Started By
Message
0
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:09 pm to TTsTowel
quote:
college career
quote:
SEC All Decade team
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:12 pm to Alahunter
McNeil started all four years at Auburn (including as a true freshman) from 2002-2005, was apart of 39 wins in four years including an SEC Championship, was named all american, and has had a productive career for the Chargers (including being named to the Pro Bowl as a LT).
McNeil's resume is as good or better than anyone else in the SEC over the last 10 years.
McNeil's resume is as good or better than anyone else in the SEC over the last 10 years.
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:12 pm to Alahunter
It is times like this when I truly hate that Tyrone Prothro was injured. He would be on this very list IMO...
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:23 pm to Rx
Here's a good question to Bama fans..
Who's better, Julio or Prothro(before injury)?
No flame, want your honest opinion.
Who's better, Julio or Prothro(before injury)?
No flame, want your honest opinion.
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:34 pm to TxTiger82
SEC All-Decade team:
OFFENSE:
QB: Tim Tebow (UF), Matt Stafford (UGA)
Honorable Mention: David Greene (UGA), JaMarcus Russell (LSU)
RB: Mark Ingram (ALA), Darren McFadden (ARK), Dexter McCluster (OM)
Honorable Mention: Ronnie Brown (AU), Felix Jones (ARK), Cadillac Williams (AU), Knowshon Moreno (UGA),
FB: Jacob Hester (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Le'Ron McClain (ALA)
WR: Josh Reed (LSU), AJ Green (UGA), Julio Jones (ALA), DeWayne Bowe (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Shay Hodge (OM), Earl Bennett (VANDY), Sidney Rice (USC), Robert Meachem (UT)
OL: Michael Oher (OM), Shawn Andrews,(ARK) Marcus McNeil (AU), Antoine Caldwell (ALA), Andre Smith (ALA)
Honorable Mention: Mike Johnson (UA), Ciron Black (LSU), Pouncey twins (UF), Jonathan Luigs (ARK), Ben Grubbs (AU)
TE: Jacob Tamme (UK), Aaron Hernandez (UF)
Honorable Mention: Colin Peek (UA)
WR/RB - Percy Harvin (UF)
------------------------------
DEFENSE:
DL:David Pollack (UGA), Glenn Dorsey (LSU), Terrence Cody (ALA), Marcus Spears (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Quentin Groves (AU), Tyson Jackson (LSU), Jamal Anderson (ARK), Dan Williams (UT), John Henderson (UT)
LB: Patrick Willis (OM), Rolando McClain (ALA), DeMeco Ryans (ALA), Jerod Mayo (UT)
Honorable Mention: Brandon Spikes (UF), Eric Norwood (USC), Jamar Chaney (MSU)
CB: Joe Haden (UF), Reggie Nelson (UF), Chevis Jackson (LSU),
Honorable Mention: Derek Pegues (MSU), Captain Munnerlyn (USC), DJ Moore (VANDY), Kareem Jackson (UA)
S: La'Ron Landry (LSU), Eric Berry (UT)
PR: Javier Arenas (UA)
KR: Brandon James (UF)
OFFENSE:
QB: Tim Tebow (UF), Matt Stafford (UGA)
Honorable Mention: David Greene (UGA), JaMarcus Russell (LSU)
RB: Mark Ingram (ALA), Darren McFadden (ARK), Dexter McCluster (OM)
Honorable Mention: Ronnie Brown (AU), Felix Jones (ARK), Cadillac Williams (AU), Knowshon Moreno (UGA),
FB: Jacob Hester (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Le'Ron McClain (ALA)
WR: Josh Reed (LSU), AJ Green (UGA), Julio Jones (ALA), DeWayne Bowe (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Shay Hodge (OM), Earl Bennett (VANDY), Sidney Rice (USC), Robert Meachem (UT)
OL: Michael Oher (OM), Shawn Andrews,(ARK) Marcus McNeil (AU), Antoine Caldwell (ALA), Andre Smith (ALA)
Honorable Mention: Mike Johnson (UA), Ciron Black (LSU), Pouncey twins (UF), Jonathan Luigs (ARK), Ben Grubbs (AU)
TE: Jacob Tamme (UK), Aaron Hernandez (UF)
Honorable Mention: Colin Peek (UA)
WR/RB - Percy Harvin (UF)
------------------------------
DEFENSE:
DL:David Pollack (UGA), Glenn Dorsey (LSU), Terrence Cody (ALA), Marcus Spears (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Quentin Groves (AU), Tyson Jackson (LSU), Jamal Anderson (ARK), Dan Williams (UT), John Henderson (UT)
LB: Patrick Willis (OM), Rolando McClain (ALA), DeMeco Ryans (ALA), Jerod Mayo (UT)
Honorable Mention: Brandon Spikes (UF), Eric Norwood (USC), Jamar Chaney (MSU)
CB: Joe Haden (UF), Reggie Nelson (UF), Chevis Jackson (LSU),
Honorable Mention: Derek Pegues (MSU), Captain Munnerlyn (USC), DJ Moore (VANDY), Kareem Jackson (UA)
S: La'Ron Landry (LSU), Eric Berry (UT)
PR: Javier Arenas (UA)
KR: Brandon James (UF)
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:35 pm to danfraz
Williams and Brown would start over any rb from any team this decade. Put them in Nutt's or Saban's 09 offense where they run 70% of the time and this wouldn't even be close. People can say whatever they want and not include pro numbers but the rookie of the year award that Carnell won does nothing but support my claims.
Marcus McNeil gave up 2 sacks during his 4 years starting at Auburn, was a 2 time 1st team All American, is on several all decade teams for all of college football and in 3 pro seasons is a 2 time pro bowler. The only reason he wasn't a top 10 draft pick is due to him having Spinal Stenosis.
Karlos Dansby was a 1st team All American and 2 time 1st team all SEC. Willis and McClain are obvious selections but for the 3rd lb Dansby is solidly in the conversation and in my eyes the 3rd lb.
Carlos Rodgers- lock Thorpe Award winner and all
Grubbs probably a reach on my part but he was a 1st round draft pick at the Guard position, a 3 year start for Auburn paving the way for names like Williams, Brown and Irons, and he has been a starter all 3 years in the NFL.
Marcus McNeil gave up 2 sacks during his 4 years starting at Auburn, was a 2 time 1st team All American, is on several all decade teams for all of college football and in 3 pro seasons is a 2 time pro bowler. The only reason he wasn't a top 10 draft pick is due to him having Spinal Stenosis.
Karlos Dansby was a 1st team All American and 2 time 1st team all SEC. Willis and McClain are obvious selections but for the 3rd lb Dansby is solidly in the conversation and in my eyes the 3rd lb.
Carlos Rodgers- lock Thorpe Award winner and all
Grubbs probably a reach on my part but he was a 1st round draft pick at the Guard position, a 3 year start for Auburn paving the way for names like Williams, Brown and Irons, and he has been a starter all 3 years in the NFL.
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:41 pm to UASports23
Dude no Carlos Rogers?
And no way is Julio on the freakin all decade team. No frickin way.
And no way is Julio on the freakin all decade team. No frickin way.
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:47 pm to Alahunter
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:49 pm to marshallcotiger
quote:
Williams and Brown would start over any rb from any team this decade
No, they wouldn't.
quote:
Put them in Nutt's or Saban's 09 offense where they run 70% of the time and this wouldn't even be close
They weren't though, and what they did, was not as good as several others did. They were very good, but not in the top 2 or 3 this past decade, argue as you might, their production vs. other RB's prove this.
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:50 pm to TTsTowel
quote:
Here's a good question to Bama fans..
Who's better, Julio or Prothro(before injury)?
No flame, want your honest opinion.
DJ Hall over both as of now.
But to answer your question, JJ everytime. Prothro was nothing but an undersized WR that played with tons of heart, not some god of the gridiron that many Bama fans make him out as...
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:51 pm to TTsTowel
These are a list of guys that have an argument.
QB- Tim Tebow
QB- Rex Grossman
ATH- Percy Harvin
WR- Jabar Gaffney
TE- Aaron Hernandez
TE- Ben Troupe
OL- Max Starks
OL- Mike Degory
DE- Alex Brown
DE- Carlos Dunlap
LB- Brandon Spikes
LB- Channing Crowder
CB- Keiwan Ratliff
CB- Joe Haden
CB- Lito Sheppard
S- Reggie Nelson
ST- Brandon James
QB- Tim Tebow
QB- Rex Grossman
ATH- Percy Harvin
WR- Jabar Gaffney
TE- Aaron Hernandez
TE- Ben Troupe
OL- Max Starks
OL- Mike Degory
DE- Alex Brown
DE- Carlos Dunlap
LB- Brandon Spikes
LB- Channing Crowder
CB- Keiwan Ratliff
CB- Joe Haden
CB- Lito Sheppard
S- Reggie Nelson
ST- Brandon James
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:51 pm to Alahunter
Look at McFadden in the NFL..
And then go look at Caddy and Ronnie.
Caddy>McFadden
Ronnie>McFadden
And then go look at Caddy and Ronnie.
Caddy>McFadden
Ronnie>McFadden
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:52 pm to UASports23
quote:
OFFENSE:
QB: Tim Tebow (UF), Matt Stafford (UGA)
Honorable Mention: David Greene (UGA), JaMarcus Russell (LSU)
RB: Mark Ingram (ALA), Darren McFadden (ARK), Dexter McCluster (OM)
Honorable Mention: Ronnie Brown (AU), Felix Jones (ARK), Cadillac Williams (AU), Knowshon Moreno (UGA),
FB: Jacob Hester (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Le'Ron McClain (ALA)
WR: Josh Reed (LSU), AJ Green (UGA), Julio Jones (ALA), DeWayne Bowe (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Shay Hodge (OM), Earl Bennett (VANDY), Sidney Rice (USC), Robert Meachem (UT)
OL: Michael Oher (OM), Shawn Andrews,(ARK) Marcus McNeil (AU), Antoine Caldwell (ALA), Andre Smith (ALA)
Honorable Mention: Mike Johnson (UA), Ciron Black (LSU), Pouncey twins (UF), Jonathan Luigs (ARK), Ben Grubbs (AU)
TE: Jacob Tamme (UK), Aaron Hernandez (UF)
Honorable Mention: Colin Peek (UA)
WR/RB - Percy Harvin (UF)
------------------------------
DEFENSE:
DL:David Pollack (UGA), Glenn Dorsey (LSU), Terrence Cody (ALA), Marcus Spears (LSU)
Honorable Mention: Quentin Groves (AU), Tyson Jackson (LSU), Jamal Anderson (ARK), Dan Williams (UT), John Henderson (UT)
LB: Patrick Willis (OM), Rolando McClain (ALA), DeMeco Ryans (ALA), Jerod Mayo (UT)
Honorable Mention: Brandon Spikes (UF), Eric Norwood (USC), Jamar Chaney (MSU)
CB: Joe Haden (UF), Reggie Nelson (UF), Chevis Jackson (LSU),
Honorable Mention: Derek Pegues (MSU), Captain Munnerlyn (USC), DJ Moore (VANDY), Kareem Jackson (UA)
S: La'Ron Landry (LSU), Eric Berry (UT)
PR: Javier Arenas (UA)
KR: Brandon James (UF)
Are you cereal? Eli Manning > every qb you listed, Dexter McCluster and Ingram over some of the other big time backs, the FB is Peyton Hillis from Arkansas, the TE is Jason Witten, Julio Jones is a joke right. Your defense is closer minus the obvious homeristic picks Cody and Kareem Jackson and the ommission of the DE from Florida's 06 NC team(Dunlap?)and Carlos Rodgers.
This post was edited on 2/14/10 at 12:55 pm
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:52 pm to TTsTowel
Don't look at NFL period. This is All SEC based on their college play.
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:54 pm to TTsTowel
quote:
Look at McFadden in the NFL..
And then go look at Caddy and Ronnie.
Caddy>McFadden
Ronnie>McFadden
Is the NFL the criteria? It's an SEC All Decade team. Not an All SEC NFL performance decade team.
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:54 pm to TTsTowel
quote:
in the NFL
quote:
SEC All Decade team
Do you not get?
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:55 pm to UASports23
Jason Witten should be the TE ahead of both Tamme and Hernandez, with Hernandez being 2nd.
John Henderson should clearly be above Marcus Spears. Henderson won the Outland trophy. Matter of fact, I'd have Albert Haynesworth ahead of Spears as well.
And no way in hell is Julio Jones on there.
John Henderson should clearly be above Marcus Spears. Henderson won the Outland trophy. Matter of fact, I'd have Albert Haynesworth ahead of Spears as well.
And no way in hell is Julio Jones on there.
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:57 pm to MagillaGuerilla
The cbs list is close although
Earl Bennett- no
Ingram over Caddy Williams
and anyone who says Eli Fricking Manning from his CFB days needs to be put down right now
Earl Bennett- no
Ingram over Caddy Williams
and anyone who says Eli Fricking Manning from his CFB days needs to be put down right now
Posted on 2/14/10 at 12:59 pm to Alahunter
I'll stick with my opinion.
Page 3 of 7
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News