Started By
Message

re: Which Expansion was Less of a Fit: Ark/SCAR, Aggie/Mizzou, or OU/TX?

Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:27 am to
Posted by wmr
North of Dickson, South of Herman's
Member since Mar 2009
32518 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:27 am to
Oklahoma is mixed. SE Oklahoma is southern in the same way SW Arkansas is southern. It is as much Southwestern as it is Southern. Fort Smith, Arkansas is an Old West town as much as it is a southern town, for example. It's history and culture is tied up in cowboy culture and frontier mentality way more than anything resembling Deep South culture. Cattle-ranching and rodeos, etc.

Arkansas is the same way. Going to SE Arkansas to duck-hunt is like visiting a different state. It is flat, rull of row-crops and mosquitoes, and the remnants of plantation culture and Old Agriculture Money.

The NW Arkansas Ozarks culture is not the same. It doesn't feel the same. People don't talk the same or view the world the same way.

Anyhoo...Deep South Culture identity being tied to the SEC went out the window entirely with the 2012 expansion.

It Doesn't Mean Anything Anymore.
This post was edited on 6/1/23 at 10:28 am
Posted by PerrillouxToTexas
Member since Sep 2022
5372 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:29 am to
Arkansas fans talking about how expansion ruined the SEC will never not be funny.
Posted by wmr
North of Dickson, South of Herman's
Member since Mar 2009
32518 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:32 am to
quote:

Arkansas fans talking about how expansion ruined the SEC will never not be funny.


Arkansas joining the SEC did ruin one conference.

But it wasn't the SEC...

Posted by AwgustaDawg
CSRA
Member since Jan 2023
7279 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:37 am to
Arkansas is the south. Its a good fit. South Carolina is unquestionably a good fit. OU, UT and Missouri are not the South with the exception of graciously 33% of Texaas (geographically....population wise far more than 33%). ATM is in that part of Texas and is a good fit for the most part. The other 3 programs are similar but the fan bases are not close. Oklahoma, in my experience, comes close to a SEC fanbase.
Posted by AwgustaDawg
CSRA
Member since Jan 2023
7279 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:40 am to
quote:

I hate when people misdiagnose our state like you have.

You got most of it right before you hit Oklahoma.

I come from a part of Oklahoma called Little Dixie. Ever heard of it? Obviously not. It is more like being in the southeast than any of the places you touched on.


I have been to Little Dixie a bunch. It ain't the south. The fact that it is named little Dixie stems from the fact that it was mostly settled by folks displaced shortly after the demise of actual Dixie. There is an area in Utah that is similarly named and it is as southern as the one in Oklahoma. They are much closer to being similar than they are to either being the south.
Posted by AwgustaDawg
CSRA
Member since Jan 2023
7279 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:42 am to
quote:

SC was the first state to secede from the Union. We're about as southern as it gets.



South Carolina was about the cradle of polite society in the south before the Civil War. It don't get more southern. USC should have been in the SEC from day one.
Posted by ReversePiggie
In non-Arkansas US
Member since Sep 2021
3592 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:43 am to
Who said expansion ruined the SEC? The post you referenced was talking about the SEC being about Southern schools vs. adding yankees and Texans. We've been slowly moving to super conferences for years, so expansion was inevitable.

Texass has quite a bit of experience in ruining conferences. Our concerns aren't with expansion, but the fact that UTerus is sorta like the batshit crazy chick that thinks she's a 10 when reality she's more of a 7. Maybe worth it if for a bang if she's a 9+... but better to run away otherwise.

My guess is the SEC isn't going to let Texass run over them, so I'm just looking forward to the fireworks.

This post was edited on 6/1/23 at 10:45 am
Posted by PerrillouxToTexas
Member since Sep 2022
5372 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:47 am to
SEC added a bunch of 5s in order to get the 10 in Texas. All it took was crippling every conference Texas was in via attrition, but the SEC finally caught their white whale.
Posted by AwgustaDawg
CSRA
Member since Jan 2023
7279 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:47 am to
quote:

What makes Texas so different from say, Florida or UGA?



The people and their culture. All are state universities and the place monied and connected people from the state send their children for education in state. The culture in all but about 1/3 of Texas (graciously) is vastly different than that of Florida and Georgia. Academically they are similar, culturally they ain't close. Nothing wrong with that...Texas culture, which accounts for about 66% of the state, is uniquely Texan and it is great. The fact that the culture of Florida and Georgia is nearly identical from North Carolina to 1/3 of Texas and the culture of the majority of Texas stretches from just a little east of Houston/Dallas to almost Los Angeles is the difference...
Posted by PerrillouxToTexas
Member since Sep 2022
5372 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 10:55 am to
Sure, but LSU and southeastern Louisiana is pretty damn unique as well. If LSU had been a SWC school that was just now joining the SEC now, people would say they're not a fit.

I agree though that it doesn't really matter. Texas doesn't have to be Ole Miss to be valuable member and will find its own special place in the SEC just like other expansion teams have, except Mizzou.
Posted by hellifiknow
Alabama
Member since Dec 2014
407 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 11:12 am to
OU and Missouri are the least best fit, they aren't southern
Posted by bunkerhill
Georgia
Member since Oct 2017
1370 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 11:15 am to
Every place in this country has changed culturally from the early days of the SEC, the 1930s forward. So much of the rural South did not join the 20th century until after WW II. The Depression hit but they were already poor to start with. With the advent of mass communications this country is very homogenized.

I have traveled just about everywhere and suburbia looks the same in Ohio, Georgia or Alabama. Same stores, same highways, all the same looking. Small town America looks very similar also. Do people speak differently? Yes they do. Is all the local establishment food the same? No it is not. The South and Midwest are closer culturally than say the South and the Northeast

People, that have not traveled all that much, hold on to their preconceived ideas of how people act or feel about their politics.

I have looked at "fitting in" in a sports conference as do you have the passion for your team as much as fans of the teams you are playing? If you bring passion, you fit in.
Posted by ReversePiggie
In non-Arkansas US
Member since Sep 2021
3592 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 11:31 am to
quote:

SEC added a bunch of 5s in order to get the 10 in Texas. All it took was crippling every conference Texas was in via attrition, but the SEC finally caught their white whale.


There it is. A glimpse into the completely delusional mind of a Texass fan.

You honestly think the SEC has been pursuing Texas?
Posted by PerrillouxToTexas
Member since Sep 2022
5372 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 11:36 am to
Let's ask former SEC commissioner Harvey Schiller.

quote:

In July, Texas accepted an invitation to join the SEC in 2025, but the move could happen sooner.

If Schiller got his wish, it would have happened much, much sooner.

Texas was the apple of Schiller’s eye during his time as SEC commissioner from 1986-89.


quote:

“We focused on Arkansas and South Carolina, and really wanted Texas,” Schiller told me earlier this month.


It was always about Texas.
Posted by Tony Rocky Horror
Member since May 2023
312 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 11:53 am to
Posted by ReversePiggie
In non-Arkansas US
Member since Sep 2021
3592 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 11:56 am to
Ah... ok. Living in the past, based on something that might have been appealing to Shiller back in 1989. I thought you were trying to say the SEC wanted Texass now, not 30+ years ago.

I found this article linked at the bottom of your "proof" that is significantly more relevant to the Texas of today and the transition to the SEC.

"Texas football is a joke" LINK /

Posted by Interweb Cowboy
NW Bama
Member since Dec 2010
3138 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 12:00 pm to
Mizzou the end
Posted by PerrillouxToTexas
Member since Sep 2022
5372 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 12:02 pm to
You left off the rest of the headline: "Texas is a joke... now, but move to SEC will help revive Longhorns"

And if Texas football is a joke, then Arkansas obviously is too. Unfortunately you've had the benefit of being in the SEC for 30 years and are still a joke.

Anyway, past, present, future, doesn't matter. If you're the SEC commissioner putting together a plan for expansion, who's your top choice? It's obviously Texas, no matter if we're in 1990, 2000, 2010, 2020.

You think it's a coincidence that every single expansion the SEC has made just randomly included a Texas rival?
Posted by BreakawayZou83
Kansas City, Missouri
Member since Oct 2011
9513 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 12:26 pm to
quote:

The reality is super conferences blow. Here's the conference Texas should be in:

Texas
Texas A&M
Texas Tech
TCU
LSU
Arkansas
Oklahoma
Oklahoma State


Yep. For Mizzou it would be:

Missouri
Kansas
Kansas State
Iowa State
Iowa
Nebraska
Colorado
Oklahoma
Oklahoma State
Illinois
Arkansas
Posted by ReversePiggie
In non-Arkansas US
Member since Sep 2021
3592 posts
Posted on 6/1/23 at 12:48 pm to
quote:

You think it's a coincidence that every single expansion the SEC has made just randomly included a Texas rival?


Yes. I think geography and cultural fit drove decisions considerably more than some latent desire to bring Texas into the fold.

You honestly believe that the SEC consciously went after rivals of Texas, playing the long game to finally lure the "white whale" into the conference?
first pageprev pagePage 3 of 4Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter