
Started By
Message
Grubb's offensive philosophy
Posted on 11/15/26 at 11:52 am
Posted on 11/15/26 at 11:52 am
Just some random thoughts I had watching the game yesterday and afterwards. Keep in mind that my total football coaching experience is entirely on video games.
Traditionally offensive strategies have been built around keeping teams on schedule: 1st and 10, 2nd and 6, 3rd and 2, 1st and 10, 2nd and 6, 3rd and 2, ad infinitum until you score. The benefit of this approach is that you only need to gain 3-5 yards each play. The drawback is that one bad play can stop a drive because once you're off schedule it can be difficult to get back on it.
Grubb doesn't seem interested in staying on schedule. Instead of using early downs to make later downs easier, his approach appears to be that each set of downs gives him three chances to gain 10 yards. I think that's why his playcalling seems disjointed, because he doesn't generally call plays to set up other plays or to make picking up a first down easier later on. Each play is intended to gain at least ten yards all on its own. I also think that's why he refuses to lean on the running game, because running plays are the bread and butter of the "staying on schedule" approach and that's not what he wants to do.
Anyway, that's just a thought I had and I'm not sure this thread really has a point beyond me trying to make sense of our most frustrating OC since Bill O'Brien, a man with whom Grubb shares some similarities:
-Neither shows much interest in any kind of offensive balance
-Neither appears to have ever heard of a traditional screen or draw
-The most effective play in both their playbooks is, "Let my uber-talented QB scramble around for a bit, I'm sure he'll figure something out."
Traditionally offensive strategies have been built around keeping teams on schedule: 1st and 10, 2nd and 6, 3rd and 2, 1st and 10, 2nd and 6, 3rd and 2, ad infinitum until you score. The benefit of this approach is that you only need to gain 3-5 yards each play. The drawback is that one bad play can stop a drive because once you're off schedule it can be difficult to get back on it.
Grubb doesn't seem interested in staying on schedule. Instead of using early downs to make later downs easier, his approach appears to be that each set of downs gives him three chances to gain 10 yards. I think that's why his playcalling seems disjointed, because he doesn't generally call plays to set up other plays or to make picking up a first down easier later on. Each play is intended to gain at least ten yards all on its own. I also think that's why he refuses to lean on the running game, because running plays are the bread and butter of the "staying on schedule" approach and that's not what he wants to do.
Anyway, that's just a thought I had and I'm not sure this thread really has a point beyond me trying to make sense of our most frustrating OC since Bill O'Brien, a man with whom Grubb shares some similarities:
-Neither shows much interest in any kind of offensive balance
-Neither appears to have ever heard of a traditional screen or draw
-The most effective play in both their playbooks is, "Let my uber-talented QB scramble around for a bit, I'm sure he'll figure something out."
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:05 pm to TheTideMustRoll
It really seems the root of our wild swings on offense are missed blocks. When you rewind a play to watch it over again a couple of times or watch someone breaking down plays, it seems that far too many plays are usually one or two missed assignments away (especially run plays that go for -2 instead of 4 or pass plays where there's just not time for the 5 yard check down).
This is not to let the coaches off the hook just a different focus of what exactly he / they are not doing well.
I'm not a coach or real expert but if Grubb's plays are going to work more consistently it seems you need to look at why it's so hard for the OL and TE to consistently block the right guy.
I think defensive coordinators see this on film too and do a better job as seasons progress of noticing what stunts. etc create chaos for us than we do of correcting it.
This is not to let the coaches off the hook just a different focus of what exactly he / they are not doing well.
I'm not a coach or real expert but if Grubb's plays are going to work more consistently it seems you need to look at why it's so hard for the OL and TE to consistently block the right guy.
I think defensive coordinators see this on film too and do a better job as seasons progress of noticing what stunts. etc create chaos for us than we do of correcting it.
This post was edited on 11/15/26 at 1:31 pm
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:08 pm to TheTideMustRoll
Whatever it is I’m not sure “philosophy” is the term to use. IMO, it’s just random shite week after week for the most part.
What’s troubling is that the head coach continually allows it.
What’s troubling is that the head coach continually allows it.
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:12 pm to wm72
Screen play yesterday that was batted and intercepted would have been a big play. Didn’t quite make it though.
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:14 pm to wm72
I think your analysis is nail on the head regarding how our staff views offensive play calling. I just happen to think that philosophy sucks.
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:14 pm to TheTideMustRoll
quote:
"Let my uber-talented QB scramble around for a bit, I'm sure he'll figure something out."
Sounds like BOB. Bill O’Brien
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:14 pm to TheTideMustRoll
quote:
Grub’s offensive philosophy
You know that scene in Billy Madison where he shits in a paper bag and sets it on fire and puts it on his neighbor’s porch….
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:23 pm to TheTideMustRoll
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:30 pm to Kashmir
I don’t see how he doesn’t have a mini-stroke every time he hears Grubb call an Empty Set.
I get chest pains when I see it, and I’m just a fan of the team.
Last week an LSU fan asked me why I keep doing that bc I always turn my back to the field and lean over and grip my chair and say a silent prayer every time I see them in an Empty Set, and just hope I don’t hear the opposing fans erupt bc of some catastrophe (like the strip Sack in the 4th qtr yesterday).
I just don’t understand it how he allows Grubb to keep calling that shite
I get chest pains when I see it, and I’m just a fan of the team.
Last week an LSU fan asked me why I keep doing that bc I always turn my back to the field and lean over and grip my chair and say a silent prayer every time I see them in an Empty Set, and just hope I don’t hear the opposing fans erupt bc of some catastrophe (like the strip Sack in the 4th qtr yesterday).
I just don’t understand it how he allows Grubb to keep calling that shite
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:37 pm to MrMojoRisin
This clip should be pinned until he's gone.
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:39 pm to Robot Santa
It seems to explain everything imo. If the plays work, awesome. If not, we have no base to rely on or adjust from.
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:39 pm to Diego Ricardo
quote:
I think your analysis is nail on the head regarding how our staff views offensive play calling. I just happen to think that philosophy sucks.
I completely agree. To my mind the most important play in any offensive playbook is (or at least ought to be) the give up the middle. If you can consistently gain a minimum of 3-4 yards with that play any time you run it, you can use that to build the rest of your offense around. But what do I know?
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:45 pm to TheTideMustRoll
Posted on 11/15/26 at 1:00 pm to Hback
Good thing rushing TDs aren't required to win football games, but if Grubb isn't shown the door, BAMA will stop getting elite running back recruits.
I am not defending Grubb by an stretch of the imagination but Kenneth Walker III was injured a lot in 2024. His choices in RBs were Zach Charbonnet, George Holani (who?), and Kenny McIntosh.
And I can understand wanting to throw the ball a lot with Tyler Lockett, DK Metcalf, and Jason Smith-Njigba at WR. Jussayin.
I am not defending Grubb by an stretch of the imagination but Kenneth Walker III was injured a lot in 2024. His choices in RBs were Zach Charbonnet, George Holani (who?), and Kenny McIntosh.
And I can understand wanting to throw the ball a lot with Tyler Lockett, DK Metcalf, and Jason Smith-Njigba at WR. Jussayin.
Posted on 11/15/26 at 1:07 pm to TheTideMustRoll
I really think he thinks a power run up the middle is uncouth or unintelligent or beneath him.
This post was edited on 11/15/26 at 1:08 pm
Posted on 11/15/26 at 1:08 pm to Refrigeraider
quote:
And I can understand wanting to throw the ball a lot with Tyler Lockett, DK Metcalf, and Jason Smith-Njigba at WR. Jussayin.
Could you go the extra step and understand wanting to also run the ball with Kenneth Walker? Super Bowl MVP
Posted on 11/15/26 at 1:09 pm to Sandkhan
quote:
Could you go the extra step and understand wanting to also run the ball with Kenneth Walker? Super Bowl MVP
Could you go the extra step and realize he was placed on IR in Dec??
He had 500+ yards on 153 carries in 11 games with nearly 300 yards receiving.
This post was edited on 11/15/26 at 1:12 pm
Posted on 11/15/26 at 1:11 pm to Refrigeraider
Ok so….when most of the season was over. Awesome point
Posted on 11/15/26 at 1:12 pm to Sandkhan
He had 153 carries in 11 games dipshit. He was injured most of the year. They finally put him on IR in Dec.
This post was edited on 11/15/26 at 1:14 pm
Posted on 11/15/26 at 1:15 pm to Refrigeraider
13 carries a game. You really are a simpleton. You argue online like someone who doesn’t talk to real people in real life
Latest Alabama News

Popular
Back to top


13









