Started By
Message

If Saban had retired after either of the last two NCs...

Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:43 pm
Posted by TommyM
Conflict of interest
Member since Nov 2013
2660 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:43 pm
Could Alabama have persuaded Kirby Smart? Maybe do they give a younger Cignetti a shot? I don't know, but things would likely be better than they are now.

It's Sunday night and Grubb is still employed AFAIK, even if that wouldn't fix the root of the problem. So I'm done until they're all gone most likely. Later baws.
Posted by pgaddxn
between here and there
Member since Jul 2008
4330 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:46 pm to
If Saban retired after the last NC and deboer got the job. He would be fired by now for sure.
Posted by Rabern57
Alabama
Member since Jan 2010
14425 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:47 pm to
He was set before Saban retired. He had nothing to gain by swapping schools and starting over. Especially one that would have expected Saban like results with the NIL in place.
Posted by MFTPC
Member since Apr 2026
468 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:49 pm to
quote:

If Saban had retired after either of the last two NCs...


Can we assume you meant 2015 and 2017, as 2020 doesn't count? Bama is going to wander in the trailer park desert forever now. Find a new hobby.
Posted by Crimson K
Tuscaloosa
Member since Dec 2018
8217 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:52 pm to
Kirby had already played for a title at that point and was at his Alma mater with a solid team. Nobody had really heard of Cignetti. You’d have been laughed off this board for even suggesting his name at the time. Kiffin was even more nuclear than today in Ttown. Sark probably would’ve been the guy. I wonder if Arch would’ve come to Bama. UTx might be willing to let the Tide have both for a rack of Dreamland ribs.
This post was edited on 10/18/26 at 7:54 pm
Posted by TommyM
Conflict of interest
Member since Nov 2013
2660 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:53 pm to
He hadn't won anything of significance when Saban won his last NC. If Saban decided to go out on top, I just wonder if Kirby maybe doesn't start thinking the grass is greener elsewhere.

Anyway, it doesn't matter now.
Posted by DownSouthJukin
1x tRant Poster of the Millennium
Member since Jan 2014
31928 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:54 pm to
quote:

So I'm done until they're all gone most likely. Later baws.


Spoken like a true band wagon fan.
Posted by TommyM
Conflict of interest
Member since Nov 2013
2660 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:55 pm to
By the logic of some Bama fans here, OM would have been better off keeping Ed Orgeron.
Posted by RT1941
Member since May 2007
32483 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:57 pm to
quote:

So I'm done until they're all gone most likely. Later baws.
This is the best thing I’ve read all day. Adios.
Posted by RGT
Member since Aug 2024
2974 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 7:58 pm to
Why would he have done that ,he’s making his own legacy.Look at Dboer he can’t win if he wins ,following Saban.Just like it was following Bear it took 20 something years of a revolving door of coaches.He would have never lived up to that.
Posted by dkreller
Laffy
Member since Jan 2009
34548 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:07 pm to
quote:

Sark probably would’ve been the guy. I wonder if Arch would’ve come to Bama. UTx might be willing to let the Tide have both for a rack of Dreamland ribs.

This post was edited on 10/18/26 at 8:10 pm
Posted by Kashmir
Member since Dec 2014
10746 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:08 pm to
quote:

Bama is going to wander in the trailer park desert forever now.


58-27-5 football. L3u will never catch up.
118-75 basketball L6u will never catch up.
185-174-3 baseball. L1u might catch up.
Posted by Sput
Member since Mar 2020
9246 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:10 pm to
Now if Auburn had offered Kirby the job instead of Gus when he wanted it in 2009 he would still be there.

He woulda been Dye 2.0 and never left
Posted by TommyM
Conflict of interest
Member since Nov 2013
2660 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:10 pm to
I'll do you one better, and this is really gonna piss people off.

UAB had, for over a decade, literally the worst coach in Division I football history. Why? Because we couldn't get anyone better, they said.

This is what Alabama has been reduced to, after having had two of the greatest coaches ever in living memory. Sounding like UAB fans under Watson Brown.

Thanks, Kalen DeBoer.

Posted by Diego Ricardo
Alabama
Member since Dec 2020
14575 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:14 pm to
quote:

TommyM


Did the doctor drop you on your head at birth?
Posted by bamabaseballsec
Member since Dec 2020
4751 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:15 pm to
Some fans also live in the false reality that things are the same as they were 5 years ago. Just based on years since the playoffs expanded who are the five best coaches? Cig, Kirby(hasn’t won a playoff game since expansion) Ryan “big game day”(chronic under achiever) I mean who else. Lane kiffin? Jim harbaugh(nfl now also cheated his arse off). Im not trying to hate on those guys they’re probably the best right now but they aren’t going anywhere and none outside cig seem dominant. I’m not a pro deboer guy but I am a pro have a guy in place before you make any moves guy. I hate to say it but unless your coach is absolutely tanking or has a small buyout/contract that’s about to be up. Staying pat another year and getting a larger sample size of what will work in this new era might be the best move. Look at how bad Tenn fulmer scenario went. And that was when athletic departments were overflowing with money. With this new mercenary era of 30 million dollar rosters and coach buyouts, I think the revolving door coaching era is over unless some things change.
Posted by New Money
UGA & OKST alum
Member since Jun 2023
5594 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:16 pm to
quote:

Could Alabama have persuaded Kirby Smart?


No. Not a chance.

Kirby played at UGA. Kirby's wife played at UGA. UGA was giving him everything he needed. UGA could match anything Bama offered.

Plus, he wouldn't be in anyone's shadow at UGA.
Posted by Bobby4Bama
Alabama
Member since Jan 2024
361 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:17 pm to
Scary thought. Kirby at Auburn.

Posted by MFTPC
Member since Apr 2026
468 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:19 pm to
quote:

185-174-3 baseball. L1u might catch up.


That stat actually surprises me with LSU having eight national championships to Bama’s 0
This post was edited on 10/18/26 at 8:22 pm
Posted by boweswi05
birmingham
Member since Aug 2016
7221 posts
Posted on 10/18/26 at 8:22 pm to
Wasn't Dabo Sweeney the hot name at the time?

That's who they would have probably tried to hire.
Before the last couple of years and the wheel fallen for him
Page 1 2
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•Twitter