4 months later, I still don't think Henry deserved the Heisman

First, I do think he is a fantastic player and has the skills to succeed in the NFL. However, he was a great talent on just an extremely talented team. He wouldn't even be touched until 4 yards down the line of scrimmage most of the time. He didn't have those signature, flashy runs. He just bulldozed behind a line with 40 carries. McCaffrey both on and off the field displayed Heisman-like greatness. He was the best player and most important to his team. He was a skilled musician and intelligent, to boot. I didn't see those special qualities in Henry other than strong and athletic and on a good team.
Tl;dr The best player isn't always on the best team.