re: Best QB in the SEC

quote:

---

Thanks, brother.

So, you're still complaining about the schedule last season?

---

Nope, I was just happy to see that you are playing us and another top ten team this year in the conference.

For clarification, I was not directing that post specifically at you, just incase you got that vibe.

So Mett is better than Manziel. Otay.

quote:

---

Unless you are basing your quarterback rankings on 2013 expectations or predictions, you cannot argue that anyone has overtaken Johnny Manziel as the best quarterback in the SEC. He is the reigning Heisman winner and was definitely the best quarterback in the SEC last year.

---

Nope, I'm basing my rankings on the past two years. The only two years AJ has played. So what, now we have to only count one of AJ's titles/years because JFF has only had one year.

AJ is the best overall QB, and JFF won the hiesman, I'm not sure what's difficult to understand here.

quote:

---

Best arm, pro style suited- Murray has an edge over AJ.

---

Huh? I think Murray may have the least arm strength of the group and the worst decision making. Plus he just doesn't show up for big games until the fourth quarter and by then it's usually too late.

I'd say JFF, AJ then Aaron. I like Aaron but I really don't think he's a better QB than JFF or AJ. I'm really only giving the edge to JFF because any of them would be as successful at Bama right now but I think JFF would be the most successful at any of the three schools.

I like AJ. Manziel lovers are ESPN highlight lovers. He's really good at what he does, but not the best QB in the SEC. If he can keep it together long enough to get drafted, watch and see which of the two is more successful in the NFL. That will tell you which one is actually the best QB, and not just a college sideshow act. Spare me the Heisman talk. The list of Heisman winning college QB's who went on to be average NFL QB's is long and undistinguished.

My 2 cents.
It stupid to compare these 3...they are all different.

1) Murray - By far the headcase of the group. But thats what happens when your supporting cast is less than optimal. He had a tremendously rough Freshman year. We saw how great he could be last year after the O line finally kept him from getting killed and we had a RB that knew what the frick he was doing. However, he is a pussy and at times I question his testicular fortitude.

2) JFF - Definitely meant more to the success of his team than the other 2 combined. W/out JFF, A&M wouldn't have been half as good. The dude is a phenomenal player, but reminds me more of Tebow than Manning. We'll see if hits the sophomore slump. We'll see what he is really made of now that teams will game-plan for him.

3) AJ - Nobody can argue this kid is a stud, but he has had the best supporting cast in the country in a stacked-arse Bama team. Its easy to go out and play football when you have a string of RB's like they have had and a lights-out defense. I do not know if AJ would be as successful on other teams with less talent. We'll never know. But he is prob the most level-headed And his girlfriend is the fricking hotness.

All 3 have strengths and weaknesses which makes it hard to rank them imo. Lets just say they are all awesome.

Just my opinion.

Man, we really needed this thread.

congrats on a great season!