Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

These 10 college football coaches aren't as great as you may think

Posted on 2/24/25 at 11:42 am
Posted by JetDawg
Los Angeles/USC Trojans fan/alum
Member since Oct 2020
8863 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 11:42 am
Gotta admit......I think this list by writer Richard Foster is legit, accurate and reasonable for the most part (especially #1!!!!!!).

No peeking ahead........this list may cause some howls in the rafters so get ready, folks.............






Coming in at #10...............................

--- Tom Herman (Florida Atlantic)

Tom Herman’s tenure at Florida Atlantic was short-lived and disappointing. Hired in 2022 with high expectations, Herman’s team went 6-16 over two seasons, including a dismal 2-8 record in 2024. FAU fired Herman on November 18, 2024, with three years left on his contract, owing him a $4.1 million buyout.


At #9.........................

--- Steve Sarkisian (Texas)

Despite recent success, Sarkisian’s 38-17 record at Texas falls short of expectations for a program of its caliber. His teams have struggled in close games and big moments, like the 2023 CFP loss to Washington. While recruiting well, Sarkisian has yet to prove he can consistently compete for national titles in the ultra-competitive SEC (such as losing twice to the only decent team they played last year).


Here's #8........................

--- Shane Beamer (South Carolina)

Despite a promising 9-4 record in 2024, Shane Beamer’s overall 29-22 record at South Carolina is underwhelming. His teams have struggled with consistency, and he has yet to prove he can compete at the highest level in the SEC. Beamer’s recent contract extension through 2030 may be premature given his limited success.


#7, here we go........................

--- Sam Pittman (Arkansas)

Sam Pittman’s initial success at Arkansas has faded. After a promising 9-4 season in 2021, the Razorbacks have regressed, going 7-6 in 2022, 4-8 in 2023, and 6-6 in 2024. Despite his popularity, Pittman’s 29-31 overall record and inability to consistently compete in the SEC raise questions about his long-term viability.


Rolling the dice at #6......................

--- Kalen DeBoer (Alabama)

DeBoer’s first season at Alabama in 2024 was disappointing, with a 9-4 record including losses to unranked teams as double-digit favorites. Despite an upset win over Georgia, the Crimson Tide missed the College Football Playoff for the first time in years, raising questions about DeBoer’s ability to maintain Alabama’s elite status.


Lucky 5..............................

--- Mario Cristobal (Miami)

Despite high expectations, Cristobal has yet to deliver consistent success at Miami. His 2024 season ended with disappointing losses, including a 42-38 upset by Syracuse. While he’s a strong recruiter, landing quarterback Carson Beck for 2025, his in-game decision-making remains questionable. Cristobal’s inability to maximize talent and produce results in big games raises doubts about his coaching prowess.


Definitely a #4 here (at the minimum).........................

--- James Franklin (Penn State)

Despite leading Penn State to consistent top-10 finishes, Franklin’s 1-15 record against top-5 teams raises questions. His inability to win big games, including a 1-18 overall record against top-5 opponents, overshadows his regular-season success. Critics argue Franklin’s teams often fall short in crucial moments, limiting Penn State’s championship aspirations.


#3 is reasonable, imo (spends too much time with Clairol for Men hair/beard coloring....................

Despite leading Ohio State to a national championship in 2024, Ryan Day’s record against rival Michigan (1-3) and in big games remains questionable. His teams have underperformed in crucial moments, and his coaching decisions have been criticized. Day’s success may be more attributed to Ohio State’s talent pool than his coaching abilities.


Ewwwwwwwwwwwww, somethang stanky at #2.......ewwwwreally???

--- Brian Kelly (LSU)

Despite his impressive record, Brian Kelly has yet to deliver a national championship at LSU. His teams have underperformed in crucial games, and his 2024 season ended with a disappointing 9-4 record. Kelly’s bold promise of a 2025 national title seems premature, given LSU’s recent struggles and inconsistent performances.


And, ladies & gentlemen.....for your pleasure.....coming in @numero uno, your number one jackass bucko of college football (OU's getting the last laugh!!).........................................

--- Lincoln Riley (USC)

Once hailed as an offensive genius, Riley’s stock has plummeted at USC. Despite a promising 11-3 debut in 2022, the Trojans went 7-6 in 2024, with a defense ranked among the nation’s worst. Riley’s inability to build a complete team has raised questions about his $110 million contract’s value.






Posted by Buckeye06
Member since Dec 2007
24135 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 11:52 am to
Haha this list is terrible if it has Day on it.

He has the highest winning % since pictures came into color and just won a national title.
Posted by Captain Crown
Member since Jun 2011
53482 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 11:59 am to
Ohio State wins in spite of Day
Posted by Buckeye06
Member since Dec 2007
24135 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 11:59 am to
Kirby should be on this list with his 1-5 type record against Bama losing to ND by Double digits with one of the 3 most talented teams in the country

Based on this guy's reasoning of course
Posted by CatholicLSUDude
Member since Aug 2018
886 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 12:17 pm to
I mean... it looks like he just threw a bunch of big-name coaches on his "list" and then articulated their haters' standard arguments against them.

Lame list.
Posted by Frac the world
The Centennial State
Member since Oct 2014
19272 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 12:19 pm to
No Kirby list is shite
Posted by Clark14
Earth
Member since Dec 2014
23967 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 1:33 pm to
quote:

I mean... it looks like he just threw a bunch of big-name coaches on his "list" and then articulated their haters' standard arguments against them.


What the heck is Sam doing on this list….haha.

No one believes he would set the world on fire..
Posted by captdalton
Member since Feb 2021
14834 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 1:33 pm to
It looks like whoever the writer is just came up with the list of coaches who he thought would get the most clicks and arbitrarily ranked them. Such is media today. If there isn’t a story to report they will create one for us.
Posted by Darindawg
Member since May 2022
3084 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 1:38 pm to
You are just like the rest of the stupid Suckeye hypocrites....after they lost to Michigan, I didn't know a single Ohio st fan that didn't want him fired. Then he managed to win a natty and now he's the greatest thing ever. Buckeye fans are the most idiotic, 2-faced fans walking this planet.
Posted by SidewalkTiger
Midwest, USA
Member since Dec 2019
61043 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 1:42 pm to
quote:

Kelly’s bold promise of a 2025 national title seems premature, given LSU’s recent struggles and inconsistent performances.


Kelly promised a natty in 2025?

When did that happen?
Posted by Buckeye06
Member since Dec 2007
24135 posts
Posted on 2/24/25 at 3:47 pm to
Well I didn’t want him fired and you can check the history

So good try
Posted by OStateBuck
Member since Jan 2025
17 posts
Posted on 2/25/25 at 12:00 am to
That list wasn’t compiled by dumbass Buckeye fans who wanted Day fired tho lol. This list was compiled AFTER he won the championship, if it was before then it would be more credible.
I would be tempted to put Kirby on there after losing to ND but he lost his dad RIP and that wouldn’t be fair.
Posted by TheCheshireHog
Cashew Chicken Country
Member since Oct 2010
41225 posts
Posted on 2/25/25 at 12:42 am to
quote:

Despite his popularity, Pittman’s 29-31 overall record and inability to consistently compete in the SEC raise questions about his long-term viability.


Despite his popularity? The majority of our fans want him fired already. He’s nowhere near popular, at this point. I’m one of the bigger sunshine pumpers of our posters here and even I want him gone. Definitely some fluff going on from this author.
Posted by armtackledawg
Member since Aug 2017
13548 posts
Posted on 2/25/25 at 6:25 am to
Yeh I am no fan of Day but he is an excellent coach and recruiter
Posted by bamameister
Right here, right now
Member since May 2016
16461 posts
Posted on 2/25/25 at 7:01 am to
quote:

These 10 college football coaches aren't as great as you may think


When you find a poll that is capable of taking a big picture and deep dive into a head coach's career get back to me. This snapshot would have had Ryan Day leading the list last season. And probably did.

People are such sheep.
Posted by dallastiger55
Jennings, LA
Member since Jan 2010
30901 posts
Posted on 2/25/25 at 7:04 am to
So this thread is saying there are no good coaches

Just like teams, by Nov everyone is overrated

first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter