
Started By
Message

Ranking SEC QBs
Posted on 9/30/26 at 12:54 am
Posted on 9/30/26 at 12:54 am
More or less accurate through Week 4? Based on the film, not just yardage lists or QBR ranks.
Tier I
1. Trinidad
2. Keelon
3. Kamario
Tier II
4. Gunner
5. Simmons
6. Philo
Tier III
7. Manning
8. Curtis
9. Leavitt
Tier IV
10. Byrum Brown
11. Faizon Brandon
12. Sellers
13. Minchey
Tier IV
14. KJ Jackson
15. Mateer
16. Reed
Tier I
1. Trinidad
2. Keelon
3. Kamario
Tier II
4. Gunner
5. Simmons
6. Philo
Tier III
7. Manning
8. Curtis
9. Leavitt
Tier IV
10. Byrum Brown
11. Faizon Brandon
12. Sellers
13. Minchey
Tier IV
14. KJ Jackson
15. Mateer
16. Reed
This post was edited on 9/30/26 at 11:21 am
Posted on 9/30/26 at 12:57 am to Demosthenian
Reed and Mateer are the worst.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 1:16 am to Demosthenian
Pretty good list overall.
Only
Change I’d make is switch faizon with sellers
Sellers is regressing big time the past two seasons while brown and faizon both theoretically could get better
Only
Change I’d make is switch faizon with sellers
Sellers is regressing big time the past two seasons while brown and faizon both theoretically could get better
Posted on 9/30/26 at 6:47 am to Demosthenian
Is this with or without our running game working?
Posted on 9/30/26 at 6:50 am to Demosthenian
Would have helped to put team beside names.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 6:53 am to Demosthenian
Minchey statistically is better than you’re giving him credit for but otherwise I don’t see much to argue with there.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 7:03 am to Demosthenian
Trinidad is in his own tier, but shouldn’t still be playing college ball.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 7:28 am to theCAW
Sounds like some fair quibbles with the bottom bracket.
I’m really interested to watch Auburn-Tennessee this wknd, and the match within that of which QB can re-write their season-to-date performance.
Byrum’s making too much $$ to settle for his current execution quality, and this is a key early career game for Golesh.
Faizon OTOH just couldn’t get anything going vs. Texas, but I thought he weathered the pressure well. Can he actually execute to lead the offense against a more attackable D? Will go a long way towards defining his ceiling.
I’m really interested to watch Auburn-Tennessee this wknd, and the match within that of which QB can re-write their season-to-date performance.
Byrum’s making too much $$ to settle for his current execution quality, and this is a key early career game for Golesh.
Faizon OTOH just couldn’t get anything going vs. Texas, but I thought he weathered the pressure well. Can he actually execute to lead the offense against a more attackable D? Will go a long way towards defining his ceiling.
This post was edited on 9/30/26 at 10:36 am
Posted on 9/30/26 at 7:53 am to Demosthenian
Can you make a negative tier for Mateer for us?
Posted on 9/30/26 at 8:03 am to Demosthenian
Stockton needs to be in the first tier. I know competition hasn't been that tough, but he leads the league in QB rating.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 8:08 am to Demosthenian
I’d take Byrum Brown and Faizon over Leavitt, Manning, or Curtis at the moment
Posted on 9/30/26 at 8:24 am to Gimme Vaughn
quote:
Can you make a negative tier for Mateer for us?
He's Tier 1...
For the other team.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 8:34 am to Demosthenian
This list will look different in the tier 2 category very soon.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 8:35 am to SEC Doctor
Lets see how he does vs Florida.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 8:41 am to Demosthenian
Tiers should be:
1. Our guy is a bad arse
2. Our guy is pretty good.
3. Our guy is ok
4. shite
5. Mother fricking goddamn dogshit
6. Mateer.
1. Our guy is a bad arse
2. Our guy is pretty good.
3. Our guy is ok
4. shite
5. Mother fricking goddamn dogshit
6. Mateer.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 8:44 am to Demosthenian
QBR doesn't see it that way.
Posted on 9/30/26 at 9:27 am to Demosthenian
I think it is a fair assessment. I was thinking about the QBs...where they are now, and opportunities for improvement. So, I thought I'd add how many starts they have under their belt so far to try and gauge potential growth from experience as the year progresses.
In order of number of college games played in:
Chambliss - 42
Mateer - 40
Brown - 39
Sellers - 31
Reed - 31
Leavitt - 28
Manning - 28
Stockton - 22
Simmons - 17
Taylor - 11
Philo - 11
Minchey - 11
Jackson - 10
Russell - 6
Brandon - 4
Curtis - 4
In order of number of starts:
Brown - 36
Chambliss - 35
Sellers - 28
Mateer - 28
Leavitt - 24
Reed - 21
Manning - 19
Stockton - 18
Taylor - 6
Philo - 5
Simmons - 5
Brandon - 4
Jackson - 4
Minchey - 4
Taylor - 4
Curtis - 2
quote:
Tier I
1. Trinidad - 35 (16 at Ferris State and 19 at Ole Miss - Saw action in 42)
2. Keelon - 4 (but saw action in 6)
3. Kamario - 6 (but saw action in 11)
Tier II
4. Gunner - 18 (but saw action in 22)
5. Simmons - 5 (but saw action in 17)
6. Philo - 5 (but saw action in 11)
Tier III
7. Leavitt - 24 (but saw action in 28)
8. Curtis - 2 (but saw action in 4)
9. Manning - 19 (but saw action in 28)
Tier IV
10. Byrum Brown - 36 (but saw action in 39)
11. Faizon Brandon - 4 (saw action in 4)
12. Sellers - 28 (but saw action in 31)
13. Minchey - 4 (but saw action in 11)
Tier IV
14. KJ Jackson - 4 (but saw action in 10)
15. Mateer - 28 (but saw action in 40)
16. Reed - 21 (but saw action in 31)
In order of number of college games played in:
Chambliss - 42
Mateer - 40
Brown - 39
Sellers - 31
Reed - 31
Leavitt - 28
Manning - 28
Stockton - 22
Simmons - 17
Taylor - 11
Philo - 11
Minchey - 11
Jackson - 10
Russell - 6
Brandon - 4
Curtis - 4
In order of number of starts:
Brown - 36
Chambliss - 35
Sellers - 28
Mateer - 28
Leavitt - 24
Reed - 21
Manning - 19
Stockton - 18
Taylor - 6
Philo - 5
Simmons - 5
Brandon - 4
Jackson - 4
Minchey - 4
Taylor - 4
Curtis - 2
Posted on 9/30/26 at 9:30 am to Demosthenian
Hard to put Simmons in tier 2 with his brain dead final drive last week. Tier 3.

Popular
Back to top

23









