm to
quote:

This kid had not 1, not 2, but 3 interceptions against LT in the first half of their game.



Leavitt only has 1 turnover worthy play all season per PFF, which is obviously among the best in the SEC

I know you havent watched every LSU game, but I have; he has had incredibly bad luck when it comes to either drop leading to INT or tipped passes leading to INT

His passing left something to be desired then A&M happened where he stopped trying to run every other time and just relaxed and threw the football and it was a beautiful thing. TBD how the rest of the year goes but if he has the passing thing figured out, he can easily be among the top in the conference. His running ability is obviously already top tier.
This post was edited on 9/30/26 at 12:10 pm
Posted by BevoBucks
H-town
Member since Dec 2022
7163 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 12:15 pm to
A LOT of sunk costs from #7 on down.
Posted by DeathByTossDive226
Member since Sep 2026
1423 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 12:18 pm to
Pretty good list.

Leavitt has a chance to work himself into tier II, if he builds on the A&M 2H performance.

If he regresses back to Ole Miss/LaTech levels, I think we lose 2-3 more games & Clark potentially overtakes him.

Hoping for the former.
Posted by thunderbird1100
GSU Eagles fan
Member since Oct 2007
72994 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 12:21 pm to
PFF grades of the 16 SEC starters so far through 4 weeks

1. Russell - 91.9
2. Stockton - 91.4
3. LEavitt - 89.4
4. Brown - 86.5
5. Chambliss - 85.0
6. Simmons - 82.4
7. Philo - 81.3
8. Taylor - 79.1
9. Manning - 74.6
10. Sellers - 68.6
11. Jackson - 68.4
12. Curtis - 67.9
13. Brandon - 58.5
14. Mateer - 58.0
15. Reed - 57.6
16. Minchey - 56.2

Obviously level of competition will have a great effect on this with some unbalanced schedules so far (some SEC teams have only played 1 easy game, others have played 2 or even 3), but as the weeks go on that will lessen by a lot.
This post was edited on 9/30/26 at 12:23 pm
Posted by Madmax77
mandeville
Member since Dec 2015
237 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 4:50 pm to
you're piss drunk at 8 AM? wtf man
Posted by FoTownBam
Foley Al
Member since Oct 2023
4949 posts
Posted on 9/30/26 at 9:25 pm to
quote:

you're piss drunk at 8 AM? wtf man

Is that wrong?
Page 1 2
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 2 of 2Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•Twitter