Started By
Message
My issue is that it was not an immediate recovery
Posted on 11/24/22 at 9:43 pm
Posted on 11/24/22 at 9:43 pm
The players stopped when the whistle blew and the MSU player walked over and picked it up. Ole Miss #11 could have recovered it,
The only fair thing in my opinion was to give Ole Miss the ball at the point where the pass was dropped
The only fair thing in my opinion was to give Ole Miss the ball at the point where the pass was dropped
8
Posted on 11/24/22 at 9:44 pm to gumbeaux
Guy ran over and picked it up....
Posted on 11/24/22 at 9:45 pm to lewis and herschel
After the whistle and everyone stopped
Posted on 11/24/22 at 9:45 pm to gumbeaux
Yes...you can see the official blow whistle and wave play dead.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 9:46 pm to gumbeaux
If an out of bounds guy can just touch a fumbled ball in the hands of another player and cause the ball to be downed by the out of bounds player, then whistles don’t matter either. Call was right.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 9:46 pm to TutHillTiger
He never stopped .... The rules cover that clearly.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 9:46 pm to TutHillTiger
quote:
After the whistle and everyone stopped
Not everyone.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:25 pm to J2thaROC
quote:
Not everyone.
I'm pretty sharp on most rules and reviews in football.
But I don't know if that kind of play can be reviewed and the sound of a whistle be used to reverse it?
This post was edited on 11/25/22 at 12:40 am
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:31 pm to gumbeaux
My issue is ref basically said the play never happened because of the whistle. The on field call was an inadvertent whistle resulted in a replay of the down.
Then they reviewed a play that never happened according to the call on the field. That isn't how replay is supposed to work.
The whistle wasn't until after the pass, so replay got it right in my opinion. I just don't like the bs way it was explained.
Then they reviewed a play that never happened according to the call on the field. That isn't how replay is supposed to work.
The whistle wasn't until after the pass, so replay got it right in my opinion. I just don't like the bs way it was explained.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:33 pm to gumbeaux
It wasn’t pretty, but would you have preferred an inadvertent whistle to an obvious backwards pass?
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:35 pm to J2thaROC
quote:
Call was right.
Wasn't right and neither is the ruling that an out of bounds player can stop a play.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:35 pm to gumbeaux
Should have been dead ball, but didn’t change the game. Doesn’t matter
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:37 pm to gumbeaux
You forgetting where they said nothing happened and was going to give it back as a first down?
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:37 pm to s0tiger
quote:Yea original call should have been inadvertent whistle after the pass.
The whistle wasn't until after the pass, so replay got it right in my opinion. I just don't like the bs way it was explained.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:38 pm to gumbeaux
It looked immediate, guy ran over and picked it up.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:41 pm to ALhunter
The ball was thrown behind the LOS and it was a fumble and we almost got screwed out of that with the refs but yeah, that whole thing was dumb officials.
Also, we tried to be Kentucky and give the game away with that damn fumble on their 1 yard line. It was almost exactly the same as KY did.
Also, we tried to be Kentucky and give the game away with that damn fumble on their 1 yard line. It was almost exactly the same as KY did.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:42 pm to BigPoppy
Play didn’t stop and nobody else possessed it. According to the rules that’s an immediate recovery.
Replaying the down due to an inadvertent whistle after an incomplete pass was what they got wrong, but corrected, and the correction is also the correct course of action. Not sure how you can make the argument that the play didn’t happen.
Replaying the down due to an inadvertent whistle after an incomplete pass was what they got wrong, but corrected, and the correction is also the correct course of action. Not sure how you can make the argument that the play didn’t happen.
Posted on 11/24/22 at 10:43 pm to STLJ
quote:
It looked immediate
Check your eyes. It was nowhere near immediate.
Page 1 of 1
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News