Drew Belsoe!??! Really? And prior to winning this year, what has Stafford ever done? Matty Ice has never done a damn thing either! Mahomes already Tier 5??? Um, no.

jscrims•22 months

Stafford played 12 years for a crappy team and amassed some crazy numbers. Granted they were always playing from behind but he is a sure thing HOF. If you can’t see that, you are either under 32 or don’t know football.

Hopeful Doc•22 months

Stafford was the first player not named “Marino, Brady, or Brees” to throw for 5,000 yards in a season.
He has not had Barry Sanders-like performances, but he very much has had a Barry Sanders-like career. Great player on a bad team that sort of proved this year that if you put him on a good team, he has what it takes to make the players around him better.

GoT1de•22 months

Bradshaw belongs in tier 2 by any metric

TigerWoodlands•22 months

A lot of recency bias. See Marino, Bradshaw, Staubach etc.

Zzyzx•22 months

Switch Favre and Rodgers

Timeoday•22 months

I will take Terry Bradshaw.

ThatTahoeOverThere•22 months

Would you take prime Eli Manning or prime Kurt Warner? Warner all day.

ThatTahoeOverThere•22 months

You down by 6 with 1:46 to play, who you want as your quarterback?? Joe fricking Montana that's who.

NC_Tigah•22 months

Terry Bradshaw Tier 4???
ROTFLMAO!

CrystalPreserves•22 months

Nah they have him as a 5th tier

ThatTahoeOverThere•22 months

Bradshaw doesn't get the respect he deserves

deuce985•22 months

This tier list is laughable especially seeing Rodgers and Brees in tier 2. For some of those guys to be ranked under them is absolutely inexcusable in the league they played in. Defenses were allowed to play defense then and noodle arm Brees never would've survived in the old league to rake anything up anyway. That said, his career was impressive but he shouldn't be a tier 2 guy and neither should Rodgers. The only thing Rodgers is good for is sucking for 3 and half quarters then making a highlight reel throw to miracle win a game after putting them in the position to lose the entire game.

DomincDecoco•22 months

Elway should be on 2md tier

Robber DeNiro•22 months

Tier 1 should be Brady and Montana!!! Shout out to Drew Brees finally getting some respect.

epicopt116•22 months

I like this list!! I agree that Bobby "cajun Cannon" Hebert should be Tier 6

Tigerpimp1974•22 months

Hebert was my favorite player as a kid!

Akit1•22 months

What’s the advanced stats on throwing a 20 yard pass knowing the DT is going to hit you full speed no matter what?

Load More Comments

Popular Stories