Posted by
Message
Harry Rex Vonner
Louisiana Tech Fan
Gumps who's the Rounders boy?
Member since Nov 2013
12234 posts

Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Here were the results of the field of 32


Cam over Brodie 17-1
Tua over Nick Marshall 12-7
YA Tittle over Jeff Rutledge 13-5
15 seed Johnny Manziel 11-8 over Matt Jones
Burrow 13-6 over Danny Weurffel
Old Ball Coach 10-8 over Archie!
Dak 15-3 over David Woodley
Eli 13-5 over Matt Mauck
Peyton 17-1 over Jared Lorenzen (RIP)
Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford tied at 9-9
Pat Sullivan 16-2 over Chris Leak
Joe Namath 13-5 over Ryan Mallett
Bart Starr 17-1 over Richard Todd
Tommy Hodson 10-8 over Tee Martin
Tim Couch 10-8 over Kenny Stabler
Tim Tebow 15-3 over Shane Matthews



And now your Sweet 16 - bold your votes in by sometime in the morning on Friday


Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow
This post was edited on 4/8 at 8:50 am


thunderbird1100
LSU Fan
GSU Eagles fan
Member since Oct 2007
59798 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
quote:

Cam over Brodie 17-1


Alright, out yourself, who actually voted for Brodie Croyle over Cam Newton


VT4
LSU Fan
Lake Charles, LA
Member since Jan 2004
777 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow


Lsupimp
Colorado Fan
The Mean Streets of ST. GEORGE
Member since Nov 2003
64827 posts
 Online 

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel
Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!
Dak Prescott v Eli Manning
Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined
Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath
Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson 4time 1st team all sec
Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow

* Bart Starr never even cracked third team QB on the all SEC team.
This post was edited on 4/9 at 12:11 pm


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
41
NorthGwinnettTiger
Atlanta Falcons Fan
Member since Jun 2006
46124 posts
 Online 

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
quote:

Cam over Brodie 17-1


So Brodie posts on the SEC Rant huh?


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
41
thunderbird1100
LSU Fan
GSU Eagles fan
Member since Oct 2007
59798 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tua!
YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel
Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!
Dak Prescott v Eli Manning
Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined
Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath
Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson
Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow

I've got a lot of recency bias in there but so hard to vote for those guys who played in the 50s and never did much of anything.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
44
BowlJackson
UAB Fan
Birmingham, AL
Member since Sep 2013
44841 posts
 Online 

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
quote:

Alright, out yourself, who actually voted for Brodie Croyle over Cam Newton



LSU fan and noted Cam Hater/ cry baby errerrerrwere




Also, I'm the one who voted for the Hefty Lefty, fight me!



quote:

Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow
This post was edited on 4/8 at 9:15 am


Hailstate15
Mississippi St. Fan
ForeverGator's mom's
Member since Nov 2018
10689 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
I must ask, Dak over Eli? what is the reasoning? Is this college only?


thunderbird1100
LSU Fan
GSU Eagles fan
Member since Oct 2007
59798 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
quote:

I must ask, Dak over Eli? what is the reasoning? Is this college only?



Assuming this is college only since it's just talking about SEC QBs. Not sure why people would care about NFL success in this but I'm sure some are factoring that in.

But yeah I voted Dak over Eli because their passing numbers are similar but Dak's rushing numbers are obviously way better, so Dak it was for me. It was slightly different eras, but still, I said in my post I dont really care what the climate at the time was like, Dak simply put up better numbers than Eli.


BowlJackson
UAB Fan
Birmingham, AL
Member since Sep 2013
44841 posts
 Online 

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
quote:

I must ask, Dak over Eli? what is the reasoning? Is this college only?


That's how I've been voting this whole time, basing off their college career (except my respect vote for Lorenzen, but I knew Peyton would in anyway)


OP just said "Best SEC QB" which to me implies best QB while they were in the SEC

Thats why it's a fricking joke that Bart Starr was a 1 seed. As a college QB he was awful even by the standards of his era




But to answer your question, I think Dak was a more dominant college QB than Eli and had more ability to take over a game and win on his own. I think Dak had more impact as an individual than Eli did in college
This post was edited on 4/8 at 9:23 am


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
61
SR SponsorSR Fan
USA
Member since 2001
Thank you for supporting our sponsors
Advertisement
Rex Feral
Georgia Fan
Member since Jan 2014
2871 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow
This post was edited on 4/8 at 9:29 am


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
021
canyon
LSU Fan
Lower Keys/Coloweedo
Member since Dec 2003
10882 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
17
SECdragonmaster
Auburn Fan
Putting the sexy back in dyslexia.
Member since Dec 2013
11611 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
quote:


Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
110
dawgM2
Mississippi St. Fan
Starkville MS
Member since Jan 2013
4219 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tua

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
215
idlewatcher
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Jan 2012
47106 posts
 Online 

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
quote:

Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
42
aggiegeog
Texas A&M Fan
Tyler, TX
Member since Feb 2013
31 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow


Wanderin Reb
Ole Miss Fan
Gallifrey
Member since Jun 2013
10123 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tua!

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
31
Lsupimp
Colorado Fan
The Mean Streets of ST. GEORGE
Member since Nov 2003
64827 posts
 Online 

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
FTR, Bart Starr was injured and or otherwise didn’t play much during college whereas Tommy Hodson was a four time FIRST team all SEC selection who broke school and conference records. We are voting on COLLEGE careers, right? Bart Starr, an all timer in the NFL , barely even had a college career. He basically only played his sophomore season , threw 8 total touchdowns and Bama went 6-2-3. C’mon guys. Knock Hodson out next round if you want, but Starr should not have even been in this competition unless this is a all- name competition.



LSUDonMCO
LSU Fan
Orlando
Member since Dec 2003
4886 posts
 Online 

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Why is this even a thing????? It's Joe Burrow! Case closed!


TigerinKorea
LSU Fan
Member since Aug 2014
4529 posts

re: Sweet 16 Best SEC Quarterbacks ever
Cam versus Tuna! versus Herb Tyler

YA Tittle versus 15 seed Johnny Manziel

Joe Burrow versus Old Ball Coach Steve Spurrier!

Dak Prescott v Eli Manning

Peyton versus Fran Tarkenton and Matt Stafford combined

Pat Sullivan versus Joe Namath

Bart Starr versus Tommy Hodson

Tim Couch versus Tim Tebow
This post was edited on 4/9 at 12:32 am


Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 7next pagelast page

Back to top

logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter