Favorite team:Alabama 
Location:Cookeville,TN
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:Teacher
Number of Posts:1024
Registered on:1/20/2009
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
It would take a little injury luck, etc. but the Giants and Cardinals would love to have him right now.
There is no defense of that effort, but if you look at the totality of his career, its hard to say that guy didn't have heart - despite his many other shortcomings. The guy led Bama to an SEC Championship, never missed a game despite taking lots of hits running the ball, and by all accounts handled being benched in the USF game as well as could be expected.
Metchie, Jameson Williams, Bryce Young, Bernard, Cuevas, Booker, Simpson, Milroe, Reichard


Underrated options: Ryan Williams - that dude has rightly drawn criticism for certain things, but that dude has taken a lot of really hard hits and gotten up every time and never complains.

Talty - I know a lot of people blasted him for getting after the snapper on national tv, but he the dude is fiery, and he could've transferred out but obviously set out to be the best kicker at Bama he could. Everyone had Quinn winning the job, and Talty has proven he deserves it so far.
Good: Talty has been much more consistent, Hill's quickness, the LBs, all the new guys, and the ability of the defense to actually look mean - the last couple of years there were a lot of games where they would be in position to make plays but let the offensive player dictate the contact. This year they are swarming better and flat out hitting.

Bad: The inability to line up and run a pass play. The best pass plays always feel like busted plays or a quick pass to RCW. I thought they'd be able to hit more open plays down the field. Hopefully that is not wanting to put everything on film just yet, but it feels like that's going to be an issue all year.
1989 Bama vs. Vandy in Nashville. Rainy and nasty, but 5 year old me loved it all.
It’s rather striking how many more games Bama has played than most of the other top teams.
quote:

Phillips is still more of a bench guy.


If he’s healthy, Phillips will be every bit as important as anyone currently on the roster. He’s physical, he can rebound, can jump over a phone book, and offers a defensive presence.

Sherrill is a nice piece, but he is soft and provided very little in rebounding or interior defense relative to his size. I would’ve liked to see him develop further at Bama, but honestly Handgloten presents more intrigue or even JP Estrella would probably give the team more of what is needed to compete with these bigger teams.
quote:

Arkansas is the only Division I team in the last 30 seasons to score 115+ points with fewer than 10 turnovers but still lose. Division I teams had been 247-0


Kind of hard to believe there’s been nearly 250 times teams have scored 115+ points in the entirety of college basketball let alone the last 30 years.
Florida would half their amount of points if these refs would call moving/illegal screens…it’s embarrassing how bad these refs are in letting that go
quote:

They have everything they need to repeat if they can get even mediocre play out of their guards.


Unless the entire top 10 gets eliminated from the tournament, their ceiling is the sweet 16. They can’t hang with Zona, Duke, and most teams with a competent front court. Bama does not pose any problems to a team with skilled bigs. Florida is solid, but not a legit national title contender.
quote:

A few G League players have recently returned to college basketball due to evolving NCAA rules, notably Thierry Darlan (Santa Clara), London Johnson (Louisville), and Abdullah Ahmed (BYU), with ex-Alabama player Charles Bediako also temporarily reinstated, signaling a new trend of players choosing developmental pro leagues before college, challenging traditional pathways and eligibility norms.


Not to mention you’ve guys like Tyon Grant-Foster who is 25 playing for his 5th team in 8 years, yet there’s hardly been anything negative said about that
College Basketball 20 years or so ago was mediocre at best. The best high school players and many fringe guys went straight to the NBA, meaning you did not have the best players in college. The Bama and Mississippi St. teams that were at the top for several years would get boat raced by nearly every team in the current SEC.

Florida capitalized on recruiting 3 star players and keeping them for several years to build cohesion. Those teams would still do damage, but the overwhelming majority of early aught teams would be awful.

re: Throwing before halftime

Posted by SECFan413 on 12/7/25 at 10:11 am to
quote:

Grubb and Deboer both are in over their head. Its obvious they do not understand big-boy SEC football. Until Deboer leaves, Bama is going to be soft and run stupid finesse offense.


They were literally playing for the conference championship against a team they had already beaten on the road. They got there playing one of the toughest schedules in the country.

You can fault them for lack of adjustments but to suggest they are in over their heads is asinine.
quote:

Venables having two weeks to prepare after dominating Tennessee in Knoxville.


450+ total yards and nearly 400 yards passing for TN. You might want to rethink your Chicken Little line of thinking. It was always going to be a tough game, but they’re no more of a matchup nightmare than UGA or Vandy.
quote:

have top seed Ohio State beating Georgia while #2 Indiana defeats Alabama.


Ohio State and Indiana would each have 2 or more losses with either Bama or Georgias schedule.

Both teams are good but have no resume to suggest they are better than any top SEC school right now
I question whether some of yall even watch the games. Talty has shanked one kicked.

He’s not missed inside of 40, right down the pipe on his extra points, and this all in his first year.

This narrative that he is Cade Foster 2.0 is simply silly at this point.

re: Saban field

Posted by SECFan413 on 10/22/25 at 10:57 am to
quote:

They used the big block letters "Crimson Tide" in the endzone;


Pretty sure it was “ALABAMA” in white letters through the 90s. It was pretty basic and no color background.


re: Bama's Permanents Leaked

Posted by SECFan413 on 9/22/25 at 9:55 pm to
quote:

MSU


Where have they been the last 2 years?

It seems kind of silly for the SEC to suggest Bama and Miss. St should be permanent rivals after not scheduling them for 2 straight years.

For the record, I agree with including them on Bamas permanent opponents. It’s just more SEC front office buffoonery.
Judging by the number of free defenders on almost every run, I’d say the run schemes aren’t the greatest.

You’ve got OL and TEs not holding their blocks or getting to the next level too, but there does not seem to be a concerted effort to establish the run game. Rather it appears to just be used as a means to setup the pass at this stage.

re: Tide Hoops | Recruiting

Posted by SECFan413 on 5/16/25 at 7:24 am to
quote:

Honestly, he was limited before the injury. He's a great shooter, but was never really athleticly gifted. I think some are kind of over-hyping what he was/is.


This is definitely true. He’s a sensational spot up shooter, but his handle is not that great and Bama would be in serious trouble if he was tasked with being a main ball handler in late game situations.

quote:

but some of the hype for mid-major transfers has been over the top the past couple years.


Sears, Nelson, Estrada, Wrightsell, Youngblood, and Bruner have all been key pieces, if not the key pieces on teams that won the SEC or made it to the Elite 8 and Final 4.

You could make the argument that it’s been the high major transfers that have disappointed more. Guys like Burnett and Cliff underperformed.