Favorite team: | LSU ![]() |
Location: | Near Exxon |
Biography: | |
Interests: | all things LSU |
Occupation: | |
Number of Posts: | 21647 |
Registered on: | 6/24/2009 |
Online Status: | Online |
Recent Posts
Message
re: What is your measuring stick for a successful hire?
Posted by Scoob on 3/21/25 at 12:15 pm
quote:ok, that being the case, a successful hire is getting someone who will consistently get you to the playoffs/postseason just about every year; the year you don't go is considered a failure, and there's no doubt you will be there next year.
What is your measuring stick for a successful hire?
It doesn't matter which sport we talk about.
Football, I would adjust that to 9+ wins on average with occasional playoff appearance. Simply because the numbers are different, less teams can get in so annual appearances is too steep. But with this, you need to have the team still in playoff discussion in the final month of the season.
For baseball, you expect to make the playoffs, and host a regional most of the time. Host a super regional probably half the time, although with LSU's history I would argue that hosting the super most of the time and making Omaha half the time should be the expectation.
Basketball, 20ish wins and make the NCAA tourney.
Women's BB same, although at this point you should make Elite 8 most years.
This is acceptable and successful, while not being impossible.
re: Milroe runs a 4.37 at pro day, third-best time by a QB ever
Posted by Scoob on 3/20/25 at 12:50 pm
quote:Look, I saw the guy play in college, and he did make some crazy plays. He was not consistent at all. But when he was on, he was good.
based on what exactly?
Look at what he did against Georgia, probably the best team in the SEC-
374 yds passing, 117 yds rushing.
if you can't acknowledge that, that's on you. I don't really care, but I can see where somebody would give it a try.
Ok, down vote me if you like. Let's see if he gets drafted
re: Milroe runs a 4.37 at pro day, third-best time by a QB ever
Posted by Scoob on 3/20/25 at 12:32 pm
quote:For one thing, as a Saints fan, I'm not hoping we draft him :lol:
gain, you're naming another player who was ELITE in college. Milroe is a guy who struggled at the college level. You can't draft a guy like that as a quick fix until his athletic abilities diminish because you first have to fix him. Lamar Jackson, Cam Newton, Vince Young, Michael Vick, et al, were awesome in college.
For another, you left off a name: Jalen Hurts. He wasn't elite, he benefited from Bama's overall talent level and they moved on to Tua as soon as they could. He put numbers up at Oklahoma, but I would say that was still talent differential + being in a great system. He was impotent against the 2019 LSU defense, which wasn't one of LSU's better defenses.
Hurts has 2 Super Bowl appearances, including a win this year.
I think Milroe has as much talent and ability as Hurts does.
re: Milroe runs a 4.37 at pro day, third-best time by a QB ever
Posted by Scoob on 3/20/25 at 11:07 am
It depends on what you want to do.
If you want to draft a prototype pocket passer, develop him, and build several generations around him over 15 years, I think he's a big no.
*Guys like Brees, Manning, Brady, etc. They secure the position for over a decade, you go through a couple crops of WRs and RBs, and usually most of the rest of the team too. You MAY have a lineman or so that lasts as long as him.
If you accept you're not gonna do that, and want to try to win and go to the playoffs and see what happens, in a relatively small window, using a supreme athlete at the QB position- I could see Milroe being that guy.
*The Cam Newton model, basically. As long as he's got fresh legs, he will ALWAYS have the ability to break off big runs, so he contorts the defense in a way the pocket guy can't, and his run threat makes the other parts easier as a result. But when he's no longer a threat to run and you can play him as a pocket guy, he's done.
I see Lamar Jackson and Jalen Hurts as that. I don't care about completion percentage and say "oh look he's got a good percentage, he is a good passer", you can tell those guys are open because the defense is hedging against his run. It's basically the ultimate play-action pass, you HAVE to prevent that 20 yd run.
It's what colleges do with these guys, because they don't get to keep them more than a few years anyway. I could see Milroe taking an otherwise mid-tier team and making them a playoff contender for a few years, I just don't think you get a decade + from him.
I'm a Saints fan, I don't know that I would want to take that. But let's use the Saints as an example: you're missing the playoffs every year now that Brees is gone. You still have Kamara and a decent defense, both of who would be gone by the time you draft a franchise passer and develop him; or you could take a Milroe and run a college-type offense, probably win 9-10 games a year for a few years. You're just not looking at a long-term (decade plus) solution, but it could get you above the "we're never going to make the playoffs" threshold.
And who knows, he could develop. Brady was a late round pick, nobody ever saw him becoming even a consistent starter.
If you want to draft a prototype pocket passer, develop him, and build several generations around him over 15 years, I think he's a big no.
*Guys like Brees, Manning, Brady, etc. They secure the position for over a decade, you go through a couple crops of WRs and RBs, and usually most of the rest of the team too. You MAY have a lineman or so that lasts as long as him.
If you accept you're not gonna do that, and want to try to win and go to the playoffs and see what happens, in a relatively small window, using a supreme athlete at the QB position- I could see Milroe being that guy.
*The Cam Newton model, basically. As long as he's got fresh legs, he will ALWAYS have the ability to break off big runs, so he contorts the defense in a way the pocket guy can't, and his run threat makes the other parts easier as a result. But when he's no longer a threat to run and you can play him as a pocket guy, he's done.
I see Lamar Jackson and Jalen Hurts as that. I don't care about completion percentage and say "oh look he's got a good percentage, he is a good passer", you can tell those guys are open because the defense is hedging against his run. It's basically the ultimate play-action pass, you HAVE to prevent that 20 yd run.
It's what colleges do with these guys, because they don't get to keep them more than a few years anyway. I could see Milroe taking an otherwise mid-tier team and making them a playoff contender for a few years, I just don't think you get a decade + from him.
I'm a Saints fan, I don't know that I would want to take that. But let's use the Saints as an example: you're missing the playoffs every year now that Brees is gone. You still have Kamara and a decent defense, both of who would be gone by the time you draft a franchise passer and develop him; or you could take a Milroe and run a college-type offense, probably win 9-10 games a year for a few years. You're just not looking at a long-term (decade plus) solution, but it could get you above the "we're never going to make the playoffs" threshold.
And who knows, he could develop. Brady was a late round pick, nobody ever saw him becoming even a consistent starter.
re: Bella Ramsey on being diagnosed as autistic while filming The Last of Us
Posted by Scoob on 3/20/25 at 10:16 am
quote:Yeah, I'm going to agree with you.quote:
Keep talking out of your arse about autism.
Calm down Nancy. I'm not dissing autism or autistic people. I'm simply asking an obvious question.
If I had graduated college and had become one of the most successful engineers in the world and had a great life...I’m not particularly going to care where I fall on the spectrum. And if I did discover it, I wouldn't put it on blast. It would obviously be working for me at that point. So what value would screening and letting everyone know bring?
I didn't bother to read the article, so I probably missed some points...
But we're all weird to some extent (hence everyone is different and unique), and we're all just trying to get through life and function in society. She's obviously been very successful, I'd say more successful than 99% of child actors and actresses to this point. Landed a role in a big show, then landed a lead role in another anticipated big show, and we've seen her in commercials. Without being mean, it's clear she didn't get those spots from being stunningly beautiful; so I'd say she's doing just fine in a highly competitive field.
re: Milroe runs a 4.37 at pro day, third-best time by a QB ever
Posted by Scoob on 3/19/25 at 6:53 pm
I think you can get maybe 7 good years out of him. He'd be a very good runner and a sub-average passer. Once his legs go, I'd say he is done.
But if you otherwise have the personnel in place to be good for the next few years, I think he'd probably win more than the other qbs in this class.
Basically, you don't develop him. You run the Ravens/Eagles offense a few years, then reset down the road.
But if you otherwise have the personnel in place to be good for the next few years, I think he'd probably win more than the other qbs in this class.
Basically, you don't develop him. You run the Ravens/Eagles offense a few years, then reset down the road.
re: Milroe runs a 4.37 at pro day, third-best time by a QB ever
Posted by Scoob on 3/19/25 at 6:26 pm
quote:of course they will...
Some dumbass will overdraft him.
I'd take Milroe over Anthony Richardson today.
If I had a good defense, running game, and deep threats, and wanted to win now without a qb, I'd think about taking him.
re: Benchmade OTF PSA
Posted by Scoob on 3/19/25 at 2:32 pm
quote:I have a couple OTF knives. A pair of real Microtechs, a couple Chinese fake Microtechs, and a pretty good Chinese Benchmade.quote:
While personally not my cup of tea, it would make a great gift for a couple of people close to me.
I've never had an OTF so I pretty much ordered it out of curiously. From what I've seen on youtube/reddit, the folks who paid $300 plus for it were pretty pissed. The folks who paid $100 for it are happy with it.
I got the Chinese stuff before Covid, and ordered them online from whatever that site was (also got some Saints jerseys for cheap).
My impressions- I think the Microtech design is superior. Just a better spring layout.
Difference between the real thing, and a well-made copy; mostly seems to be case material. The real Microtech appears to be aluminum, the fakes are something heavier and softer. The blades on the fakes are a decent form of stainless, not looking at one right now to list.
The difference in prices at the time- the Microtech Spartan was around $300 or so, and I think BladetechHQ had them on sale for that. It's a nice knife.
I got the fake Microtech Scarab for around $30, and the fake Benchmade Infidel for about the same.
They came in authentically marked fake boxes. I bought the "Benchmade" to Jim's, and the guy behind the counter thought it was real.
After comparing real and fake, the real IS nicer, but not THAT much. The better quality fakes are probably 85-90% as good, way more than 10%.
re: NBC News: Football conference takes college basketball by storm
Posted by Scoob on 3/19/25 at 1:14 pm
quote:I think it's more the fact that we don't expect to see anyone back.
Why did we decline the NIT? Do we think we don't need the additional play time to improve?
McMahon may return; I know he got the vote of confidence but I could still see LSU letting him go after this season. But I doubt we see any of the players come back. They came, and were brought in, to make this team competitive and a tourney team. Those who are good will likely move to a better program, those who are not good won't be invited back if we have any viable options to replace them.
And to go with that, as I said above, McMahon may also be gone too. So "his guys" would then be gone.
So no, there's no reason to play, there's nothing to improve.
Awesome moments in otherwise average shows or movies
Posted by Scoob on 3/17/25 at 9:20 pm
This probably isn't fair, because I do like The Mandalorian. It was always fun.
But the season 2 finale, The Rescue, when everyone is pinned down and waiting to die, and Luke fricking Skywalker comes and wrecks shop to save the day- that was incredible.
Yeah, I know, not the smoothest digital reconstruction of his face when talking; I don't care. They did it as right as could be done; all the teases:
-"One X Wing? Yay, we're saved"
- That first camera shot, of the gloved hand, then the green lightsaber ignites
- "is that a ... Jedi?"
- the hooded figure just rolling through the Death Troopers, with the music playing
- then he Force-chokes (crushes actually) one of the Death Troopers
That scene still gives me chills, far beyond what that show should illicit.
But the season 2 finale, The Rescue, when everyone is pinned down and waiting to die, and Luke fricking Skywalker comes and wrecks shop to save the day- that was incredible.
Yeah, I know, not the smoothest digital reconstruction of his face when talking; I don't care. They did it as right as could be done; all the teases:
-"One X Wing? Yay, we're saved"
- That first camera shot, of the gloved hand, then the green lightsaber ignites
- "is that a ... Jedi?"
- the hooded figure just rolling through the Death Troopers, with the music playing
- then he Force-chokes (crushes actually) one of the Death Troopers
That scene still gives me chills, far beyond what that show should illicit.
re: LSU and USC declines the NIT bid
Posted by Scoob on 3/17/25 at 8:56 pm
quote:
they gonna have to change their name/acronym to the "NUT"
Now Uninvited Tournament -
South Alabama -
https://1819news.com/news/item/inexcusable-nit-rescinds-south-alabama-basketball-invite
Loading Twitter/X Embed...
If tweet fails to load, click here.
Holy fricking shite :lol:
Man, that's just wrong.
re: Canceled Show that Deserved More ...
Posted by Scoob on 3/17/25 at 6:19 am
We do this every so often, and Firefly is always at the top of the list.
re: Watched Jacob's Ladder for the first time. Opinions on it?
Posted by Scoob on 3/16/25 at 10:47 pm
I thought it was a good movie, thought-provoking, not one I'm in a hurry to watch again.
I have to chuckle at this:
Somebody who can, do the comparison:
Free with ads, vs paid with ads. How much worse are the ads in the free service?
In theory, the Paramount/Showtime version might be higher resolution, but since we're talking about an older movie, I don't think there's any 4k, or maybe even any 1080 versions out there. Picture and sound quality are probably about the same across the board.
I have to chuckle at this:
quote:
Roku, Tubi, and PlutoTV have it for free with ads
Somebody who can, do the comparison:
Free with ads, vs paid with ads. How much worse are the ads in the free service?
In theory, the Paramount/Showtime version might be higher resolution, but since we're talking about an older movie, I don't think there's any 4k, or maybe even any 1080 versions out there. Picture and sound quality are probably about the same across the board.
re: Your 2025 NIT Bracket is set
Posted by Scoob on 3/16/25 at 10:38 pm
quote:Sadly, it makes perfect sense.quote:
LSU, USCe, Indiana, Rutgers, Northwestern, Wake and maybe another I'm forgetting...All declined to play. Just go ahead and put the NIT out of its misery.
South Carolina turned it down too
P4 schools pursue NIL-caliber athletes. Those guys are not going to stick around for the NIT, and odds are they won't return the following year either. So there's really no point in forcing them to lie and say they're "injured" etc; it was a business decision that didn't work out.
re: Does Your Amazon Driver Hate You This Much?? NSFW
Posted by Scoob on 3/16/25 at 8:49 pm
I can see both sides of this...
Yes, it's heavy. I order ammo by the case, and I correctly anticipated the demand going into covid. I'm sure my UPS driver hated me :lol:
But, it's their job. And especially for Amazon delivery drivers, part of the draw to having an Amazon Prime account is free delivery of a bunch of stuff we used to go to Walmart to get.
Yes, it's heavy. I order ammo by the case, and I correctly anticipated the demand going into covid. I'm sure my UPS driver hated me :lol:
But, it's their job. And especially for Amazon delivery drivers, part of the draw to having an Amazon Prime account is free delivery of a bunch of stuff we used to go to Walmart to get.
re: Basically everyone in the SEC made the tourney but LSU
Posted by Scoob on 3/16/25 at 6:00 pm
quote:Honest question- if we don't lose Reed, how do you think this team does?
That's funny, but if we would have just won the games we were leading at halftime, we would be in the NCAA tournament.
edit to add- pissy crowd here :lol:
I'm getting downvoted, but I'm not suggesting anything at all. I just asked a fricking question!
re: So we moved the Friday night game up to Friday afternoon to avoid rain
Posted by Scoob on 3/15/25 at 11:14 am
quote:Well, then maybe you shouldn't have said anything about today
Several of you have not followed the logic here.
I am questioning why Jay Johnson once again moved a game on a workday into work hours and it never rained. There was a comment on the Rant yesterday that someon said "the Box is really starting to fill up now"... it was the 5th inning. I'm sure all of those people would have enjoyed being in their seats for the first few innings.
I am not saying anything about today.
quote:
And it is 10:35 AM on Saturday and it has yet to rain.
Jay Johnson... great baseball coach, bad meterologist
re: So we moved the Friday night game up to Friday afternoon to avoid rain
Posted by Scoob on 3/15/25 at 11:08 am
quote:It's 11:07 here by me, beginning to rain, lots of lightning and wind
And it is 10:35 AM on Saturday and it has yet to rain.
re: “Captain America: Brave New World” one of the lowest-grossing Marvel movies of all-time
Posted by Scoob on 3/14/25 at 3:08 pm
I got downvoted for saying the MCU is not synched with reality, but I think that is an issue.
Superhero films are at their best when you can imagine it happening in the real world. The MCU went so far, nothing they put out now will mesh with that- characters in-universe are talking about the NY alien invasion, the Thanos Snap, the destruction of an Eastern European city by Ultron, now the emergence of a giant hand in the ocean etc. They are motivated and make decisions based on that. None of which apply to the real world... but are SO big it's impossible to ignore and try to make it more reality-based again.
So now, an MCU movie isn't about "what if that superhero appeared in an American city" anymore, which makes it less interesting.
Superhero films are at their best when you can imagine it happening in the real world. The MCU went so far, nothing they put out now will mesh with that- characters in-universe are talking about the NY alien invasion, the Thanos Snap, the destruction of an Eastern European city by Ultron, now the emergence of a giant hand in the ocean etc. They are motivated and make decisions based on that. None of which apply to the real world... but are SO big it's impossible to ignore and try to make it more reality-based again.
So now, an MCU movie isn't about "what if that superhero appeared in an American city" anymore, which makes it less interesting.
re: “Captain America: Brave New World” one of the lowest-grossing Marvel movies of all-time
Posted by Scoob on 3/14/25 at 12:51 pm
quote:One of the problems for me was the fact that it forced an alternate reality, due to what happened in the various movies...
MCU fell into a trap when the storyline becoming more ridiculous the longer it runs. There is always a new enemy that is even more powerful than the last, rinse and repeat.
I can watch Iron Man up to Avengers, and imagine it's happening in our world. Tony Stark is Elon Musk doing and making things at the top of his game; Captain America is a classified secret project from WW2 that nobody heard of afterwards. Thor is a strange event in a small obscure desert town that the government covers up, etc.
You may see references in tabloids, but otherwise it's all under the radar. The real world goes on.
Following Avengers and the attack on NYC, it's not my world anymore. Every decision in-world is based on things extremely different than what we have, so it loses touch. It loses the appeal of "what if this happened tomorrow in my town".
Popular