Greatest isn't the same as most talented.

Greatest is measured by championships and to a lesser extent by stats.

Most talented is more subjective and is mainly individual stats focused.

Until Mahomes gets his 5th ring maybe, this is isn't even a debate for greatest. Montana would still be ahead of Mahomes at this point. Plus it's a much more offense friendly game today.

BK785•3 months

Crazy how Mahomes is considered a "GOAT" when he barely passes for 200 yds and his tram scores only 17pts. Without that defense, KC would have gotten drubbed by Buffalo.

Corso•3 months

Let Pat Mahomes play for Brian Schottenheimer and see how GOAT he is. Andy Reid is arguably better than Bill Walsh as the greatest offense mind ever

Fat Bastard•3 months

LOL DELUSIONAL. reid is very good but better than walsh?? put down the crackpipe free shoes U

Corso•3 months

After your performance on the Poli Board you really want to talk about a crack pipe?

Savagetiger65•3 months

Brady is the Goat!! Why? Look at New England after he left and Tampa Bay when he was there. Anybody who thinks it was Bilicheks System or Robert Krafts Ownership now has to Realize after winning Another Super Bowl with Bruce Arians at Tampa it was Brady that was the X factor with all of the teams he played on!

sdc74•3 months

And what would happen to the Chiefs if Mahomes wasn't here?

Domeskeller•3 months

Greenberg is a bitter Jets fan. He's also a moron.

WHATDOINO•3 months

Brady has the greatest career ever so far. IMO Mahomes is a better overall qb. That’s not taking anything from Brady. Just if I had a pick it would be Mahomes

CrystalPreserves•3 months

You must be under 20 years old.

Scoob•3 months

No, it's an accurate statement. I think Manning, Farve, Brees and Rodgers were also better than Brady, as an actual QB.
Brady was never considered the best QB in the league, during the vast majority of his career. He was just the guy on the best team.

Savagetiger65•3 months

Really? How’s ole Bill Belichek doing Now? How many Superbowls did he win without Brady? O! Annnnd Brady goes to Tampa and wins 1 there!! Seems to me this guy was the reason he won 7 Superbowls not the Teams he played on!

Show 1 last reply in this conversation

TerdLorange•3 months

Greenberg is a moron. Nobody liked to work with him and he's just not knowledgeable at all.

ThatTahoeOverThere•3 months

The way the media glazes Mahomes is hero manufacturing at its finest. Its like early 90s NBA. All the big legends from the 80s were retiring and the league needed a new hero, MJ. Then MJ retires and Lebron gets the glazing.

JackieTreehorn•3 months

Kiss the 7 rings. Of course anything to push the KC Swifty Pfizers.

Wadey•3 months

Brady sold his soul for those rings. His wife is a self professed witch so you think about that. Piece of shite

eddieray•3 months

He’s on pace to challenge Brady. That’s all anyone has to say. He’s not the goat but might be one day

SuperOcean•3 months

I mean... Really. If you built a dream team and your QB sections are TB or PH and you don't take TB... Your an idiot. Mahomes isn't coming back against ATL but no one is really shocked TB did

faraway•3 months

your? shouldn't be calling others idiot.

SuperOcean•3 months

Miss Grandberry that you?

JoseyWalesTheOutlaw•3 months

Greenberg trying hard to please his masters.

Geauxldninja•3 months

Greenberg is a frickin idiot.

geauxbrown•3 months

The same idiot who proclaimed LSU 2019 as the GOAT?

ALhunter•3 months

If Tom Brady is Jordan, Mahomes is maybe a Garnett or Koby... he isn't even Lebron yet...