re: Georgia had the #1 composite roster in college football in 2019

quote:

---

If you can’t beat Alabama, you don’t want none of CLEMSON

---

Didn’t UGA beat Clemson the last time they played? It wasn’t close either.

quote:

---

but he's an average coach at best

---

He's done more in his first five years than Saban, O, Dabo, Mullen etc etc etc.

quote:

---

He's done more in his first five years than Saban, O, Dabo, Mullen etc etc etc.

---

This is comparing apples to oranges and I shouldnt have to explain it to you.

quote:

---

Georgia had the #1 composite roster

---

But they sucked at WR.

He's done more in his first five years than Saban, O, Dabo, Mullen etc etc etc.

Kirby took over a team that had finished ranked with 10 wins and the 6th ranked recruiting class the year before yeah totally the same

quote:

---

Kirby took over a team that had finished ranked with 10 wins and the 6th ranked recruiting class the year before

---

They went 10-3 two consecutive seasons before Kirby.

quote:

---

Don’t forget this: That 2015 team may be considered the worst 10 win team in power 5 history. Was really the equivalent of a 7-5 team with an insanely easy schedule. 

Don’t ignore this: richt let the roster slide way down as the draft was proving.

---

Does all this make you feel better about Kirby?

quote:

---

Kirby took over a team that had finished ranked with 10 wins

---

It wasn't ranked and almost lost to Georgia Southern in OT.The team got crushed by Florida and Alabama

He "inherited" one of the worst UGA senior classes in the last 25 years (ZERO drafted) and his best QB prospect was an incoming freshman

Kirby inherited a 10 win team with a roster full of top 10 talent in one of the most talent rich states in the nation. Those are facts. He basically inherited a gold mine and stepped into a dream situation as a HC. Heading into year 5 now, he still has zero NC's and only 1 SEC title to his name. He's done no better than Richt did his first 4 years in Athens.

Bottom line, Kirby is an elite recruiter, but so far has not been able to take UGA to the next level on the field. Not only has his offense been a joke, but the rate that he is developing all that talent and putting them into the league leaves alot to be desired. His on the field coaching has also been mediocre at best, with at least one blowout every season, random bad losses (hello South Carolina) and inexplicable calls in big games (hello fake punt vs. Alabama). He may turn into a great coach in time, but he simply is not at this time anything more than an elite recruiter. As was Les Miles, Ron Zook, Larry Coker, etc, etc. So many Dawg fans acting like he's a Bear Bryant or even Urban Meyer level coach is simultaneously funny and pathetic. He's a chubby recruiter. Congrats, dawgs.

Literally nobody thinks he’s a “great coach” so calm down buddy. He’s an elite recruiter and hopefully learning how to manage the team better with his shift to a new OC. At year 5 I would say he’s as good or better at this time than many coaches in the SEC at their 5th year