Hugh Freeze On Nick Saban: "He's Incredible, But I Should Have Four Wins Against Him”

Les Miles could say that too. And any other coach that lost a close game.

If you “should” have you “would” have.
Former coach Bill Burgess

Kirby “should” have beaten Bama for 2017 title
Bama “should” have beaten A&M in 2012
Duke “should” have beaten Miami in 2012
You can do these all day

Thanks to his cheating, he's only got one now.
That being said, it seems like he's claiming the close losses should be wins.
By that logic, Saban "should be" undefeated against Hugh, as Hugh never managed to beat Alabama by more than 1 score.

Shoulda woulda

So should Kirby, but he doesn't

Scoreboard, Hugh.