Started By
Message
locked post

Best Ever SEC Coach - Input needed from all SEC fans

Posted on 7/6/25 at 7:33 pm
Posted by Lucas Ryan
Magic City
Member since Jul 2025
74 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 7:33 pm
Unclouded by angst, hurt feelings, and wadded panties, let's objectively and rationally decide who the best SEC coach of all-time was.

Of course, there are only two candidates to choose from and this is where many of you will have a difficult time behaving like adults.

Bryant still permeates the horrid nightmares of many SEC fans who are in their sunset years and almost dead. He scarred many of their lives, especially old and creepy Tennessee fans and backwoods hick auburn fans of yesteryear.

Saban, otoh, has changed the very personalities of modern rival fans of all stripes and turned them into quivering masses of jealous, raving, lunatical degenerates.

Tale of The Tape:

National Championships-

Bryant: 6 (should have been a couple more easy)

Saban: 7 NC's, if you count the one that USC claims.

Total win/loss record while coaching an SEC team

Bryant: 292-69-14 (79.43%)

Saban: 249-45 (84.69%)

SEC Championships:

Bryant: 14

Saban: 11

SEC Coach of The Year:

Bryant: 12

Saban: 5

They were alike in many ways, expect for height.

Both Bryant and Saban were well renown for reviving programs. Taking down on their luck teams, and through hard-nosed determination, getting them back to championship levels or close to it.

Bryant did it at Maryland, Kentucky, A&M, and then at at Bama that had turned into a caricature of its former self.

Saban did it at Toledo, Michigan State, LSU, and then at a wounded and dying Alabama.

Both coaches were well known for taking any advantage of any rule, in any way they could, without actually breaking the rules. Both had new rules written specifically for them because of this.

Both coaches were not afraid to completely overhaul their whole coaching philosophy and learn new ways to compete when necessary to survive.

Bryant went from a passing attack to perfecting the wishbone, as well as any team did, and back again in some form or another.

Saban moved away from total domination with smash mouth, possession control ball, to high school football when the game changed and reached the pinnacle of the sport using both variations.

Bryant was an extrovert and had more friends, many in great positions of power, than most men can dream of having.The respect shown to him from all, big and small, from all walks of life and from rival fans, rival coaches, and all opponents was off the charts.

Among Alabama fans, he was almost a literal deity.

Saban was an introvert and while he had a sense of humor and a great personality if you knew him personally, he was a complete a-hole to many people and had a tendency to speak down to people in many ways. Yet, he too was greatly beloved, but mostly just by Alabama fans. While also highly respected around the football nation, he did not transcend football environs in any meaningful way.

Who was the greatest SEC coach?
This post was edited on 7/6/25 at 7:45 pm
Posted by KCM0Tiger
Kansas City, MISSOURI
Member since Nov 2011
16829 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 7:36 pm to
Posted by Lucas Ryan
Magic City
Member since Jul 2025
74 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 7:45 pm to
Who is that, KCMO?
Posted by KCM0Tiger
Kansas City, MISSOURI
Member since Nov 2011
16829 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 7:49 pm to
The Best Ever SEC Coach
Posted by Lucas Ryan
Magic City
Member since Jul 2025
74 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 8:09 pm to
quote:

The Best Ever SEC Coach


I'm talking about football coaches.
Posted by Themicah86
Member since Jun 2023
2468 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 8:16 pm to
As a Tennessee fan I think its saban then Bryant. I didn't really get to see any of Bryant because I wasn't alive during his hay day but Bryant faced a less competitive leage. Saban was good at adjusting to the game changing which most arent willing to do. That alone makes him great. As far as innovators Spurrier has to be up there.
Posted by N0T SURE
Member since Dec 2023
1607 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 8:22 pm to
I never thought it would be possible growing up to have a discussion about this, but here we are....love the bear and that era of football, but Saban is the goat.
Posted by Gunga Din
Oklahoma
Member since Jul 2020
3021 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 8:32 pm to
quote:

I never thought it would be possible growing up to have a discussion about this, but here we are....love the bear and that era of football, but Saban is the goat


Saban gets the nod for winning in an era where the competition was tougher (playoff era/wide open offenses)...

But the fact that Bryant navigated the social and political climate both on and off the field... and did what he did cannot be overstated.
Posted by makersmark1
earth
Member since Oct 2011
20031 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 9:14 pm to
Coach Saban would be my pick.

I met Coach Bryant. He was a living legend.

But the old days did not have as much parity as college football from about 1992 forward.

Coach Saban won many titles at a time that the SEC produced multiple different champions. From 2007 to 2023, LSU, Florida, Auburn, Georgia all won the NC.

The league was not as strong in the 1960s and 1970s which corresponds with Coach Bryant’s championships.

It was a different time.
Posted by WilliamTaylor21
3117 Noles N Your Butt Ave
Member since Dec 2013
37763 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 9:49 pm to
Two cheating fruits



Kirby won more without Saban than Saban without Kirby. That speaks volumes imho.

And Ed Orgeron absolutely owned Kirby
Posted by Lynxrufus2012
Central Kentucky
Member since Mar 2020
18058 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 9:55 pm to
The Bear won at Kentucky. Enough said.
Posted by Scoob
Near Exxon
Member since Jun 2009
22687 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 10:51 pm to
I'd say Saban was better. My biggest qualifier is level of competition he faced in conference, vs what Bear did.

Looking at Bear, he was at Kentucky from 1946-1953. He got an obscure title in 1951, but the consensus winner that year was Oklahoma. Tennessee got the consensus title in 51. No other SEC team seems up there during that period.
At Alabama from 1958-82, you had LSU in 1958, you had Georgia in 1980. And you had the Bama run, where he got his 5 titles.

Saban, at LSU 2000-2004. Got a title in 2003.
At Alabama 2007-2023. LSU won the title in 2007 and 2019, Florida won in 2008, Auburn in 2010, Georgia in 2021 and 2022. That doesn't address the times LSU, Georgia or Auburn played in the title game and lost.
Saban won 6 titles in that span, and played for several more.

Quite simply, Bear didn't have to deal with the level of competition Saban did.
Posted by GoGators1995
Member since Jan 2023
6157 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 10:55 pm to
Record (s) Against Final Ranked Teams (AP/Coaches) at Bama

Bryant: 49-34-5
Saban: 61-26
Posted by TrueLefty
St. Louis County
Member since Oct 2017
18148 posts
Posted on 7/6/25 at 11:17 pm to
There no denying that BK at LSU will be the one to become the greatest one ever because LSU fans keep defending him when other SEC fans were saying he is just an average HC instead of an above average HC.
Posted by LSUtigerNVegas
Las Vegas
Member since Aug 2024
572 posts
Posted on 7/7/25 at 1:56 am to
Bear also didn’t make Kentucky or Texas A&M a national power. Saban made LSU a national power and that continues to this day. Since the moment LSU hired Saban only one school can claim more football nattys and that’s the school where he spent the majority of his career. Bear didn't do that with either Kentucky or A&M. It’s completely different time periods but IMHO Saban wins out.
Posted by SLCGumpFB25
SLC
Member since Jun 2025
991 posts
Posted on 7/7/25 at 2:01 am to
quote:

And Ed Orgeron absolutely owned Kirby


Might have to auction him off to pay his divorce settlement.
Posted by Tiger Live2
Westwego, LA
Member since Mar 2012
9871 posts
Posted on 7/7/25 at 5:03 am to
Some Bama fans have the worst inferiority complex, in all sports
Posted by bamameister
Right here, right now
Member since May 2016
17117 posts
Posted on 7/7/25 at 6:43 am to
quote:

Quite simply, Bear didn't have to deal with the level of competition Saban did.


1978 ALABAMA schedule

Nebraska

Missouri

USC

Vandy

Washington

Florida

Tennessee

VaTech

Mississippi State

LSU

Auburn

Penn State (Sugar Bowl, winning the title)
Posted by Lige
Member since Nov 2015
1891 posts
Posted on 7/7/25 at 7:10 am to
I see what you did there throwing shade on the 03 LSU championship because Southern Cal cried about it. But push comes to shove you give Saban credit.
Posted by Darindawg
Member since May 2022
3721 posts
Posted on 7/7/25 at 7:24 am to
Too long, didn't read, but I assume it had something to do with Kirby Smart based on the title.
Page 1 2 3
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 3Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter