Who would you rather have as your HC: Kirby Smart or Jimbo Fisher?

Kirby Smart.
He’s a lot younger for one...

Kirby.

He runs a good defense and his offense will be based on whoever he hires as OC meaning a bad offense can always be fixed.

Jimbo runs an outdated offense and doesn't outscheme anyone and it doesn't seem like he will ever change.

I'm curious how Aggies would feel about him if he were just their QB coach and OC.

Jimbo. He can develop a QB and you ain’t winning a championship without a good QB

Kirby, he's young, he'll win championships, and unlike Jimbo, he doesn't look like an Oompa Loompa.

Jimbo at his best is better than Kirby at his best. But you can't ignore that Jimbo at his worst is a total trainwreck. He completely destroyed the FSU program and had no idea how to sustain the success he had built. I'd take Kirby because at his worst he is still contending for the East.

Fisher

Fischer.

Jimbo. He’s had 4 QBs drafted in the first round and won a national title. Didn’t FSU win 29 games in a row? That’s impressive. Not to mention how he’s made A&M relevant. Kirby was gifted a way easier path to success. Kirby always has Georgia in the mix but just can’t close the deal. I’d trust Fisher with the keys to my program before Smart.

Kirby would intentionally torpedo our program since he bleeds red and black.
I still wonder if Jimbo would leave for the NFL. Don't think you have to worry about that with Kirby.

Smart. I would want a great defense