re: Kirby’s Decision to Fake Punt

quote:

---

I'd put it up there with Pete Carroll throwing on 2nd and goal against the pats a few years ago.

---

Oh no. Kirby's Shart was much, much worse.

If he was so confident in the play, he made a really dumb move putting Fields in since he had never been in on punts before. Basically tipped off that the fake was coming. Just go for it with your starter who has thrown for 300+ and 3 tds

Kirby wasn't aggressive enough in the second half. He should have been worried about scoring points and not worried about field position (which the dominated the entire game) or TOP (which he dominated the entire game), or turnovers (which he dominated the entire game.

I think he realized too late that he'd made the same mistake and kinda bundled all that risk into one big play.

I think before last night I would have told you that the dumbest coaching move I’ve ever seen was Mike Shula’s decision in the 2003 OU game to defend punts by putting ten men bunched up along the line and completely ignoring both OU gunners - and by “ignoring” I mean not bothering to put anyone within ten yards of either of them. The first time or two he did it, OU had already called punt and simply kicked it away, but eventually they did the obvious and had the punter throw to one of the wide open gunners for an easy first down. That successful fake broke open what had been a close, hard-fought game, which ended in an OU win. After the game, Stoops said something along the lines of, “Well, if they were going to keep leaving them open, we decided we were going to throw to them.” Just a brain-meltingly stupid move by Shula and his special teams staff.

But that was before last night.

quote:

---

He'd seen Bama come back from a two score deficit, again. He was watching another game against his mentor slip away, and I think emotion overcame logic.

---

I think that is exactly it. I knew Kirby would try to do something in the game to “outsmart” Saban. Smart is a hell of a coach and has UGA at a high level, but he isn’t a mature coach yet and panics at some times. His insecurity to “out Saban” Saban is a major flaw.

I just finally saw it, what a shitty play call. Not even anything besides a dumb fake steps to the left and then right up the middle nothing even sneaky.

quote:

---

Underrated thing was Saban knew it was coming. Master/apprentice.

---

He's got access to the opposing team's communications. He learned that from Belichick.

I look at it the exact opposite. I look at it as he trust his defense to stop them even starting on the 50. Bama did covert two pretty long third downs on that drive I believe.

STUPID CALL !!!