
Started By
Message
re: Toodle
Posted on 11/12/26 at 7:28 am to GoCrazyAuburn
Posted on 11/12/26 at 7:28 am to GoCrazyAuburn
Ever play the position with 22 players on the field?
Don’t need an answer, I know you haven’t. You go one step further. To train decent future Officials, you start with 8-10 year olds on the field. The reason? You can see over everyone on the field. Doesn’t make you a good official, gives you a place to start. 22 players on the field is confusion. You learn zones and where to be and at what time.
I joined unexpected. My first scrimmage, supervised by the two most experienced Officials in the Association. Two plays in….the most experienced guy asked “How many years were you a QB and what was your last record?” “Four years and the last record was 10-0 Champions.” “You’ll be doing JV High School mid season. But you better get off the anticipation jump…..someone will run a double pass and leave you flat footed.” They were my mentors from that moment on.
Don’t need an answer, I know you haven’t. You go one step further. To train decent future Officials, you start with 8-10 year olds on the field. The reason? You can see over everyone on the field. Doesn’t make you a good official, gives you a place to start. 22 players on the field is confusion. You learn zones and where to be and at what time.
I joined unexpected. My first scrimmage, supervised by the two most experienced Officials in the Association. Two plays in….the most experienced guy asked “How many years were you a QB and what was your last record?” “Four years and the last record was 10-0 Champions.” “You’ll be doing JV High School mid season. But you better get off the anticipation jump…..someone will run a double pass and leave you flat footed.” They were my mentors from that moment on.
Posted on 11/12/26 at 9:44 am to bluedragon
I'm very confused at what that post is in response to 
Posted on 11/12/26 at 10:32 am to GoCrazyAuburn
Read the sentence.
Good QB’s are few and far between. Those who criticize the most and loudest….likely never played the position in COMBAT…..
Handicaps not recognized when critiquing a QB.
1. No clue on the play called. If you don’t what was called, How do know where and who to look for? Camera view is elevated…not what the field actually is. Always get a kick at…..he missed 16 people wide open!
Really? You had his view looking through rushers?
But had an elevated camera view the QB should have seen….BS.
Good QB’s are few and far between. Those who criticize the most and loudest….likely never played the position in COMBAT…..
Handicaps not recognized when critiquing a QB.
1. No clue on the play called. If you don’t what was called, How do know where and who to look for? Camera view is elevated…not what the field actually is. Always get a kick at…..he missed 16 people wide open!
Really? You had his view looking through rushers?
But had an elevated camera view the QB should have seen….BS.
Posted on 11/12/26 at 10:57 am to bluedragon
I did read the sentence, then you went on a diatribe about referees, thus the confusion
Have I been? I think I've made some very fair criticisms of him and the post you responded to was merely a counter argument in a discussion about the value of his scrambling. I don't think I've made any critique that is overly critical of him, especially in light of our shite OL play. And to the originaly question, yes I have played the position, not at a level that really matters but I've also not said anything that isn't a very base level analysis. But even if I hadn't, there has been nothing i've criticized on his play this year that hasn't been pointed out by those that have at the highest level. His timing and anticipation have not been good this year, that really isn't up for debate.
That's all well and good in a vacuum, but when the problem persists over the long term of the season, you can't use these as the excuses. Are these things that are factors? Absolutely, but everyone deals with them. Has our piss poor OL play impacted how he sees the field? I don't think anyone would argue otherwise.
However, we are not the only offense that deals with these factors, so when we are not overcoming them, it can only point to two things, poor coaching/play calling/giving a single read, or poor execution by the ones on the field. I've been critical of all of those things. However, if the play call itself produces viable options and the player executing the play doesn't get the ball there consistently, that is fair to be criticized over.
I think it is folly though to say someone can't criticize the QB for holding onto the ball too long and gets sacked, when there are open receivers, since you "don't know the play call". He very well may not have seen the receiver, but that doesn't actually counter any point I've made, in fact it is in support of it.
quote:
Those who criticize the most and loudest
Have I been? I think I've made some very fair criticisms of him and the post you responded to was merely a counter argument in a discussion about the value of his scrambling. I don't think I've made any critique that is overly critical of him, especially in light of our shite OL play. And to the originaly question, yes I have played the position, not at a level that really matters but I've also not said anything that isn't a very base level analysis. But even if I hadn't, there has been nothing i've criticized on his play this year that hasn't been pointed out by those that have at the highest level. His timing and anticipation have not been good this year, that really isn't up for debate.
quote:
Handicaps not recognized when critiquing a QB.
1. No clue on the play called. If you don’t what was called, How do know where and who to look for? Camera view is elevated…not what the field actually is. Always get a kick at…..he missed 16 people wide open!
Really? You had his view looking through rushers?
But had an elevated camera view the QB should have seen….BS.
That's all well and good in a vacuum, but when the problem persists over the long term of the season, you can't use these as the excuses. Are these things that are factors? Absolutely, but everyone deals with them. Has our piss poor OL play impacted how he sees the field? I don't think anyone would argue otherwise.
However, we are not the only offense that deals with these factors, so when we are not overcoming them, it can only point to two things, poor coaching/play calling/giving a single read, or poor execution by the ones on the field. I've been critical of all of those things. However, if the play call itself produces viable options and the player executing the play doesn't get the ball there consistently, that is fair to be criticized over.
I think it is folly though to say someone can't criticize the QB for holding onto the ball too long and gets sacked, when there are open receivers, since you "don't know the play call". He very well may not have seen the receiver, but that doesn't actually counter any point I've made, in fact it is in support of it.
This post was edited on 11/12/26 at 11:02 am
Posted on 11/12/26 at 11:52 am to bluedragon
quote:
Good QB’s are few and far between. Those who criticize the most and loudest….likely never played the position in COMBAT…..
I think this is kind of silly. So, you can only criticize if you played the position? Hell, I played DE in high school and I am probably the last who should criticize because I wasn't as good as a lot of players. The things that are being pointed out, there are others that get it done. And therein is the criticism.
Example I hope makes sense. Let's say there is a band with a drummer. I play bass and am an active live player now. It is hard to play an instrument and it is hard to get out there on a stage and perform songs in front of a live crowd at a high level. Let us say the drummer is up there and he can't keep propper time. Goes too fast then too slow. Plays the wrong parts to the point the singer is confused. Can't hit the marks. Am I or people that have played live the only people that can say, that drummer sucked? No, there are a lot of times someone who doesn't even know how to play can watch and listen and easily criticize what they are doing.
Roger Ebert didn't make movies but he was worth listening to as a movie critic.
The "You've never done it" stuff is weak sauce IMO.
This post was edited on 11/12/26 at 11:55 am
Posted on 11/12/26 at 12:44 pm to wareaglepete
I try to not criticize the actual players… it’s ultimately the coaches’ responsibility for how a player performs. If a guy struggles on the field, he either should’ve been taught better or never there to begin with… that’s on the staff.
As much as our play on the field makes me wanna pull my hair out, I can’t blame Brown… it’s not his fault his throwing motion looks like my dead granddads… the staff knew that when they signed him… and the OL, my god… these dudes just aren’t SEC caliber players.., but again, it’s on Golesh and Co for thinking they were.
As much as our play on the field makes me wanna pull my hair out, I can’t blame Brown… it’s not his fault his throwing motion looks like my dead granddads… the staff knew that when they signed him… and the OL, my god… these dudes just aren’t SEC caliber players.., but again, it’s on Golesh and Co for thinking they were.
Posted on 11/12/26 at 2:07 pm to wareaglepete
I kinda agree. Unless we have some former stud All-SEC performers hidden on this board, we're all under qualified if we go by the "can't talk unless ya done it" rule
Most of us were just average athletes at best. We come here to give uneducated guesses. Hell Alex Golesh was a 2 way lineman who never played QB from what I know. Should his opinion also be taken with a grain of salt? lol
This post was edited on 11/12/26 at 3:27 pm
Posted on 11/12/26 at 5:28 pm to Johnnycrane
quote:
Alex Golesh was a 2 way lineman who never played QB from what I know. Should his opinion also be taken with a grain of salt? lol
Posted on 11/12/26 at 6:03 pm to Johnnycrane
quote:We started the season with a returning All-American, Xavier Atkins, and a potential All-American, Elijah Melendez, as starters.
but how in the holy hell has this kid not played?
They were backed up by Bryce Deas and Demarcus Riddick.
Auburn had the best LB room in the nation at the start of the year, and we didn’t even know Toodle could ball like that. It’s easy to see why he didn’t play until now.
Good problem to have. It’s unfortunate that we have injuries now and X isn’t on the team anymore
Posted on 11/13/26 at 11:03 am to TTsTowel
My biggest concern is his father highly praising Durkin, if Durkin goes does Toodle want to follow?
Posted on 11/13/26 at 11:17 am to TemperdTiger
His dad is a pretty massive Auburn fan, but there is always that chance. However, he had de-committed and comitted to UGA for a while as well, so while I think if Durkin ever does leave it is obviously a possibility Toodle would too, I don't think that would be close to the sole reason if Toodle was to leave ever.
Posted on 11/13/26 at 11:39 am to GoCrazyAuburn
I am optimistic in Toodle but I am not beside myself over the performance of one game
Posted on 11/13/26 at 12:00 pm to jangalang
Always the pessimistic voice.
Posted on 11/14/26 at 11:16 am to Johnnycrane
quote:
convince the money men to buy SEC caliber lineman?
That would make a ton of difference for both run and pass. Last great line we had was Chizik era recruits like Greg Robinson. Can't imagine what Robinson would cost today.
Posted on 11/14/26 at 6:15 pm to jangalang
quote:
I am not beside myself over the performance of one game
Shadarius Toodle
Total - 10
Solo - 3
Sacks - 1
TFL - 2
( through 3 quarters)
Posted on 11/14/26 at 6:37 pm to SouthEasternKaiju
He whiffed on that 1 sack though

Posted on 11/14/26 at 6:38 pm to SouthEasternKaiju
against two teams that wont go bowling
Posted on 11/14/26 at 6:43 pm to Auburn1968
quote:
Can't imagine what Robinson would cost today.
Imagine what Braden Smith would earn in today's game. That dude played every single position on the OL at a high level.
Posted on 11/14/26 at 6:54 pm to jangalang
If it was such a nothing accomplishment…

Posted on 11/14/26 at 6:58 pm to SouthEasternKaiju
Big players make big plays in big games
Latest Auburn News

Popular
Back to top


1












