Started By
Message
re: Your Top 5 SEC Players ever?
Posted on 11/30/11 at 1:59 pm to Prominentwon
Posted on 11/30/11 at 1:59 pm to Prominentwon
quote:I've got nothing against MacFadden, but you got guys like Emmit Smith, Reggie White, Peyton manning to consider. I am now wondering if Tebow and Cam belong on the list.
I didn't want to add McFadden, but I agree with alot of these guys.
McFadden belongs in the top 5 is debatable with Peyton. That's about it.
3
Posted on 11/30/11 at 1:59 pm to llfshoals
Hershel Walker
Bo Jackson
Peyton Manning
Tim Tebow
Eli Manning (One can argue on this one)
All game changers.
Bo Jackson
Peyton Manning
Tim Tebow
Eli Manning (One can argue on this one)
All game changers.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:00 pm to BennyAndTheInkJets
I'd like to add Kevin Faulk for consideration. He held the record for all-purpose yards and touchdowns in the SEC until Tebow. He is currently third in rushing yards all-time as well.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:00 pm to BennyAndTheInkJets
Walker
Jackson
Newton
Manning/Tebow/Mcfadden
I'm sure defensive players have a case as well but that's too hard to compare
Jackson
Newton
Manning/Tebow/Mcfadden
I'm sure defensive players have a case as well but that's too hard to compare
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:00 pm to Alahunter
quote:
Derrick Thomas 52 sacks, 27 in one season.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:01 pm to RebinHogland
quote:After being on TD for over a year, people will definitely argue all kinds of ridiculous things. Good luck convincing people of Eli over Cam, DMac, Emmit Smith, Reggie White and probably at least 20 others.
Eli Manning (One can argue on this one)
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:01 pm to WDE24
quote:
I've got nothing against MacFadden, but you got guys like Emmit Smith, Reggie White, Peyton manning to consider. I am now wondering if Tebow and Cam belong on the list.
TOTALLY forgot about Peyton
This is a hard list to make. And as someone already said before defensive guys like Reggie White complicate it.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:01 pm to Prominentwon
Wow... that's a tough one.
Bo Jackson
Herschel Walker
Cam Newton
Lee Roy Jordan
Billy Cannon
Give me another hour to think and I'd probably have a different list. Hell, I'd like to put Reggie White and Tracy Rocker on there too.
Bo Jackson
Herschel Walker
Cam Newton
Lee Roy Jordan
Billy Cannon
Give me another hour to think and I'd probably have a different list. Hell, I'd like to put Reggie White and Tracy Rocker on there too.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:02 pm to RebinHogland
I dont see JJ on your list.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:03 pm to ZereauxSum
quote:To be fair, while a great college QB, he wasn't as great in college as he has been in the pros. It is hard to imagine now after the way his pro career has gone, but there are reasonable arguments to leave him off a top 5 list like this. Top 5 is pretty hard to narrow down.
TOTALLY forgot about Peyton
This post was edited on 11/30/11 at 2:04 pm
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:04 pm to WDE24
IMO Newton has to be on here over Tebow. I look at it kind of the way we look at the colts without manning. Look at Auburn the year before Cam got there and the year after he left. He singlehandedly took an at best mediocre team and carried it to an undefeated season in a year when the SEC had one of it's best seasons of all time. Especially the West
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:04 pm to BennyAndTheInkJets
Honey Badger
Fairley
Trent
McFadden
tie - Herschal, Atwater, Bo
Fairley
Trent
McFadden
tie - Herschal, Atwater, Bo
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:04 pm to Hubbhogg
quote:
DMac
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:05 pm to tigerfan88
quote:Newton may be the best of them all, but I was just thinking that only really playing one year in the SEC might make his inclusion a little more difficult.
IMO Newton has to be on here over Tebow.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:06 pm to Greenwood Leflore
quote:
Atwater
Oh my god!!
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:08 pm to vol017
quote:
Jim Bob Cooter
Now that's what I'm talkin' about!!
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:08 pm to PirateJunk
That is unreal What's the story behind that? No Heisman love?
What's the story behind that? No Heisman love?Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:10 pm to PirateJunk
Derrick Thomas should be in the top 3 with Herschel and Bo.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:11 pm to RebinHogland
quote:
Eli Manning (One can argue on this one)
quote:
All game changers.
Posted on 11/30/11 at 2:14 pm to bulldawger
Mcfadden is the 3rd best SEC running back ever
Page 3 of 9
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News