Started By
Message
Which scenario would produce the most wins?
Posted on 4/30/13 at 7:40 am
Posted on 4/30/13 at 7:40 am
a. Roster full of nothing but 3 star athletes coached by Spurrier
or
b. Roster with all 5 star talent coached by Gene Chizik
or
b. Roster with all 5 star talent coached by Gene Chizik
6
Posted on 4/30/13 at 7:43 am to mwlewis
c. Roster full of 2 stars coached by Chris Petersen
Posted on 4/30/13 at 7:51 am to mwlewis
Depends which team is playing LSU's 2013 schedule and which team is playing Alabama's 2013 schedule
Posted on 4/30/13 at 7:51 am to mwlewis
1st year: Chizick's team wins
2nd year toss up
3rd & 4th years Spurrier's team wins.
2nd year toss up
3rd & 4th years Spurrier's team wins.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 7:56 am to spacewrangler
quote:
1st year: Chizick's team wins
2nd year toss up
3rd & 4th years Spurrier's team wins.
Eh, Chizik did beat a Spurrier team twice in his second year at Auburn.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:00 am to spacewrangler
quote:
1st year: Chizick's team wins
2nd year toss up
3rd & 4th years Spurrier's team wins.
Well played.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:00 am to Tigerbait337
quote:
Depends which team is playing LSU's 2013 schedule and which team is playing Alabama's 2013 schedule
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:06 am to Tigerbait337
Well that didn't take long.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:23 am to The Nino
quote:
Eh, Chizik did beat a Spurrier team twice in his second year at Auburn.
And once in his third year...
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:25 am to mwlewis
if it's all 5.7 3* players, then spurrier.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:26 am to The Nino
Cam Newton beat Carolina twice... and then Stephen Garcia beat Carolina the next year. But technically, Chiz did coach those teams.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:33 am to mwlewis
quote:
b. Roster with all 5 star talent coached by Gene Chizik
I would go with this. In the end, superior talent wins most of the time. Coaching definitely matters but there is only so much of a talent gap that superior coaching can overcome. The difference between Spurrier and Chizik isn't big enough to make up that significant of a talent gap. See 2010 SC v. AU games for example.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:40 am to UpstateCock2007
quote:
Cam Newton beat Carolina twice
Roster with 5 star talent
quote:Roster coached by Spurrier
Stephen Garcia beat Carolina the next year
Anyway, I agree with elposter. Superior talent wins out more times than not.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:46 am to mwlewis
If Chizik can win with two 5 stars (if Fairley was even a 5 star when he was recruited), then I'm guessing he can win with a roster full of 5 stars. It would all fall apart after a couple of years though. Plus we know that Spurrier can't win it all with 3 stars after how many years now at USCe?
Posted on 4/30/13 at 8:53 am to The Nino
quote:
Eh, Chizik did beat a Spurrier team twice in his second year at Auburn.
True, but it was his 1st year with the 5* talent that won him the games.
Actually, I think the 5* Chez teams would win 80% of the Time. That's just too much of a talent gap even after a few years of being coach by Chiz.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 10:04 am to Chadaristic
quote:
Well that didn't take long.
This coming from a fan of a team who's coach wanted to do away with the hurry up offense because it's "unfair" to the defense.
Posted on 4/30/13 at 10:37 am to rsande2
Has nothing to do with the thread topic.
Some of you frickers can figure out a ways to whine in every thread on this board. It's really kind of impressive and pathetic at the same time.
Please stay on topic.
You're not very good at this.
Some of you frickers can figure out a ways to whine in every thread on this board. It's really kind of impressive and pathetic at the same time.
Please stay on topic.
You're not very good at this.
Page 1 of 1
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News