Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

Will the 5 for 5 rule eventually work better?

Posted on 9/4/26 at 8:52 pm
Posted by i am dan
NC
Member since Aug 2011
32647 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 8:52 pm
Afte these covid players with extra years get finished and gone?

Posted by RoscoeHarper
Edmond, OK
Member since Aug 2011
5049 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 8:53 pm to
Yes? That's kinda the entire point of it. No waivers
Posted by i am dan
NC
Member since Aug 2011
32647 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 8:55 pm to
But a player could play 2 years in college, get drafted and play 2 years in the NFL, and then come back and play 1 year in college technically if he gets released by the NFL?

Wouldn't he have 1 year of eligibility left?
This post was edited on 9/4/26 at 8:56 pm
Posted by southsidedell
Tucson, AZ
Member since Dec 2016
5803 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 8:55 pm to
If they would have just added the current kids there wouldn’t have been an issue at all.
Posted by Dawgs2122
Member since Dec 2024
2808 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 8:58 pm to
Honestly I'm not a fan. If a 40 year old freshman that has never been pro shows up and makes the team what do I care. What if someone does 4 years in the military out of HS and then goes to college?
Posted by vidtiger23
Member since Feb 2012
10430 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 9:05 pm to
quote:

But a player could play 2 years in college, get drafted and play 2 years in the NFL, and then come back and play 1 year in college technically if he gets released by the NFL? Wouldn't he have 1 year of eligibility left?

No
Posted by ljhog
Lake Jackson, Tx.
Member since Apr 2009
20768 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 9:05 pm to
I prefer five to play four.
Posted by bstaceyau19
New Orleans
Member since Jun 2022
1725 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 9:09 pm to
quote:


Honestly I'm not a fan. If a 40 year old freshman that has never been pro shows up and makes the team what do I care. What if someone does 4 years in the military out of HS and then goes to college?


You do realize that both of those things (esp. #2) have happened.

Or a Mormon kid does his mission and then goes to college.

Or a guy tries his hand in minor league baseball, craps out, then goes to college to play football.

Nothin new there.

Posted by Pikes Peak Tiger
Colorado Springs
Member since Jun 2023
10260 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 9:09 pm to
quote:

Yes? That's kinda the entire point of it. No waivers


Exactly. But for reasons that defy all logic, the NCAA chose not to include the 22 High School class even though they are still on that 5 year window.

And that is why there is such a mess right now.
Posted by Dawgs2122
Member since Dec 2024
2808 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 9:11 pm to
I thought 5for5 put a stop to it though. I'd be happy to be wrong
Posted by DaBike
Member since Jan 2008
10739 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 9:11 pm to
Some go for 5 for 6 or 5 for 7
Posted by LSUcajun77
New Orleans
Member since Nov 2008
24712 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 9:12 pm to
Yes, next year. That’s the whole point of this messed up situation. Had they just said 2023 class, no issue. Yet, here we are.
Posted by twk
Wichita Falls, Texas
Member since Jul 2011
3072 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 9:15 pm to
quote:

Yes, next year. That’s the whole point of this messed up situation. Had they just said 2023 class, no issue. Yet, here we are.
Lane will be back next year claiming some other exception. He’s always going to push the envelope.
Posted by Smokin Joe Dumas
Armchair QB
Member since Apr 2022
2466 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 10:22 pm to
I think there are exceptions for pregnancy and religious missions ( basically for BYU). Not sure if there are any others
Posted by OU Guy
Member since Feb 2022
33656 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 10:27 pm to
Side note. No more 4 game caps for freshmen. OU played a shitload of true freshmen tonight and i expect thats something that all teams.will do in OOC like normal.

Where it pays off is once you get into conf play they will play more games. And that will help as injuries mount. And provide deep depth for playoff teams.

Plus before, once they hit 4 games they knew season was over. Perhaps they throttle back a bit in practice. Now every player can play every game if needed. Will create better practice efforts.

Lots of upside to no longer worrying about redshirts.
Posted by dallastigers
Member since Dec 2003
11133 posts
Posted on 9/4/26 at 10:40 pm to
quote:

I thought 5for5 put a stop to it though. I'd be happy to be wrong


quote:

Exceptions

The Cabinet defined the exceptions that could delay or pause an individual’s period of eligibility under the age-based rules, which include pregnancy, active-duty military service and official religious missions. These exceptions will only be available if the student-athlete does not participate in organized competition for the duration of the exception.

For consistency throughout Division I, the NCAA Eligibility Center will administer the use of the exceptions.

Waivers under previous rules

Under the age-based eligibility model, waivers will not be available — including clock extensions and waivers previously granted for hardships, seasons of competition and delayed enrollment.

For current student-athletes with eligibility remaining under the previous rules, schools must submit any season-of-competition or eligibility clock extension waiver requests based on circumstances that occurred during or before the 2025-26 academic year — and all supporting documentation — to the national office no later than July 31, 2026. After that date, waivers of the previous rules will no longer be available.
https://www.ncaa.org/division-i-adopts-age-based-eligibility-model/
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter