
Started By
Message
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted on 11/19/26 at 2:25 pm to GenX Tar Heel
Posted on 11/19/26 at 2:25 pm to GenX Tar Heel
quote:
Yes, quantity is what is lifting the SEC. The B1G is lifted by both quantity and quality. The SEC could improve quality without expansion, but I see no signs of applicable efforts.
Wait. You think top to bottom the B1G is deeper than the SEC? There really is no point in continuing this, then.
Rankings staying like they are today the B1G has two teams that would make the CFP. The SEC has 4. Sure. This will change, but the B1G is top heavy. The SEC has quality and quantity.
And its been that way for 20 or so years. Are you not aware that the SEC had 7 straight National Championships won by 4 different teams?
But sure. The B1G has quality and quantity and the SEC lives off quantity.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 2:49 pm to DawgsLife
quote:
You use this phrase a lot, and i have no idea what you mean by upper-right....please explin what you mean.
An "upper-right" is a P4/P5 school that is among the best in both athletics (up/down) and academics (right/left). UNC, FLORIDA and TEXAS are all upper-rights. GEORGIA, BAMA and LSU are not.
I also never downvote. Those who do generally lack the maturity and intellectual honesty for a productive exchange,
This post was edited on 11/19/26 at 3:32 pm
Posted on 11/19/26 at 2:57 pm to DawgsLife
quote:
Wait. You think top to bottom the B1G is deeper than the SEC? There really is no point in continuing this, then.
You seem to regularly fail to understand things within the applicable context. in this context, "quantity" and "quality" are describing fanbases. To simplify into 3 binaries:
SEC: High quantity fanbases, low quality fanbases, high population growth
B1G: High quantity, high quality, low growth
ACC: Low quantity, high quality, high growth
Again, the average B1G or ACC viewer likely has a media value of ~2x+ of the average SEC. This is how academic standing impacts media value, which is a function of both quantity and quality of viewers.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 3:16 pm to GenX Tar Heel
quote:
An "upper-right" is a P4/P5 school that is among the best in both athletics 9ip/down) and academics (rightleft). UNC, FLORIDA and TEXAS are all upper-rights. GEORGIA, BAMA and LSU are not.
I'd say Georgia is pretty close. It's a fine school.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 3:20 pm to NickPapageorgio
quote:
UNC would be an easy top choice.
I think everyone in the conference, other than LSU, would prefer to have UNC at this point. Having Vandy, Florida, Texas and UNC means the SEC doesn't take a back seat to anyone in academics. Right up there with UCLA, USC and Michigan. I'd say Northwestern, but they're not in the same league for athletics.
This post was edited on 11/19/26 at 3:21 pm
Posted on 11/19/26 at 3:26 pm to RunningHog
It is the best school left on the board imo.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 3:29 pm to AUCE05
Lsu will always be an SEC member.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 3:30 pm to RunningHog
quote:
I'd say Georgia is pretty close. It's a fine school.
Not per the graph I reference; however, I have already noted efforts, improvement, and aspirations. GEORGIA is already there in overall athletics, a lite blue having finished 13x Top 10 D-Cup. For context.., the blue FLORIDA, TEXAS & UNC are at 32, 27 & 26 respectively.
The referenced graph is now ~4 years old, so I suspect that GEORGIA has moved right when most don't move much.
For discussion purposes, my point is that GEORGIA and FLORIDA have reached a point of improvement that the SEC now has few direct or general peers. Both are now historical ACC type schools rather than SEC (ignoring history/tradition).
Posted on 11/19/26 at 3:52 pm to GenX Tar Heel
quote:
the B1G will wither unless it can heavily and effectively expand south. Demography is destiny.
Based on what? This is pure conjecture or just a false narrative. The B1G still has major national brands in football and hoops. Media markets really don’t play as big a factor today with all four broadcast networks, ESPn, and the emergence of streaming which is sure to come. In football, which is still the tail that wags the dog, UNC is not a brand. In fact, the ACC has FSU, Miami and Clemson as significant brands and FSU is swirling the bowl with Clemson not far behind.
The SEC had plenty of viewership before the demographic shift.
What will be will be but I don’t put a lot of stock in some random AU goober posting that UNC has been contacted.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 3:58 pm to Night Vision
I’ve heard absolutely not a single word from our AD, President, Chair of the Board of Regents or any State Official on the subject of LSU, and I doubt that we will unless and until there are actual votes. This is our third year of membership in the Conference, so I think this is a matter best led by the 10 Conference members of the 1990 SEC membership.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 4:08 pm to JohnnyU
quote:
Based on what? This is pure conjecture or just a false narrative.
Based on demography being destiny. A shrinking pool from which to enroll students (including quality students) means dropping selectivity, in-state undergrad percentage, total undergrad enrollment. The States of TX and FL are now #2 and #3 respectively in population. VA, NC & GA have already passed (or will soon pass) MI, IL, OH & PA.
An example is the typical B1G uber-flag PSU. Selectively is now good (far from great/elite), its in-state percentage is ~50% (from a once normal ~85%), it's now dropping ~50 academic programs and closing satellite campuses. I suspect most core B1G members to follow this same road.
quote:
UNC is not a brand
UNC's brand in iconic and national/international. Recognized by the colors alone. The informed knew that this realignment would come down to a fight over UVA/UNC.
quote:
The SEC had plenty of viewership before the demographic shift.
There's a reason why the B1G remains more valuable than the SEC notwithstanding the material viewership quantity difference, namely the current quality difference. Given demo trends, the SEC can increase the quantity, increase quality. The core B1G cannot maintain its historical quantity/quality metrics.
Again, the SEC has been in contact with UNC for decades. A white whale target notwithstanding the LSU situation. In related news, water is wet. Night is dark,
This post was edited on 11/20/26 at 9:05 am
Posted on 11/19/26 at 4:08 pm to Giantkiller
Me too. The SEC screwed Oklahoma last week. They send conflicting signals to LSU. The SEC has its favorites. Time to move along.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 4:09 pm to The Orange Bull
No one give a flying frick what you think. You have enough to worry about with the makeup of your student body.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 4:12 pm to DawgsLife
Will SEC fans ever stop living in the past? The BCS and 4 team invitational are over. Bragging about 7 national titles in the past is like what Dabo is doing,
The BIG has won 3 straight Natties by 3 different teams. That’s where we are. So you can talk about how great you think you are but even SEC fans aren’t buying it anymore. And bragging about how many teams a committee puts in only means your conference will have more losses.
But, it will play out and I’ll be hear laughing again when the SEC falls short.
The BIG has won 3 straight Natties by 3 different teams. That’s where we are. So you can talk about how great you think you are but even SEC fans aren’t buying it anymore. And bragging about how many teams a committee puts in only means your conference will have more losses.
But, it will play out and I’ll be hear laughing again when the SEC falls short.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 4:19 pm to GenX Tar Heel
quote:
For discussion purposes, my point is that GEORGIA and FLORIDA have reached a point of improvement that the SEC now has few direct or general peers. Both are now historical ACC type schools rather than SEC (ignoring history/tradition).
You can take this to the bank. Georgia and Florida are not leaving the SEC. Neither are OU or Texas.
Posted on 11/19/26 at 5:20 pm to RunningHog
quote:
You can take this to the bank. Georgia and Florida are not leaving the SEC. Neither are OU or Texas.
I never claimed that they would. Nevertheless, two related scenarios were presented in this thread. LSU and others disgruntled leaving ~and~ FLORIDA now being a bad general fit. I simply played out a "what if". Also doesn't change the fact that most of the core SEC are no longer direct/general peers of GEORGIA and FLORIDA. VANDY has been that way for a long time.
Posted on 11/20/26 at 6:54 am to RunningJacket
quote:
Will SEC fans ever stop living in the past?
This from a Georgia Tech fan?
quote:We could brag about how we have more players drafted into the NFL.
Bragging about 7 national titles in the past is like what Dabo is doing,
quote:
The BIG has won 3 straight Natties by 3 different teams.
Yet when we won 7 by 4 different teams, y'all were screaming SEC bias!
quote:Well, yeah. DUH. Only two can play for a title. (Not that GT fans would know anything about that) So, yeah. The more teams that make the playoffs the more losses you will have.
And bragging about how many teams a committee puts in only means your conference will have more losses.
quote:And if the SEC wins it all this year? What will you hear then?
But, it will play out and I’ll be hear laughing again when the SEC falls short.
Oh, yeah. Laughing.
Posted on 11/20/26 at 6:58 am to GenX Tar Heel
quote:
An "upper-right" is a P4/P5 school that is among the best in both athletics (up/down) and academics (right/left). UNC, FLORIDA and TEXAS are all upper-rights. GEORGIA, BAMA and LSU are not.
Georgia most certainly is. Apparently you have no idea where Georgia stands academically. Of public universities Georgia is third in the SEC just behind Texas and Florida, so I would argue we are good. Tops in the nation? No. But still very good.
Of 2,177 public Universities in the United States, Georgia is ranked #19 according to US News and World Reports rankings.
Enjoyed talking to you, but this has run its course for me.
This post was edited on 11/20/26 at 7:01 am
Posted on 11/20/26 at 7:12 am to DawgsLife
quote:
Georgia most certainly is.
Nope... Not per my reference. Apparently you have no idea where GEORGIA stands in this context,
quote:
Of public universities Georgia is third in the SEC just behind Texas and Florida,
Sure, big gap. One ranking,,,,
Shanghai 2022 Academic Ranking of World Universities
Select Global and National/Regional Rank:
HARVARD 01 - 01
STANFORD 02 - 02
CAL 05 - 04
UCLA 13 - 11
WASH 17 - 14
MICH 28 - 19
UNC 29 - 20
DUKE 31 - 22
FL 94 - 28
GATECH 151-200 - 55-62
GEORGIA 301-400 - 86-106
The more you know? GEORGIA still doesn't have the academics to be considered upper-right.

Popular
Back to top



2





