Posted by
Message
Reeves40
USA
Member since Dec 2019
99 posts

Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman. Based on college career only. For me it's Keith Byars(84), Adrian Peterson (04),Darren McFadden (06),Orlando Pace(96) and Hershel Walker (80). I think Hershel could have been the 2nd player to win the Heisman twice.
This post was edited on 9/16 at 11:18 pm


KingOrange
Alabama Fan
Mayfair
Member since Aug 2018
8686 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
I Hate Tennessee but Peyton Manning was robbed.


pioneerbasketball
Arkansas Fan
Team Bunchie
Member since Oct 2005
113056 posts
 Online 

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Adrian Peterson, Larry fitz, McFadden and peyton


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
81
deeprig9
Georgia Fan
Unincorporated Ozora, Georgia
Member since Sep 2012
47224 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Herschel was definitely robbed in 1980 but the culture said freshmen weren't even supposed to play, much less win awards.




deeprig9
Georgia Fan
Unincorporated Ozora, Georgia
Member since Sep 2012
47224 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Rex Grossman got robbed as a soph.

And I hate FL.


McGregor
Alabama Fan
Member since Feb 2011
4631 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Derrick Thomas dominated about as much as you can in one year on D. He was better than the rest for sure.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
371
Decker
Alabama Fan
Member since Nov 2015
2468 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
I’d add Larry Fitzgerald and Derrick Thomas


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
111
NFLSU
Houston Astros Fan
Member since Oct 2014
11540 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
2525
Lynxrufus2012
Kentucky Fan
Member since Mar 2020
5862 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Peyton Manning. Woodson was a great player. Great pro. But Peyton Manning was robbed.


BoCam2
Auburn Fan
Alabama
Member since Apr 2012
2772 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Ndamukong Suh. One of the scariest college football players I've ever seen.


cjohn
Texas A&M Fan
Georgia
Member since Aug 2014
312 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?

Gordy Lockbaum

/lock thread


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
03
Whiskey Man
Navy Fan
St Somewhere
Member since Nov 2012
896 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Peyton Manning and Toby Gerhart.


Reeves40
USA
Member since Dec 2019
99 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
I always felt that if the Heisman was for the best player. It should have included defense players too. Not just an offense award. I know Woodson won but he played on special teams too and did a little WR too.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
22
RebelExpress38
Ole Miss Fan
In your base, killin your dudes
Member since Apr 2012
11904 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Archie Manning, Peyton Manning, Eli Manning.


Go Go Gata
Florida Fan
Member since Oct 2016
1627 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Danny Wuerfel lost to Eddie George in '95.

Rex Grossman lost to Eric Crouch

Peyton Manning

Jemelle Holloway

Willis McGahee
This post was edited on 9/16 at 7:11 pm


colbycovington
Louisiana Tech Fan
Ruston
Member since Jan 2020
1209 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Darren McFadden finished 2nd place in 2006 and 2007.

In 2006, Troy Smith's sorry arse beat him


RickDorf
LSU Fan
Nothing to prove Nothing to lose
Member since Jan 2021
3294 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
quote:

I think Hershel should have been the 2nd player to win the Heisman twice.



If I'm being honest, I feel like Trent Richardson got shorted a little because of the espn RG3 hype machine 2011. The other player who was hurt too was Tyrann Mathieu. Dude should have won it really.

Perception of a bad OL game from LSU in 2015 really hurt Fournette's standing more so than it should have but yeah, Derrick Henry was the right choice.



Replies (0)
Replies (0)
80
FourThreeForty
Penn State Fan
Member since May 2013
17226 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
Surprised nobody has said Deshaun Watson


artompkins
Alabama Fan
Orange Beach, Al
Member since May 2010
4107 posts
 Online 

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
That fat arse toby gearhart didn't deserve shite.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
113
Landmass
Ole Miss Fan
Member since Jun 2013
11812 posts

re: Who do you think was one of the best football players Not to win the Heisman?
The fact that neither Archie, nor Peyton, nor Eli won the Heisman means the Heisman is shite.


Page 1 2 3 4 5
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 5next pagelast page

Back to top

logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter