re: Coordinator Discussion

For real, can we at least check the posting history to see if this person is an actual Bama fan?

I've been as vocal as anyone in criticizing Wommack, but I have to give him credit. Our last two wins have been total team wins, and the defense has noticeably improved from the start of the season. In fact other than the FSU game when the entire team showed up flat and disinterested, the defense has played pretty well. Our rushing defense looks worse by the numbers than it actually is because we've played so many teams that live off their running games. You really can't give Wommack anything lower than a C for this season so far, and I think an argument could be made to bump him up to a B.

Grubb gets an A-, and he doesn't get a perfect score only because his playcalls can get too cute for his own good when we have to pick up short yardage. He has worked wonders with Simpson, and he clearly understands what the strength of his offense is (Simpson and the receiving corps) while not neglecting the running game. Early returns say he is the best OC we've had since Sarkisian.

Grubb

A-

Mainly: Ty Simpson looks great and many just assume he would have always been this comfortable making quick reads and not that Grubb has worked with him to where he's a whole lot better now than he would have been last season.

Wommack
C

Not certain that his scheme can't work since it has against Georgia and Vandy to where the offense was just as much responsible for close games as the defense.

However, he's certainly had issues getting his defensive backfield to understand where they need to be.

I mean i gave Grubb a B+ which isn't far off from the A- a lot of folks are giving him.

I just don't think I've seen our offense really look smooth for a full game at any point this season apart from against ULM. Georgia was nicely done, but he had an extra week to gameplan.

People who are convinced he's better than Sheridan, I don't think we can know that considering Sheridan had Milroe to work with...

I think they're both good coordinators. All I said was I wouldn't be worried if Grubb left and Sheridan took the reins again.

quote:

---

Groupee?

---

Original username was TideGroyper. You know like the neo-nazi hate group.

“You all”

this is so freakin weird. ive went from just shaking my head at watching proctor give up sacks and pressures to hoping they give him the ball on shot yardage and he breaks off a 60 yard td run. ok, maybe 40 yard, but you get the picture, lol.

Womack is a C at best. Too many big plays. For example: Vandy ripping of a 65 yard touchdown off tackle. And don’t worry about what people say. Your opinion is your opinion. As of now we still have free speech.