re: Only one modern SEC college town existed as a named American settlement in 1776

There's a historical marker sign down on campus with the details on it. It was probably UK playing Transy or Centre or some such back then, yeah.

Was it a shithole in 1817?

Rodo

quote:

---

Ya, I made the OP too quickly and left my flank open

Baton Rouge doesn't count because it wasn't an American settlement in the 1700s (France & Spain mostly)

---

I reject your premise

It was ABSOLUTELY an American settlement, as Baton Rouge is located in North America. And prior to 1776, there wasn't a "United States of America", so anything founded prior to that date wouldn't be part of the US.

It wasn't a British settlement, which is completely outside what you've stated.

quote:

---

Was it a shithole in 1817?

---

I was going to write something snarky , but decided to look it up instead.

No, it was not

quote:

---

SEC School / Location Status in 1817 Daily Life & Context
LSU (Baton Rouge, LA) Incorporated Town
A bustling, multilingual port town on the Mississippi River bluffs with a diverse population of nearly 1,500 people.
Georgia (Athens, GA) Small Frontier Village
Founded in 1801 around the young university, Athens was an isolated, heavily wooded settlement with only a few hundred residents.
South Carolina (Columbia, SC) Established State Capital
A planned, thriving political and cotton-trading hub (founded 1786) with a population of over 2,000, making it one of the few places more developed than Baton Rouge.
Vanderbilt (Nashville, TN) Growing Frontier Town
An incorporated town of around 3,000 people. It was a major trading center on the Cumberland River, rapidly expanding due to early steamboat commerce.
Kentucky (Lexington, KY)"Athens of the West"
The most culturally advanced town on this list. It boasted a population over 5,000, active manufacturing, and a mature wealthy class.
Tennessee (Knoxville, TN) Former Territorial Capital
A rustic but established Appalachian town of roughly 1,500 people, serving as a gateway for settlers moving further west.
Alabama (Tuscaloosa, AL) Pioneer Log Settlement
Known as "The Cabin Settlement," it was a tiny cluster of log huts. The Mississippi Territory was just split in 1817, and the area was wide-open wilderness.
Auburn (Auburn, AL) Creek Nation Territory
Non-existent. The land belonged entirely to the Creek Nation and would not be settled by white pioneers until the late 1830s.
Ole Miss (Oxford, MS) Chickasaw Nation Territory
Non-existent. The area was ancestral Chickasaw land and would not be ceded to the U.S. or founded as a town until the 1830s.
Mississippi State (Starkville, MS) Choctaw Nation Territory
Non-existent. The region was controlled by the Choctaw Nation. The town was not established until after the 1830 Treaty of Dancing Rabbit Creek.
Florida (Gainesville, FL) Spanish Territory / Seminole Land
Florida belonged to Spain in 1817. The area was deep wilderness home to the Seminole people; Gainesville was not founded until 1853.
Arkansas (Fayetteville, AR) Osage & Cherokee Territory
Deep wilderness. The Arkansas Territory hadn't even been formed yet (1819). The area was Ozark wilderness hunting ground.
Missouri (Columbia, MO) Pioneer Outpost
Missouri was still a territory. Columbia was not laid out until 1821; in 1817, it was just a few scattered pioneer cabins.
Texas A&M (College Station, TX) Spanish Texas / Wilderness
Total wilderness under nominal Spanish control. Anglo-American colonization of Texas did not begin in earnest until the 1820s.
Texas (Austin, TX)Spanish Texas / Comanche Territory
Dangerous frontier. The site of Austin was completely unsettled, roaming grounds for the powerful Comanche and Tonkawa tribes.
Oklahoma (Norman, OK) Plains Tribes Territory
Uncharted territory populated by the Wichita and other Plains tribes. It would later become Indian Territory via forced removals.

Key Differences in Daily LifeCultural Fusion vs. Anglo-Pioneers: While towns like Nashville and Lexington were strictly Anglo-American, Baton Rouge daily life was a unique blend of French, Spanish, British, and American laws, languages, and architecture.Geopolitics: Baton Rouge had only been part of the United States for seven years (following the 1810 West Florida Rebellion). Places like Austin, College Station, and Gainesville were still entirely foreign soil owned by Spain.

Indigenous Frontiers: In 1817, the deep-South schools (Auburn, Ole Miss, Mississippi State) were completely non-existent because the sovereign Creek, Chickasaw, and Choctaw nations still held total control of those lands.

---

quote:

---

In 1817, the title of "most cultured" belonged to Lexington, Kentucky, closely followed by Columbia, South Carolina, and Baton Rouge, Louisiana. During this era, "culture" in the American South and West was defined by wealth, formal architecture, higher education, literature, and access to European goods. Here is how the top tier of 1817 SEC school locations ranked by cultural sophistication:

1. Lexington, Kentucky (The "Athens of the West")
Lexington was arguably the most culturally advanced city in the entire American interior, vastly outshining places like Chicago, Cincinnati, or St. Louis at the time.Education & Intellect: It was home to Transylvania University (founded 1780), which featured the first law school and medical school in the West. Its libraries rivaled those on the East Coast.High Society: The town boasted the region's first orchestra, a permanent theater company, a public library, and multiple literary societies.Wealth & Architecture: Wealthy hemp and horse barons built grand, permanent brick estates designed by professional architects, moving far away from the frontier's log cabin aesthetic.

2. Columbia, South Carolina
As a wealthy, planned state capital, Columbia was the epicenter of the Antebellum South’s planter aristocracy. The University Vibe: South Carolina College (founded 1801, now the University of South Carolina) was already fully operational. It served as a massive cultural and political center where the Southern elite sent their sons to be educated. Urban Planning: The city was built on a massive, grand scale with wide avenues, lush gardens, and permanent state buildings designed to showcase civic pride and Enlightenment-era ideals. Luxury Markets: Because of its direct stagecoach and river connections to Charleston, citizens had easy access to imported European wine, fine silks, silver, and furniture.

3. Baton Rouge, Louisiana
Baton Rouge did not have the high-end academic institutions of Lexington or Columbia in 1817, but it was culturally unique due to its international flair. Multilingual Diversity: While other SEC towns were strictly Anglo-Saxon, Baton Rouge daily life was a cosmopolitan blend of French, Spanish, Anglo-American, Creole, and African cultures. Global Access: Sitting directly on the Mississippi River meant that international ships brought the latest European fashions, wines, books, and news directly to the town's bluffs long before they reached inland wilderness settlements. Sophisticated Planning: The grand Beauregard Town grid, laid out by a French aristocrat in 1806, was designed with a European-style civic layout that felt distinctly Mediterranean compared to American pioneer towns.

4. Nashville, Tennessee Nashville was in a transitional phase in 1817. It was rapidly accumulating immense wealth through cotton and river trade, but it still retained a rugged, rough-around-the-edges frontier identity. Cumberland College (the precursor to Vanderbilt's era) existed but was struggling financially, and the town was more focused on rapid commerce and politics than high arts.

The Rest of the Field: Wilderness
The remaining 12 modern SEC school towns—including Tuscaloosa, Athens, and all the locations that were still sovereign Native American or Spanish territory—possessed zero Euro-American "high culture" in 1817. They were landscapes of log cabins, military tracks, or ancient tribal hunting grounds.

---