
Started By
Message
History Discussion Thread
Posted on 8/24/26 at 7:18 pm
Posted on 8/24/26 at 7:18 pm
I know its not football but hey, lets have fun.
Diego, Kerrygold, and Amarillo I belive we left off here.
Diego said this "The thing that created the Prussian/German war machine was the existential terror of a French army rolling over the Rhine.
Ultimately, the reason France got rolled over in WW2 was decided by the cementing of Belgium as an independent state. Belgium is basically a design feature by the rest of Europe to keep France from being able to annex and fortify the Belgian low countries thus changing the paths for invasion from the North into France.
I'm a bit less dismissive of France as a military power. However the inability to solidly claim and hold the low countries is their real failure but, in fairness, the whole of Europe was determined to never let that geographical fortress France stand for long."
Amarillo said this "Gonna have to disagree with you on why France got their asses kicked by the Germans. The French did little to change their mindset on warfare from WWI and WWII. They assumed that massive fortifications (e.g. Maginot Line) would make all the difference.
It never dawned on them those fortifications would be breached and/or flanked and because of that, they had no real answer to German blitzkrieg and rapid advances of armor and troops through those breaches.
Moreover, German weaponry was superior. Better tanks, better small arms, better artillery, better aircraft. Better trained men and superior leadership."
My thoughts: I think you're both half right. Amarillo, the "better weapons" part is iffy. The French and British had more tanks in May 1940, and the Char B1 and Somua S35 outgunned and out-armored most of what the Germans fielded. The real German edges were radios in every tank, a Luftwaffe built for close support, and concentrating their armor into panzer divisions instead of spreading it out in infantry support. The Maginot Line also did its job: it shut the direct route and pushed the Germans into Belgium, which is exactly what it was for. The failure was the Dyle plan sending the best French armies deep into Belgium, leaving the Ardennes hinge to reserve divisions, and keeping no strategic reserve at all. Once Guderian was over the Meuse at Sedan, a headquarters with no radio and a 1918 mindset just couldn't react at the speed required.
Diego, you're right that Belgian neutrality in 1936 mattered. It killed joint planning and is a big reason the Allied plan was a headlong rush north with a thin hinge behind it. But France fought 1870 and 1914 with the same map, and in 1914 it held. What changed by 1940 wasn't the geography, it was the French army's ability to move and decide. Doctrine and command lost that campaign, not walls, weapons, or borders. Love this.
Diego, Kerrygold, and Amarillo I belive we left off here.
Diego said this "The thing that created the Prussian/German war machine was the existential terror of a French army rolling over the Rhine.
Ultimately, the reason France got rolled over in WW2 was decided by the cementing of Belgium as an independent state. Belgium is basically a design feature by the rest of Europe to keep France from being able to annex and fortify the Belgian low countries thus changing the paths for invasion from the North into France.
I'm a bit less dismissive of France as a military power. However the inability to solidly claim and hold the low countries is their real failure but, in fairness, the whole of Europe was determined to never let that geographical fortress France stand for long."
Amarillo said this "Gonna have to disagree with you on why France got their asses kicked by the Germans. The French did little to change their mindset on warfare from WWI and WWII. They assumed that massive fortifications (e.g. Maginot Line) would make all the difference.
It never dawned on them those fortifications would be breached and/or flanked and because of that, they had no real answer to German blitzkrieg and rapid advances of armor and troops through those breaches.
Moreover, German weaponry was superior. Better tanks, better small arms, better artillery, better aircraft. Better trained men and superior leadership."
My thoughts: I think you're both half right. Amarillo, the "better weapons" part is iffy. The French and British had more tanks in May 1940, and the Char B1 and Somua S35 outgunned and out-armored most of what the Germans fielded. The real German edges were radios in every tank, a Luftwaffe built for close support, and concentrating their armor into panzer divisions instead of spreading it out in infantry support. The Maginot Line also did its job: it shut the direct route and pushed the Germans into Belgium, which is exactly what it was for. The failure was the Dyle plan sending the best French armies deep into Belgium, leaving the Ardennes hinge to reserve divisions, and keeping no strategic reserve at all. Once Guderian was over the Meuse at Sedan, a headquarters with no radio and a 1918 mindset just couldn't react at the speed required.
Diego, you're right that Belgian neutrality in 1936 mattered. It killed joint planning and is a big reason the Allied plan was a headlong rush north with a thin hinge behind it. But France fought 1870 and 1914 with the same map, and in 1914 it held. What changed by 1940 wasn't the geography, it was the French army's ability to move and decide. Doctrine and command lost that campaign, not walls, weapons, or borders. Love this.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 7:33 pm to CrimsonBoz
We didn't have equality in those times. if we had women in the war. We would have won in September 1944.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 7:34 pm to UASports23
WWII history is the best. I mean those boys > 
Posted on 8/24/26 at 7:44 pm to CrimsonBoz
I'm not a huge millitary history buff, but I always thought that France's failures in WW2 were an extension of their failures in WW1: ego.
They were convinced that their superior fighting spirit would be the key to dominating WW1 battlefields and they sent all their best troops to basically be slaughtered by modern weaponry and tactics. So by the time trench warfare set the lines they had already lost their best troops and on-field leadership.
So WW2 comes and they basically are thinking the same thing. They had beat Germany's western advance solidly before the treaty of Versailles and thought that was the best Germany was capable of. So they hunkered down with a bunch of defensive fortifications and then Germany just went around them.
More posted this to be corrected as I'm more knowledgeable about the politics and political theory of the early 20th century as opposed to the millitary history.
They were convinced that their superior fighting spirit would be the key to dominating WW1 battlefields and they sent all their best troops to basically be slaughtered by modern weaponry and tactics. So by the time trench warfare set the lines they had already lost their best troops and on-field leadership.
So WW2 comes and they basically are thinking the same thing. They had beat Germany's western advance solidly before the treaty of Versailles and thought that was the best Germany was capable of. So they hunkered down with a bunch of defensive fortifications and then Germany just went around them.
More posted this to be corrected as I'm more knowledgeable about the politics and political theory of the early 20th century as opposed to the millitary history.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 8:10 pm to Kashmir
Truly a terrible but fascinating time in history. Nothing but respect for the greatest generation. They lived through some terrible times but we are all blessed for their sacrifices.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 8:12 pm to Diego Ricardo
I hate to hate on France too much. They saved us a time or two.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 8:21 pm to McGregor
Their reputation as cheese eating surrender monkeys isn't very deserved. For much of its history as a geopolitical entity France was the military boogeyman of Europe.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 8:26 pm to McGregor
I think the Marquis de Lafayette is a very interesting historical figure. A young French officer in Washington's cadre during our Revolution. He was a central figure in the "good" part of the first French Revolution. In his later days, he helped assure the Revolution of 1830 did not have a repeat of the terrors before offering the throne to Louis-Phillippe.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 9:01 pm to Diego Ricardo
quote:
the Marquis de Lafayette is a very interesting historical figure
Absolutely. He is the real life Batman. Rich orphan who spent his fortune fighting the bad guys.
Incredible story on that guy.
And to the point of WW2 France paying for the sins of WW1 France, it can also be argued that WW1 France was set in motion from their supporting the USA in our revolution.
So much of that history is more connected than we are taught and the story of the Marquis De Lafeyette touches on so many parts of it. If you start with his father and then go until MDL is an old man, then you can get an interesting perspective on WW1.
But, personally, I'm in this camp nowadays. "All wars are bankers' wars" - Smedley Butler.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 9:34 pm to SECSolomonGrundy
France dropped out at the end of WWI and Great Britain at the end of WWII. The U. S. stepped up their game after WWII because of this and we been paying ever since.
Posted on 8/24/26 at 11:49 pm to CrimsonBoz
quote:
My thoughts: I think you're both half right. Amarillo, the "better weapons" part is iffy. The French and British had more tanks in May 1940, and the Char B1 and Somua S35 outgunned and out-armored most of what the Germans fielded. The real German edges were radios in every tank, a Luftwaffe built for close support, and concentrating their armor into panzer divisions instead of spreading it out in infantry support. The Maginot Line also did its job: it shut the direct route and pushed the Germans into Belgium, which is exactly what it was for. The failure was the Dyle plan sending the best French armies deep into Belgium, leaving the Ardennes hinge to reserve divisions, and keeping no strategic reserve at all. Once Guderian was over the Meuse at Sedan, a headquarters with no radio and a 1918 mindset just couldn't react at the speed required
Maurice Gamelin CinC and General Alphonse Georges commander of the northeast front got totally out played on strategy and deception. It was a master class on modern warfare by brilliant tactical planning by General Erich von Manstein. He engineered the concept of the plan knowing exactly what Gamelin would do.
Without going to deep in explaining this I’ll cut it short by saying it was probably the worst frick up a European General ever ordered. It only took those Kraut bastard’s 10 days to reach the channel.
The Allied armies in the north were now largely cut off from the rest of France.
It was over that fast and that quick, Europe was lost. The French had more than enough forces capable of repelling Jerry. What they didn’t have was generals that studied the art of war on a level Ole Fritz took it too.
I think ppl often forget how powerful a fighting force the third reich engineered. It’s pretty damn scary what they almost accomplished considering how beaten and destroyed Germany was after the first world war. 20yrs later they came damn close of conquering the world. And in return it showed us how to become the most lethal military force ever created known to mankind. Strange how things evolve sometimes and shapes the world
Posted on 8/25/26 at 7:05 am to hwyman108
I still contend if the Allies (particularly the French) hadn’t insisted on humiliating and crippling Germany with reparations after WWI, the Weimar Republic might have made it thru the Great Depression and most likely, Nazism probably wouldn’t have taken root.
In no way, shape or form am I justifying Hitler and the Nazis but if you and your children are literally starving, and Hitler says, “If you follow me, I will feed your children and we can get off our knees as a nation.”, most people would accept that offer.
Yes, the decision to accept and follow Hitler was made by the Germans but Allies made the decision easier with the harsh Treaty of Versailles.
In no way, shape or form am I justifying Hitler and the Nazis but if you and your children are literally starving, and Hitler says, “If you follow me, I will feed your children and we can get off our knees as a nation.”, most people would accept that offer.
Yes, the decision to accept and follow Hitler was made by the Germans but Allies made the decision easier with the harsh Treaty of Versailles.
Posted on 8/25/26 at 7:16 am to Fells
France's miscalculation leading into WW1 was not ego. Every major combatant headed into 1914 had drawn the exactly wrong conclusions from the Russo-Japanese War. In that conflict, the smaller Japanese army managed to inflict a severe defeat on the Russians at Mukden by attacking and keeping the pressure on until the Russian army fell apart. European observers did not take into account (and here ego certainly did come into play) that the Japanese, despite being outnumbered, were better equipped, trained, and led than the Russians were. Instead they concluded that modern offensive firepower was so overwhelming that, when properly applied, armies could not stand against it. The key to victory was a quick, sharp attack that concentrated your own fire before the enemy could do the same. Your troops simply had to be willing to endure the heavy casualties they would sustain until the attack hit home and the enemy's line collapsed. It was not only France who believed this - all the major powers, including Germany, did. Remember that the German plan to win the war was not to dig trenches and wait to be attacked, but was rather a quick, sharp offensive designed to defeat the French in one blow. It just so happened that the German plan to attack in a place the French wouldn't expect was superior to the French plan to attack directly into the teeth of the strongest German defenses. The war's subsequent transition into a years-long defensive stalemate was foreseen by no one and was driven by realties at the tactical level, not by some overarching plan to build a fortress from the North Sea to the Alps.
French planning leading into WW2 was based off their experience in WW1. They expected another primarily defensive war and discounted the practicality of quick, deep offensives. The Allied advances in the Hundred Days had been built around methodical mass infantry advances supported by large numbers of tanks spread out to reduce enemy strong points. This is in contrast to the Germans, who in the First World War had never focused much on tanks but whose success in the Spring 1918 offensives had been based around the use of Stosstruppen - small groups of elite troops whose mission was to quickly penetrate deep behind enemy lines ahead of the main attack, sowing chaos and confusion and ignoring strong points, leaving them for the slower-moving mass infantry formations to deal with (sound familiar?). The German Blitzkrieg attacks in WW2 were Stosstruppen tactics taken to the next level by incorporating mass tank formations and close airpower support, but even so German military planners did not account for the super-deep penetrations achieved by their Panzer formations in 1940 any more than the Allies had. These were suggested by the local commanders of those formations once they realized that they had driven completely through Allied lines and that there was nothing standing between them and the North Sea coast, and then pushed their own commanders to be allowed to go as far as they could as fast as they could. The German High Command was torn over whether or not to let them do this and was in a state of high anxiety, all the way up to Hitler himself, until it became clear that the gambit had worked and, rather than cutting off and destroying the overstretched Panzer forces, the Allied armies were falling apart.
French planning leading into WW2 was based off their experience in WW1. They expected another primarily defensive war and discounted the practicality of quick, deep offensives. The Allied advances in the Hundred Days had been built around methodical mass infantry advances supported by large numbers of tanks spread out to reduce enemy strong points. This is in contrast to the Germans, who in the First World War had never focused much on tanks but whose success in the Spring 1918 offensives had been based around the use of Stosstruppen - small groups of elite troops whose mission was to quickly penetrate deep behind enemy lines ahead of the main attack, sowing chaos and confusion and ignoring strong points, leaving them for the slower-moving mass infantry formations to deal with (sound familiar?). The German Blitzkrieg attacks in WW2 were Stosstruppen tactics taken to the next level by incorporating mass tank formations and close airpower support, but even so German military planners did not account for the super-deep penetrations achieved by their Panzer formations in 1940 any more than the Allies had. These were suggested by the local commanders of those formations once they realized that they had driven completely through Allied lines and that there was nothing standing between them and the North Sea coast, and then pushed their own commanders to be allowed to go as far as they could as fast as they could. The German High Command was torn over whether or not to let them do this and was in a state of high anxiety, all the way up to Hitler himself, until it became clear that the gambit had worked and, rather than cutting off and destroying the overstretched Panzer forces, the Allied armies were falling apart.
This post was edited on 8/25/26 at 8:43 am
Posted on 8/25/26 at 7:23 am to SECSolomonGrundy
quote:
it can also be argued that WW1 France was set in motion from their supporting the USA in our revolution.
No. WW1 France was set in motion by the French experience in the Franco-Prussian War, which was set in motion by the Prussian experience in the Napoleonic Wars, which was set in motion by the French Revolution. You could say that one of the indirect causes of the French Revolution was the French monarchy bankrupting itself supporting the fledgling US in the AWI, but that's about as much of a connection as you can make.
Posted on 8/25/26 at 8:45 am to TheTideMustRoll
quote:
No. WW1 France was set in motion by the French experience in the Franco-Prussian War, which was set in motion by the Prussian experience in the Napoleonic Wars, which was set in motion by the French Revolution. You could say that one of the indirect causes of the French Revolution was the French monarchy bankrupting itself supporting the fledgling US in the AWI, but that's about as much of a connection as you can make.
And the American Revolution owes much to the experience of the English Revolution that was an offshoot of the Thirty Years War that assured the HRE would never become a modern state thus setting the stage for the Prussian-led modern German state centuries later.
It’s all connected somewhat if you look hard enough.
Posted on 8/25/26 at 9:12 am to Diego Ricardo
quote:
It’s all connected somewhat if you look hard enough.
Oh, absolutely. History is a giant web of interconnectedness and we are just isolating various strands of it. But some strands are more closely and directly connected than others.
Posted on 8/25/26 at 9:30 am to CrimsonBoz
I want to love history, but it's all a lie.
So, it's really hard unless you want to devote yourself to this and go ultra deep on single topics to really even begin to have a clue. And even if you do understand X, Y or Z as totally accurate, you still totally miss the context of the time people lived in.
History is among the most important things ever. That is why it is totally gate-kept.
So, it's really hard unless you want to devote yourself to this and go ultra deep on single topics to really even begin to have a clue. And even if you do understand X, Y or Z as totally accurate, you still totally miss the context of the time people lived in.
History is among the most important things ever. That is why it is totally gate-kept.
Posted on 8/25/26 at 9:43 am to m2pro
In the final analysis, attempting to find truth is better than resigning yourself to complete ignorance even if your endeavor falls short of total enlightenment.
Posted on 8/25/26 at 10:00 am to Diego Ricardo
quote:
In the final analysis, attempting to find truth is better than resigning yourself to complete ignorance even if your endeavor falls short of total enlightenment.
Maybe so, but I guess my point is I think my time is best spent on other more fruitful endeavors. I admit, I have a deeply curious nature about history, but I also just know that it has all be meticulously curated for us. You're just seeing me be sore about it.
This post was edited on 8/25/26 at 10:01 am
Latest Alabama News

Popular
Back to top


4










