Started By
Message
re: Feldman top 25 college coaches in The Athletic
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:03 pm to djsdawg
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:03 pm to djsdawg
My larger point, the forest if you will, was that Kirby Smart was overrated at #6. I made a number of points explaining why I think that.
I think the writers are falling victim to a recency bias and are patronizing Georgia fans. I think they are foolish to judge a man off of such a single remarkable season and an otherwise small body of work.
As a subpoint to that I said that 2017 wasn’t all nearly as impressive objectively as Georgia fans might like to believe. Because of the Auburn loss, the weakness of the East, and what I called “Luck” but could have easily called fortune or something else far more acceptable.
I’ve continually said that my use of that word is in a general sense rather than a specific one but that word has driven you crazy and now you have focused on a subpoint of a subpoint to argue about, which I’ll admit is arguable, and claimed victory because my use of that particular word is arguable.
That’s approaching dangerous levels of austism and I use that word earnestly. It shows an incredible amount of scrutiny on a small detail while neglecting the larger issue and a complete inability to take anything someone says beyond its immediate and literal meaning. It’s actual autism and I don’t think I want to engage with it.
I think the writers are falling victim to a recency bias and are patronizing Georgia fans. I think they are foolish to judge a man off of such a single remarkable season and an otherwise small body of work.
As a subpoint to that I said that 2017 wasn’t all nearly as impressive objectively as Georgia fans might like to believe. Because of the Auburn loss, the weakness of the East, and what I called “Luck” but could have easily called fortune or something else far more acceptable.
I’ve continually said that my use of that word is in a general sense rather than a specific one but that word has driven you crazy and now you have focused on a subpoint of a subpoint to argue about, which I’ll admit is arguable, and claimed victory because my use of that particular word is arguable.
That’s approaching dangerous levels of austism and I use that word earnestly. It shows an incredible amount of scrutiny on a small detail while neglecting the larger issue and a complete inability to take anything someone says beyond its immediate and literal meaning. It’s actual autism and I don’t think I want to engage with it.
This post was edited on 3/5/19 at 7:08 pm
2
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:08 pm to Hugh McElroy
Dantonio and Gunsy too low
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:10 pm to Hugh McElroy
Richt has lost control of this top 25 list
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:13 pm to GRTiger
Welp, Saban has all time wins, conference titles, Natty titles over Dabo.
Why the confusion?
Why the confusion?
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:18 pm to KSGamecock
quote:
shows an incredible amount of scrutiny on a small detail while neglecting the larger issue and a complete inability to take anything someone says beyond its immediate and literal meaning. It’s actual autism
So basically he’s Gus.
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:18 pm to Dawgsontop34
quote:
Gonna be honest... this seems a little bitter
Not bitter all leg humper
Get back to humping legs
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:19 pm to Hugh McElroy
David Shaw too high
Jimbo probably too high too.
All time he’s one of the few active coaches with a ring, but he’s hasn’t had a great season in a while.
Jimbo probably too high too.
All time he’s one of the few active coaches with a ring, but he’s hasn’t had a great season in a while.
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:19 pm to I Bleed Garnet
What dabo is doing at Clemson is more impressive than what saban is doing at bama
It’s freaking Clemson. And they are on par with bama. Just think of that
It’s freaking Clemson. And they are on par with bama. Just think of that
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:21 pm to MeatPants
You’ll see.
I know some people who know some people who once sat next to me at a Benihana that have a lot of information of the ins and outs of the shady stuff they do up there.
A long with hump sheep and their sisters
I know some people who know some people who once sat next to me at a Benihana that have a lot of information of the ins and outs of the shady stuff they do up there.
A long with hump sheep and their sisters
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:22 pm to I Bleed Garnet
What are their peens like?
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:23 pm to KSGamecock
Probably all gross from the sister and sheep humping
This post was edited on 3/5/19 at 7:24 pm
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:43 pm to MeatPants
quote:
And they are on par with bama.
They have passed Bama
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:46 pm to GRTiger
Dabo is a better coach than Saban based on personality alone.
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:48 pm to MeatPants
quote:
t’s freaking Clemson. And they are on par with bama. Just think of that
i don't understand this logic. if a college in tuscaloosca can win national titles, why does it seem crazy a college in Clemson could win titles. lol
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:48 pm to Farmer1906
quote:
That is what you call trying way too hard.
Just my opinion buddy. Please respect it.
Posted on 3/5/19 at 7:51 pm to I Bleed Garnet
quote:
Probably all gross from the sister and sheep humping
You went full Cheese Grits and the rooster guy.
never go full cheese grits and the rooster guy.
Posted on 3/5/19 at 8:01 pm to Hugh McElroy
Kelly is too high based on UCLA and just overrated 8n general
Scott Frost? Really? Hype is a horrible drug. Have to win at a major school before being put on a list like this. Its like having Kiffin on the list.
Scott Frost? Really? Hype is a horrible drug. Have to win at a major school before being put on a list like this. Its like having Kiffin on the list.
Posted on 3/5/19 at 8:28 pm to Tillman
quote:
never go full cheese grits and the rooster guy.
Why you say that?
Posted on 3/5/19 at 8:41 pm to Hugh McElroy
because some writer named Bruce Feldman played football in 6th grade once?
What in the absolute frick would some dude named Bruce Feldman know?
What in the absolute frick would some dude named Bruce Feldman know?
Posted on 3/5/19 at 9:26 pm to KSGamecock
quote:
larger point, the forest if you will, was that Kirby Smart was overrated at #6. I made a number of points explaining why I think that.
I think the writers are falling victim to a recency bias and are patronizing Georgia fans. I think they are foolish to judge a man off of such a single remarkable season and an otherwise small body of work.
As a subpoint to that I said that 2017 wasn’t all nearly as impressive objectively as Georgia fans might like to believe. Because of the Auburn loss, the weakness of the East, and what I called “Luck” but could have easily called fortune or something else far more acceptable.
I’ve continually said that my use of that word is in a general sense rather than a specific one but that word has driven you crazy and now you have focused on a subpoint of a subpoint to argue about, which I’ll admit is arguable, and claimed victory because my use of that particular word is arguable.
You want to talk about How long has he coached? I don’t really feel strongly about it. Yes, it’s a short tenure. Low quantity of seasons. Oh well. Not a big deal If you feel that way. You should have stopped there.
So why do they respect Kirby? It’s no small detail as you claim. High quality: 2017 and 2018. Yes, I do enjoy pointing out the massive holes in your reasoning about our success in 2017, but let’s add in 2018 as well. It was just a continuance of that high quality of overall play we saw in 2017.
Objecitively, compared on a national scale, Our program has been pretty damn good under smart without needing luck. We aren’t perfect, but We have been well prepared and developed. Nothing factually or logically supports your claim of the importance of fortune or luck or whatever you want to call it. That’s just a story you made up in your head.
Page 3 of 4
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News