Started By
Message

1st year coaches grades

Posted on 11/16/26 at 8:55 am
Posted by Landmass
Premium Member
Member since Jun 2013
27633 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 8:55 am
Thoughts?

Will Stein - A
Resurrected the UK program.

Jon Sumrall - C
Won big games but dropped some that he shouldn't have.

Alex Golesh - C
Georgia's only loss but hasn't beaten anyone else with a pulse.

Silverfield - D+
Won 2 SEC games, which is an improvement, but the team absolutely sucks.

Pete Golding - D
Defense sucks. Offense sucks. Won some big games. Lost some big games.

Kiffin - D-
Hasn't beaten anyone with a pulse but they got close to winning some big games.

This post was edited on 11/16/26 at 9:10 am
Posted by Aguga
Member since Aug 2021
4189 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 8:58 am to
I thought you were going bomb the board?
Posted by VolunGator
Franklin, TN / Key West, FL
Member since Jan 2020
1534 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:01 am to
Stein B
Posted by Landmass
Premium Member
Member since Jun 2013
27633 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:02 am to
quote:


Stein B


If it was somewhere other than Kentucky, I would agree but I think he has overachieved where all of the other year 1 coaches have underachieved.
Posted by Godawgs4
Member since Aug 2016
5681 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:05 am to
Quote
“Silverfield - D
Won 2 SEC games, which is an improvement, but the team absolutely sucks.”

Actually you can make a case for Silverfield improving Arkansas this year. Early in the season they were bad but the second half of the season they have played competitive football. I would give him much better than a D. And with Texas being flat after an emotional win look for this game to be closer than expected.
Posted by Pettifogger
I don't really care, Margaret
Member since Feb 2012
88071 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:08 am to
As an Auburn fan who has no firm opinion about Golesh, I think he deserves better than a C if we at least compete against Bama.

He's likely to have the most wins at Auburn in 7 years (sad) and he's the 4th coach in that time frame. He also has the biggest Auburn win in that time frame, and the first over a rival in that time frame.

I am not convinced he's the right guy for Auburn or anything like that, but numbers are numbers.
Posted by Night Vision
33rd Level REC/Bryant Denny West
Member since Feb 2018
28020 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:09 am to
Posted by Landmass
Premium Member
Member since Jun 2013
27633 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:09 am to
quote:

I would give him much better than a D


I can't give any coach that has an overall losing record anything higher than a D. I'll bump him up to a D+
Posted by Landmass
Premium Member
Member since Jun 2013
27633 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:12 am to
quote:


As an Auburn fan who has no firm opinion about Golesh, I think he deserves better than a C if we at least compete against Bama.


If he manages to beat Alabama, giving him wins against two of the best teams in the SEC, he's going to fly up to a B.
This post was edited on 11/16/26 at 9:13 am
Posted by Rhino5
Atlanta
Member since Nov 2014
31195 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:18 am to
quote:

Alex Golesh - C Georgia's only loss but hasn't beaten anyone else with a pulse.

Golesh is doing more with less than any other first year coach in the SEC and has the same record as LSU, Florida, and Ole Miss, Oklahoma who are loaded with talent.
Posted by Trumansfangs
Mo
Member since Sep 2018
10532 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:20 am to
quote:

I thought you were going bomb the board?



I stepped in and posted naked chicks yesterday.

Landmass is safe, and no one will miss me !
Posted by Lokistale
Member since Aug 2013
1380 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:23 am to
Just SEC team?

Bob Chesney first year at UCLA has them undefeated this season at 10-0. They have not beaten many ranked teams except Oregon. But he took over UCLA after the Nico Iamaleava mess last year at 3-9. That's A+
Posted by madmaxvol
Infinity + 1 Posts
Member since Oct 2011
22750 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 11:06 am to
quote:

Will Stein - A
Resurrected the UK program.


If Kentucky can win out and win a post-season game...it will be their first 10 win season since 2021. Stoops had 2 of them, and it took him 6 seasons before he got his first. UK has had four of them in their history (2021, 2018, 1977 and 1950). If they win out, it will definitely be an "A" season for him.

Jon Sumrall - C
Won big games but dropped some that he shouldn't have.

Florida has won 4 SEC games for the 2nd time since the 2024 season and their 3rd since 2020. If they win one more...it will be their first 5 conference win season since 2020. Mullen won 5 in his first season, McElwain won 7 in his first, Muschamp won 3 in his first. A "C" sounds appropriate.

quote:

Alex Golesh - C
Georgia's only loss but hasn't beaten anyone else with a pulse.


Record isn't great...but it is much better than what they've had in the past. Auburn has won 4 SEC games so far this season. Gus Malzahn was the HC the last time they did that. A win over Samford will give them 7 wins overall. the last time they did that was before COVID. I'd lean towards a "C+" or even "B-".

quote:

Silverfield - D+
Won 2 SEC games, which is an improvement, but the team absolutely sucks.


Yep...Arkansas only has 2 SEC wins...they were close to having one on the road at Auburn and were within a TD of Tennessee at home. They also have had the 11th hardest SOS so far this season. Compare that to the last time they actually won a conference game...that was 2024, when their SOS was 24th. I think, from the talent they returned and the schedule they have, a "C" wouldn't be out of the question for Silverfield.

quote:

Pete Golding - D
Defense sucks. Offense sucks. Won some big games. Lost some big games.



Not a great record...but SOS so far (per ESPN) is #1 in the country. Sure, they only have 4 SEC wins (will likely finish with 5), and that is a big drop off from 7 last season...but their SOS was #31 last season...the year before that, they finished 5-3 in conference with the 37th hardest schedule in the country. I feel that a "D" is a bit low for a first-year coach with that schedule. I could see a "C-" or even a "C". It's not great...but it wasn't a great situation, either.

quote:

Kiffin - D-
Hasn't beaten anyone with a pulse but they got close to winning some big games.



LSU has a ton of talent this season...so you can't say the cupboard was bare. Kiffin has already lost more overall games than Brian Kelly did last year before he was let go...and has the most SEC losses that LSU has experienced since Ed Orgeron was HC. LSU's SOS so far has been pretty hard at #16, but is relatively easy compared to 2025's #12 ranking, or 2024's #14. Looking at those losses...an OT loss at Kentucky and a loss in the last 2 seconds on Saturday against Texas tell a bit more of the story. They are really close to actually being 8-2 overall and 5-2 in conference...but they aren't. I will add that, LSU was a missed 38-yard Field Goal from winning on Saturday by the kicker that transferred there from Arkansas. I'd say that, while it is close to being better, a "D" so far is appropriate.
Posted by Landmass
Premium Member
Member since Jun 2013
27633 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 11:12 am to
I agree with all of your points, which are also mostly my points. Nice points. At least I said that to you and not your wife.
Posted by Landmass
Premium Member
Member since Jun 2013
27633 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 11:13 am to
quote:

I stepped in and posted naked chicks yesterday.


Here's two more naked chicks



Posted by Betavols1992
Johnson city tennessee
Member since Oct 2024
655 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 11:18 am to
I call ba stein. Just b got beat by the c minus got there arse beat besides sumrall have more top 25 wins
Posted by Landmass
Premium Member
Member since Jun 2013
27633 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 11:19 am to
quote:


I call ba stein. Just b got beat by the c minus got there arse beat besides sumrall have more top 25 wins


It's Kentucky.
Posted by John Casey
New Orleans
Member since Nov 2016
4722 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 11:21 am to
It’s an interesting would you rather.

Would you rather win a couple of big games while having some blowout losses to teams you should beat OR be in the mix in every big game (but lose) and handle teams you should beat with relative ease.

LSU’s 4 losses are by a combined 28 points (8 points to Ole Miss, 1 point to Kentucky, 18 points to Bama, and 1 point to Texas).

Every other 1st year SEC head coach has 1 or more blowout losses of 28+ points.
This post was edited on 11/16/26 at 2:34 pm
Posted by BluegrassBelle
RIP Hefty Lefty - 1981-2019
Member since Nov 2010
110448 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 11:21 am to
quote:


Stein B


We had 5 wins last season and 4 wins the season before that under Stoops. We had only won 3 SEC games in the last two seasons.

Stein is an A at this point if for no other reason in how quickly he was able to flip the roster to produce.

It only slips to a B if they can't beat Louisville.
This post was edited on 11/16/26 at 11:22 am
Posted by TigerLunatik
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Jan 2005
113237 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 11:22 am to
quote:

all of the other year 1 coaches have underachieved

People have too many expectations on year 1. Can it happen? Of course. But, it usually takes longer than that.
Page 1 2 3
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 3Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•Twitter