GenX Tar Heel
| Favorite team: | North Carolina |
| Location: | |
| Biography: | |
| Interests: | |
| Occupation: | |
| Number of Posts: | 28 |
| Registered on: | 11/19/2026 |
| Online Status: | Not Online |
Recent Posts
Message
re: We’re All SEC…
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/20/26 at 3:59 pm to theballguy
quote:
LSU should be removed from the conference.
Can't wait for the fight over the Golden Ugg Boot!
re: The beginning of the end of the SEC
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/20/26 at 1:51 pm to Victor R Franko
An irony is that it was the NCAA rules to allow a CCG that was a material factor that got us to where we are. That's what caused the P5 consolidation/contraction.
A "do over" realignment could yield a regional P6. Perhaps a 10-team playoff with ~6 auto-bids. My concept a) accounts for history, brand, culture, b) no set membership number but 8 minimum, c) minimal force used only to mandate acceptable over preference.
Since this is an SEC board, my "do over" SEC is a rollback to the core 10,
A "do over" realignment could yield a regional P6. Perhaps a 10-team playoff with ~6 auto-bids. My concept a) accounts for history, brand, culture, b) no set membership number but 8 minimum, c) minimal force used only to mandate acceptable over preference.
Since this is an SEC board, my "do over" SEC is a rollback to the core 10,
re: The beginning of the end of the SEC
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/20/26 at 11:37 am to Cornpoptiger
I can see a series of events that result in an effective contraction back to smaller regionals. College isn't pro. Not just a single sport. Separate branding, culture & synergies natter.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/20/26 at 7:18 am to DawgsLife
BTW and FYI... Per the earlier referenced chart/graph, GEORGIA is a general academic peer of (e.g.) FSU, PSU, RUT & UTAH. Slightly behind VATECH & NCSTATE. Well behind original public ivys and equivalents which are upper-rights in contrast,
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/20/26 at 7:12 am to DawgsLife
quote:
Georgia most certainly is.
Nope... Not per my reference. Apparently you have no idea where GEORGIA stands in this context,
quote:
Of public universities Georgia is third in the SEC just behind Texas and Florida,
Sure, big gap. One ranking,,,,
Shanghai 2022 Academic Ranking of World Universities
Select Global and National/Regional Rank:
HARVARD 01 - 01
STANFORD 02 - 02
CAL 05 - 04
UCLA 13 - 11
WASH 17 - 14
MICH 28 - 19
UNC 29 - 20
DUKE 31 - 22
FL 94 - 28
GATECH 151-200 - 55-62
GEORGIA 301-400 - 86-106
The more you know? GEORGIA still doesn't have the academics to be considered upper-right.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 5:20 pm to RunningHog
quote:
You can take this to the bank. Georgia and Florida are not leaving the SEC. Neither are OU or Texas.
I never claimed that they would. Nevertheless, two related scenarios were presented in this thread. LSU and others disgruntled leaving ~and~ FLORIDA now being a bad general fit. I simply played out a "what if". Also doesn't change the fact that most of the core SEC are no longer direct/general peers of GEORGIA and FLORIDA. VANDY has been that way for a long time.
re: Watch LSU, Clemson, Fl St and Miami move to the Big 10 and suffocate the SEC
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 5:12 pm to Lsuhoohoo
quote:
You think if LSU was sitting out there as a free agent, that the B1G wouldn't move on them and others from the sinking ACC to strengthen their own position?
The B1G would take ~half of the current ACC and more former PAC before considering LSU. It's academic-centric brand is as important to the B1G as the geo-centric brand/culture is to the SEC.
Delusions yield poor decisions. Outside of the SEC, the BIG12 will be LSU's most viable option. A ND type arrangement would mean playing ~5 BIG12 schools annually in football.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 4:08 pm to JohnnyU
quote:
Based on what? This is pure conjecture or just a false narrative.
Based on demography being destiny. A shrinking pool from which to enroll students (including quality students) means dropping selectivity, in-state undergrad percentage, total undergrad enrollment. The States of TX and FL are now #2 and #3 respectively in population. VA, NC & GA have already passed (or will soon pass) MI, IL, OH & PA.
An example is the typical B1G uber-flag PSU. Selectively is now good (far from great/elite), its in-state percentage is ~50% (from a once normal ~85%), it's now dropping ~50 academic programs and closing satellite campuses. I suspect most core B1G members to follow this same road.
quote:
UNC is not a brand
UNC's brand in iconic and national/international. Recognized by the colors alone. The informed knew that this realignment would come down to a fight over UVA/UNC.
quote:
The SEC had plenty of viewership before the demographic shift.
There's a reason why the B1G remains more valuable than the SEC notwithstanding the material viewership quantity difference, namely the current quality difference. Given demo trends, the SEC can increase the quantity, increase quality. The core B1G cannot maintain its historical quantity/quality metrics.
Again, the SEC has been in contact with UNC for decades. A white whale target notwithstanding the LSU situation. In related news, water is wet. Night is dark,
re: Watch LSU, Clemson, Fl St and Miami move to the Big 10 and suffocate the SEC
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 3:48 pm to hookem33
It's actually quite amazing how much damage delusion has caused during the realignment, The PAC remainders, FSU, and now apparently LSU didn't/don't recognize their respective stations in this context.
At least the BIG12 remainders accepted reality ~2 months after the TX/OK news dropped.
At least the BIG12 remainders accepted reality ~2 months after the TX/OK news dropped.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 3:30 pm to RunningHog
quote:
I'd say Georgia is pretty close. It's a fine school.
Not per the graph I reference; however, I have already noted efforts, improvement, and aspirations. GEORGIA is already there in overall athletics, a lite blue having finished 13x Top 10 D-Cup. For context.., the blue FLORIDA, TEXAS & UNC are at 32, 27 & 26 respectively.
The referenced graph is now ~4 years old, so I suspect that GEORGIA has moved right when most don't move much.
For discussion purposes, my point is that GEORGIA and FLORIDA have reached a point of improvement that the SEC now has few direct or general peers. Both are now historical ACC type schools rather than SEC (ignoring history/tradition).
re: Watch LSU, Clemson, Fl St and Miami move to the Big 10 and suffocate the SEC
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 3:12 pm to Safety Blitz
quote:
You don’t look at tv ratings much do you?
You don't understand media value do you? Holistic/relative value?
re: Watch LSU, Clemson, Fl St and Miami move to the Big 10 and suffocate the SEC
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 3:09 pm to EV
quote:
B1G interest in FSU is incorrect
Did you mean disinteresr? Anyway, we know from history and pro reporting (including quotes from B!G Presidents) that there is little interest (if any) in FSU. This made worse by the barking and scorched earth.
The B1G's targets are....
Primary: ND, UNC & likely still UVA
Secondary: GATECH & MIAMI & STANFORD
Tertiary: UTAH & likely among KANSAS, CO, ARIZ, CAL
The SEC wants flagships and perhaps acceptable big brand private schools in the greater Southeast. The B1G wants high academic flagships, AAU, research institutions.
re: Watch LSU, Clemson, Fl St and Miami move to the Big 10 and suffocate the SEC
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 3:01 pm to Safety Blitz
quote:
They don’t have interest in UNC because your only a basketball school….those four offer the Big 10 something much bigger.
UNC has had a standing rejection of the SEC for decades, the B1G for years. ND/UNC are the primary targets of the B1G.
Adding the upper-right UNC is like adding a FLORIDA or TEXAS from a holistic/relative perspective. LSU isn't a UNC, sorry.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 2:57 pm to DawgsLife
quote:
Wait. You think top to bottom the B1G is deeper than the SEC? There really is no point in continuing this, then.
You seem to regularly fail to understand things within the applicable context. in this context, "quantity" and "quality" are describing fanbases. To simplify into 3 binaries:
SEC: High quantity fanbases, low quality fanbases, high population growth
B1G: High quantity, high quality, low growth
ACC: Low quantity, high quality, high growth
Again, the average B1G or ACC viewer likely has a media value of ~2x+ of the average SEC. This is how academic standing impacts media value, which is a function of both quantity and quality of viewers.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 2:49 pm to DawgsLife
quote:
You use this phrase a lot, and i have no idea what you mean by upper-right....please explin what you mean.
An "upper-right" is a P4/P5 school that is among the best in both athletics (up/down) and academics (right/left). UNC, FLORIDA and TEXAS are all upper-rights. GEORGIA, BAMA and LSU are not.
I also never downvote. Those who do generally lack the maturity and intellectual honesty for a productive exchange,
re: Watch LSU, Clemson, Fl St and Miami move to the Big 10 and suffocate the SEC
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 2:42 pm to Safety Blitz
Except that the B1G has little (if any) interest in LSU or FSU and only contingent interest in CLEMSON,
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 11:52 am to DawgsLife
quote:
Bysettling with UNC, FSU and Miami? And lowering the buyout at their demands? They were trying to stave off elimination, not being proactive.
Nope... It's all interconnected. Adding the dilutive CAL+2 over objections was a breach of the GOR. The ACC had to keep the 3 financially whole. CAL+2 came in at a discount that finances the settlement. UNC has political [barriers]. CLEMSON/FSU don't have non-contingent invites to the SEC or B1G, hence the broad settlement.
quote:
I think the SEC would be interested in Virginia Tech,
We know from history and pro reporting that the SEC is focused on its white whales: UVA & [UNC]. NCSTATE is the better option than VATECH, but again if ~24 each Tier 1 P2, the SEC would target both pairs.
quote:
Florida would try to block FSU or Miami
a) The SEC likely remains uninterested in MIAMI and b) MIAMI would prefer a 24-member B1G, I think that a 24 SEC should secure all of the flags, #2, and big brands from VA down to FL 9except perhaps VATECH), but I accept realities.
quote:
If you think the B1G and SEC is going to a 24 team conference and not taking 2-3 ACC teams then there is nothing more to discuss.
I made no such claim. In fact, I wrote the opposite.
quote:
You can believe that all you want.
If GEORGIA has no aspirations to be an upper-right, then perhaps a contracted ACC would have no interest. FLORIDA is already upper-right.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 11:41 am to DawgsLife
quote:
I get what you are saying, but quaity matters.
Yes, quantity is what is lifting the SEC. The B1G is lifted by both quantity and quality. The SEC could improve quality without expansion, but I see no signs of applicable efforts.
quote:
last additions to the ACC has been Cal, SMU and Stanford
CAL+2 would not be members of a contracted ACC. They are preemptive backfill for UNC+. The topic of this exchange is a contracted ACC, which would be a better long-term investment than the B1G and perhaps SEC. A core ACC viewer is likely worth ~2x+ that of a core SEC viewer. Population growth would close the quantity gap,
quote:
Your only hope is if LSU wants to join IF they leave or get kicked out of the SEC.
Nope.... LSU (or ND) joining the current ACC would not prevent material depletion. Again, the topic is a contracted ACC.
quote:
I doubt very seriously if LSU leaves or is kicked out. I think it is all gamesmanship, but...who actually knows?
If LSU is either unwilling and/or unable to comply with SEC rules, there are only 2 options: A granted exception or expulsion. As an outsider, too many on this board are focused on some final straw(s) when it's clear to me that there have been a thousand straws prior,
If LSU is kicked or leaves the SEC in some other manner, its only viable option is the BIG12. What happens with LSU has little impact on the SEC/UNC situation. A departure would raise the average academic standing of the conference and perhaps allow for a bonus coattail.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 11:17 am to Tiger Prawn
quote:
Now what about subtractions? Because LSU is a pretty fricking big subtraction on media rights.
The SEC's current deal is apparently already far below current market value. Replacing with the more iconic brand and higher media value per viewer UNC would effectively net zero, with UNC providing lift elsewhere (e.g. mitigating the student apocalypse
quote:).
But $147M exit fee is a big pill to swallow.
a) The cost bottoms out at ~$75M in ~2030, b) The numbers math that getting the increased payout sooner covers the higher exit costs. c) UNC's barriers to move are low desire and political, not financial.
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 11:10 am to DawgsLife
quote:
Why? I mean they are doing just fine right now. So, I am missing your reasoning.
Demos. Falling quantity and quality of the alum and extended fanbases. PSU is on the leading edge of this decline, now accepting 5 applicants to net 1 enrollment.
quote:
But your contracted example of the ACC included Florida and Georgia, and i can assure you neither has any inclination of leaving the SEC.
Even without GEORGIA/FLORIDA, a contracted ACC should work. Fast-growing footprint. High media value per viewer.
quote:
Even if they did, Alabama is the prize of the SEC, followed by Georgia Texas, Oklahoma and LSU.
Not really. Synergies and geo matter. TEXAS and FLORIDA are the prizes. GA's value would be increased due to synergies. BAMA, OK & LSU would be unnecessary bad fits in a contracted ACC. Value is holistic and relative.
A contracted ACC would have far different football and basketball values. UNC's own studies blamed falling attendance and viewership on failed expansions, A round robin in football and back to home/aways in basketball with high value per viewer would cause a major lift.
In the bigger picture and ignoring geo, etc., FLORIDA, VANDY, TEXAS, TXAM, & GEORGIA (with aspirations) are "Alliance" type schools rather than historical SEC,
re: UNC has been contacted
Posted by GenX Tar Heel on 11/19/26 at 10:46 am to Tiger Prawn
quote:
UNC football is a FAR stretch from a big ratings draw. Right off the bat, ESPN would be demanding to renegotiate the TV contract to a lesser value to compensate for that loss.
a) This isn't just about football or even athletics. As an upper-right, a UNC viewer is likely worth ~2x that for LSU. This also applies to a TEXAS and FLORIDA.
b) It's been reported that the SEC has a pro rata, though perhaps for staggered additions.
quote:
Meaning that even if UNC were to leave the ACC, the ACC would still own all of their TV media rights until 2036.
Nope... There was a settlement ~2 years ago capitalizing all costs to exit the ACC.
Popular
0












