Started By
Message
0
Posted on 8/10/25 at 5:54 pm to Tammany Tom
Stetson whipped your teams butt while your QB was being held up like a rag doll.I see that loss is still smarting.
Posted on 8/10/25 at 6:24 pm to Go Go Gata
Yes, we understand the limitations of AI
Posted on 8/13/25 at 9:01 am to Tammany Tom
Can you read? Did you not see the accolades?
Those are individual trophies, not team trophies.
You just hate that a walk on had such success for some strange reason.
Stafford did little for GA, go look at his stats and record with the teams he played with
Those are individual trophies, not team trophies.
You just hate that a walk on had such success for some strange reason.
Stafford did little for GA, go look at his stats and record with the teams he played with
Posted on 8/13/25 at 9:09 am to Go Go Gata
AJ McCarron won back to back NC's as the starting QB, finished second in the Heisman race and was a part of one of the greatest runs in college football history. But he's left off, and Jay Barker is on there? LOL!
Posted on 8/13/25 at 10:21 am to Go Go Gata
quote:
7 Jay Barker (Alabama) 1992–1995 3 SEC titles,
Not quite. 2 SEC titles and 1 was because Florida was on probation.
Posted on 8/13/25 at 10:40 am to Go Go Gata
Here is the correct and updated list:
Top 10 SEC QBs of All Time
1. Danny Wuerffel (Florida, 1993–1996)
Stats: 10,875 yards, 114 TDs, ~68% comp.
Hardware: 4× SEC champ, 1 Nat’l champ, Heisman, Maxwell, Davey O’Brien, SEC legend.
Why #1: Four straight SEC titles and elite efficiency over four seasons.
2. Peyton Manning (Tennessee, 1994–1997)
Stats: 11,201 yards, 89 TDs, ~64% comp.
Hardware: SEC title, Maxwell, multiple All-American honors.
Why #2: Model of consistency and leadership, one of the most technically sound passers ever.
3. Tim Tebow (Florida, 2006–2009)
Stats: 9,285 pass / 2,947 rush yards, 145 total TDs.
Hardware: 1 Heisman, 2 Nat’l champs, 2 SEC titles.
Why #3: Dual-threat dominance + championship pedigree.
4. Chase Daniel (Missouri, 2005–2008)
Stats: 12,515 yards, 101 TDs, ~68% comp.
Hardware: 2007 Heisman finalist (#4), 2× division titles, #1 AP ranking (2007).
Why #4: Sustained elite production, transformed Mizzou into a national contender.
5. Joe Burrow (LSU, 2018–2019)
Stats: 8,852 yards, 88 TDs (60 in 2019), 76.3% comp. in final season.
Hardware: 1 Nat’l champ, 1 SEC title, Heisman, Maxwell, Walter Camp.
Why #5: Greatest single season in CFB history; short career keeps him from being higher.
6. Drew Lock (Missouri, 2015–2018)
Stats: 12,193 yards, 99 TDs, SEC-record 44 TDs in 2017.
Hardware: First-team All-SEC (2017).
Why #6: One of the most prolific passers in SEC history, dangerous deep-ball arm.
7. Archie Manning (Ole Miss, 1968–1970)
Stats: 5,576 pass / 823 rush yards, 56 total TDs (shorter seasons, run-heavy era).
Hardware: SEC Player of the Year (1969), College Football HOF.
Why #7: Legendary figure and innovator for his era.
8. Brad Smith (Missouri, 2002–2005)
Stats: 8,799 pass / 4,289 rush yards — 13,088 total yards.
Hardware: Big 12 Freshman of the Year, multiple all-conference honors.
Why #8: First NCAA QB with 8k passing + 4k rushing; pre-Tebow dual-threat prototype.
9. Matt Stafford (Georgia, 2006–2008)
Stats: 7,731 yards, 51 TDs.
Hardware: SEC Offensive POY, Sugar Bowl win, #1 NFL Draft pick.
Why #9: Strong SEC career, though college production lags behind others on this list.
10. Stetson Bennett (Georgia, 2017–2022)
Stats: 8,428 yards, 66 TDs, 4,332 total yards in 2022 alone.
Hardware: 2 Nat’l champs, CFP MVP twice.
Why #10: Clutch championship QB, late bloomer who thrived in big moments.
Top 10 SEC QBs of All Time
1. Danny Wuerffel (Florida, 1993–1996)
Stats: 10,875 yards, 114 TDs, ~68% comp.
Hardware: 4× SEC champ, 1 Nat’l champ, Heisman, Maxwell, Davey O’Brien, SEC legend.
Why #1: Four straight SEC titles and elite efficiency over four seasons.
2. Peyton Manning (Tennessee, 1994–1997)
Stats: 11,201 yards, 89 TDs, ~64% comp.
Hardware: SEC title, Maxwell, multiple All-American honors.
Why #2: Model of consistency and leadership, one of the most technically sound passers ever.
3. Tim Tebow (Florida, 2006–2009)
Stats: 9,285 pass / 2,947 rush yards, 145 total TDs.
Hardware: 1 Heisman, 2 Nat’l champs, 2 SEC titles.
Why #3: Dual-threat dominance + championship pedigree.
4. Chase Daniel (Missouri, 2005–2008)
Stats: 12,515 yards, 101 TDs, ~68% comp.
Hardware: 2007 Heisman finalist (#4), 2× division titles, #1 AP ranking (2007).
Why #4: Sustained elite production, transformed Mizzou into a national contender.
5. Joe Burrow (LSU, 2018–2019)
Stats: 8,852 yards, 88 TDs (60 in 2019), 76.3% comp. in final season.
Hardware: 1 Nat’l champ, 1 SEC title, Heisman, Maxwell, Walter Camp.
Why #5: Greatest single season in CFB history; short career keeps him from being higher.
6. Drew Lock (Missouri, 2015–2018)
Stats: 12,193 yards, 99 TDs, SEC-record 44 TDs in 2017.
Hardware: First-team All-SEC (2017).
Why #6: One of the most prolific passers in SEC history, dangerous deep-ball arm.
7. Archie Manning (Ole Miss, 1968–1970)
Stats: 5,576 pass / 823 rush yards, 56 total TDs (shorter seasons, run-heavy era).
Hardware: SEC Player of the Year (1969), College Football HOF.
Why #7: Legendary figure and innovator for his era.
8. Brad Smith (Missouri, 2002–2005)
Stats: 8,799 pass / 4,289 rush yards — 13,088 total yards.
Hardware: Big 12 Freshman of the Year, multiple all-conference honors.
Why #8: First NCAA QB with 8k passing + 4k rushing; pre-Tebow dual-threat prototype.
9. Matt Stafford (Georgia, 2006–2008)
Stats: 7,731 yards, 51 TDs.
Hardware: SEC Offensive POY, Sugar Bowl win, #1 NFL Draft pick.
Why #9: Strong SEC career, though college production lags behind others on this list.
10. Stetson Bennett (Georgia, 2017–2022)
Stats: 8,428 yards, 66 TDs, 4,332 total yards in 2022 alone.
Hardware: 2 Nat’l champs, CFP MVP twice.
Why #10: Clutch championship QB, late bloomer who thrived in big moments.
Posted on 8/13/25 at 10:43 am to WG_Dawg
quote:
College Career
quote:
2 Peyton Manning
Hasn't played a snap in an SEC game in almost 30 years, so it was before the game became as offense friendly as it is, now.
Currently ( SEC Career Rank):
#6 on career Passing Yards
#5 on Passing Touchdowns
#5 in Pass Completions
#17 in Completion %
#44 in interceptions
Posted on 8/13/25 at 12:23 pm to Dawg4Life47
quote:
If the later, Stetson is probably #1 on that list since he did the following:
no one is saying stetson is a bad qb lmao
Stetson got to play with a NFL roster- I'm sure his entire starting offense and defense are playing in the NFL right now.
UGA whooped up on a LSU team that had like 4- NFL starters on offense and none on defense
Posted on 8/13/25 at 12:46 pm to skrayper
But it was not him...plenty of QBs could have done it easily..
You had a players at every position that were amazing. Besides weirdly QB. Not sure why...but AJ was average and is not remotely the reason for Alabama's dominance.
You had a players at every position that were amazing. Besides weirdly QB. Not sure why...but AJ was average and is not remotely the reason for Alabama's dominance.
Posted on 8/13/25 at 3:54 pm to Gatorbait2008
quote:
AJ was average and is not remotely the reason for Alabama's dominance.
That's what everybody says....AJ McCarron, the most average QB to ever win back to back NCs, win the Maxwell Award, The Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award, The Kellen Moore Award and make first team All- American.
Posted on 8/13/25 at 4:08 pm to Go Go Gata
Stetson winning 2 puts him top of list. Bonus points for playing for his childhood team as a walk on
Posted on 8/13/25 at 4:22 pm to DaBama
He had tons of time because of a top tier Oline, an amazing RB, and pro recievers, and one of the best CFB coaches ever, not to mention a top-tier defense. Does not get easier then that...most starting Div 1 QBs could easily do that. He is average at best.
He was taken in the fifth round...the NFL scouts agree he isn't great, but you know more than them. Those loser do not know more than you! You know Football better then all the scouts, experts, coaches etc..
He was taken in the fifth round...the NFL scouts agree he isn't great, but you know more than them. Those loser do not know more than you! You know Football better then all the scouts, experts, coaches etc..
This post was edited on 8/13/25 at 4:25 pm
Posted on 8/14/25 at 12:33 pm to Gatorbait2008
quote:
He had tons of time because of a top tier Oline, an amazing RB, and pro recievers, and one of the best CFB coaches ever, not to mention a top-tier defense. Does not get easier then that...most starting Div 1 QBs could easily do that. He is average at best.
He was taken in the fifth round...the NFL scouts agree he isn't great, but you know more than them. Those loser do not know more than you! You know Football better then all the scouts, experts, coaches etc..
Average QBs don't get drafted. Average QBs don't win national awards. Average QBs don't get voted first team All-American by the AFCA (American Football Coaches Association).
Every Division 1 head coach got a vote and AJ received more votes than anybody including the likes of Jameis Winston, Johnny Manziel and Derek Carr.
This clearly hurts but AJ McCarron was way above average as a college quarterback. Learn it, live it, love it.
Posted on 8/14/25 at 12:55 pm to Go Go Gata
Stetson Bennet should be top 5. Cam Newton should be in here somewhere. Fromm and Stafford being in is hilariously bad and proves the robots aren’t taking over. Yet.
Posted on 8/14/25 at 12:57 pm to DaBama
quote:
This clearly hurts but AJ McCarron was way above average as a college quarterback. Learn it, live it, love it.
I’d say he was a great game manager and an above average overall QB. He was not special and won games by not making many mistakes and having the best individual units every time he stepped onto the field. I won’t fault a man for having the best players around him but I also won’t anoint him as an all-timer when his team clearly carried him.
Posted on 8/14/25 at 1:20 pm to Tammany Tom
Love seeing all of the mutt fans get butthurt over your comments.
Smart’s 2 titles were all Bennett. He singlehandedly carried those teams and covered for a lot of weaknesses that would have easily been exposed had he left earlier.
They have a super easy schedule this year and will get smashed against whoever they play in the SECCG.
Smart’s 2 titles were all Bennett. He singlehandedly carried those teams and covered for a lot of weaknesses that would have easily been exposed had he left earlier.
They have a super easy schedule this year and will get smashed against whoever they play in the SECCG.
This post was edited on 8/14/25 at 1:23 pm
Posted on 8/14/25 at 1:24 pm to Lacreus
quote:
This clearly hurts but AJ McCarron was way above average as a college quarterback. Learn it, live it, love it.
Might be tad hyperbolic. 2021 had one of the best defenses of all time and ‘21 and ‘22 had best tight end of all time in Bowers. Bennett was severely underrated though.
Posted on 8/14/25 at 2:53 pm to FireDanMullen
quote:
I’d say he was a great game manager and an above average overall QB. He was not special and won games by not making many mistakes and having the best individual units every time he stepped onto the field. I won’t fault a man for having the best players around him but I also won’t anoint him as an all-timer when his team clearly carried him.
I'm not trying to say that he was some kind of generational QB. My point was that he wasn't "average at best". Like you said, he was a great game manager but he was also capable of putting up numbers when needed.
Against A&M in 2013, Bama couldn't just play ball control and hope that the defense could somehow stop Manziel. They needed production from the QB. AJ threw for 334 yds, 4 TDs and a completion percentage of 76.9%. He was no Tua or Bryce Young but he was good regardless of the talent around him.
Posted on 8/14/25 at 3:16 pm to Go Go Gata
quote:
Danny Wuerffel (Florida)
I don't if he's the top, but people forget how good he was in college
Page 4 of 6
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News