Started By
Message

WDE24's Top 5 SEC RB's - Week 3
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:28 am
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:28 am
It's that time again. Feedback, insults, debate and disagreement are welcomed. They are usually more productive if you put homerism aside and provide info on who you think should be on the list, who should be left off and why. Please understand the criteria listed below for this list before responding.
As always this list chronicles the top SEC running backs by production on the field to date for the current season. Objective statistics are the primary criteria utilized in formulating this list, however, the statistics are set into context based on the quality of opponent upon which the statistics were accumulated. In some instances where the choice is close, a subjective eye test is also taken into account. However, hype, injuries, suspensions, etc. are not. This isn't a list of most talented or a prediction of NFL draft status. It is just an unbiased look at which 5 SEC RB's are getting the job done the best on the field. As such, this list will likely drastically change each week, especially early in the season.
Without further adieu:
1. Todd Gurley - Still the easy choice here.
2. Mike Davis - His most recent performance wasn't as good or efficient as his first 2, but he is still getting the job done against 3 quality opponents in the first 3 weeks.
3. WILCO - I'm putting Johnathan Williams and Alex Collins here tied at 3. I originally had these 2 at 4th behind Yeldon, but the weakness of aTm's run D combined with the fumble issues caused me to re-evaluate. Their numbers are extraordinarily impressive and there is a chance that one of these backs could climb to the top of these rankings in time. However, in a list where we are comparing RBs throughout the SEC, the lack of any quality opponents makes it very difficult to compare these two with most others in the conference. In 2 or 3 more weeks we should have a better understanding of these 2.
5. Jeff Scott - He and Corey Grant are carrying their respective teams at times by using explosive running plays while getting limited touches in comparison to most of the other backs on this list. Scott had the better week 3 game and edges Corey Grant out this week. Additionally, Scott's ypg fro scrimmage has him edge out TJ Yeldon for the 4th slot.
First One Out. TJ Yeldon - solid performances against quality teams (although only one quality defense). Still, both opponents are BCS bowl conference opponents, so he almost slides into the list at number 5 for the first time this season. TJ also has to take better care of the ball if he wishes to move up this list (and I know from a good source -buccwildbammer - that he does).
Honorable Mentions: Corey Grant, Rajon Neal, Jeremy Hill.
As always this list chronicles the top SEC running backs by production on the field to date for the current season. Objective statistics are the primary criteria utilized in formulating this list, however, the statistics are set into context based on the quality of opponent upon which the statistics were accumulated. In some instances where the choice is close, a subjective eye test is also taken into account. However, hype, injuries, suspensions, etc. are not. This isn't a list of most talented or a prediction of NFL draft status. It is just an unbiased look at which 5 SEC RB's are getting the job done the best on the field. As such, this list will likely drastically change each week, especially early in the season.
Without further adieu:
1. Todd Gurley - Still the easy choice here.
2. Mike Davis - His most recent performance wasn't as good or efficient as his first 2, but he is still getting the job done against 3 quality opponents in the first 3 weeks.
3. WILCO - I'm putting Johnathan Williams and Alex Collins here tied at 3. I originally had these 2 at 4th behind Yeldon, but the weakness of aTm's run D combined with the fumble issues caused me to re-evaluate. Their numbers are extraordinarily impressive and there is a chance that one of these backs could climb to the top of these rankings in time. However, in a list where we are comparing RBs throughout the SEC, the lack of any quality opponents makes it very difficult to compare these two with most others in the conference. In 2 or 3 more weeks we should have a better understanding of these 2.
5. Jeff Scott - He and Corey Grant are carrying their respective teams at times by using explosive running plays while getting limited touches in comparison to most of the other backs on this list. Scott had the better week 3 game and edges Corey Grant out this week. Additionally, Scott's ypg fro scrimmage has him edge out TJ Yeldon for the 4th slot.
First One Out. TJ Yeldon - solid performances against quality teams (although only one quality defense). Still, both opponents are BCS bowl conference opponents, so he almost slides into the list at number 5 for the first time this season. TJ also has to take better care of the ball if he wishes to move up this list (and I know from a good source -buccwildbammer - that he does).
Honorable Mentions: Corey Grant, Rajon Neal, Jeremy Hill.
This post was edited on 9/16/13 at 9:41 am
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:30 am to WDE24
Magee > yeldon. Punish the terrible fumble.
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:35 am to BigEdLSU
quote:Much like Corey Grant, his lack of touches is hurting him on this list. That combined with not doing much with limited touches against the likes of UAB.
Magee > yeldon.
quote:I dropped him from 3 to 4 based mostly on the fumble issue.
Punish the terrible fumble.
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:36 am to parkjas2001
i think the minimal touches pushes grant and scott higher on the list for getting so many yards per rush. and scott had over 24o all purpose yards and a punt return. he should be higher
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:37 am to taste the rainbow
LOL WEREN'T YOU AN MSU FAN YESTERDAY
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:38 am to Landsharks
one of the guys who uses the account was. he was on all last night. im an ole miss and air force fan
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:42 am to WDE24
Terrible list, Alex Collins and Jonathan Williams are both top 7 nationally. But you don't think that matters because of the competition? Most teams have played nothing but terrible opponents so that point is invalid. They should both be top 5 individually in the SEC if they're top 7 in the country.
This post was edited on 9/16/13 at 8:44 am
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:44 am to Stonehog
He said they were tied at #3 

Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:44 am to taste the rainbow
You guys know that accounts are free right?
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:45 am to Stonehog
quote:It matters, but how much does it matter. The level of competition makes it difficult to evaluate.
But you don't think that matters because of the competition?
quote:Name one player on this list that has played as shitty of a schedule so far as WILCO. Hell, name any BCS conference running back that has played such an easy slate for 3 weeks.
Most teams have played nothing but terrible opponents so that point is invalid.
quote:That logic doesn't hold up based on the criteria of the list. Nevertheless, they are both top 5 on this list.
They should both be top 5 individually in the SEC if they're top 10 in the country.
This post was edited on 9/16/13 at 8:46 am
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:48 am to LSUsuperfresh
If it's a ranking of the top 5 running backs in the SEC, you can't have a tie. That makes 6. If this list was legit it would have Collins at #1 and Williams at #2.
This is supposed to be a week to week ranking, but WDE is coming up with new parameters every time. Now it's no longer a ranking of the best running backs, just ones who have played opponents that WDE deems acceptable.
This is supposed to be a week to week ranking, but WDE is coming up with new parameters every time. Now it's no longer a ranking of the best running backs, just ones who have played opponents that WDE deems acceptable.
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:49 am to WDE24
Alex Collins is the first running back in SEC history to rush for 100+ yds in his first 3 games.
Will he break his own record this week at Rutgers and make it 4 straight?
Will he break his own record this week at Rutgers and make it 4 straight?
This post was edited on 9/16/13 at 8:50 am
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:49 am to Stonehog
quote:I considered this, but decided I would allow it this week because of the unique situation that Arky has presented me with.
If it's a ranking of the top 5 running backs in the SEC, you can't have a tie. That makes 6.
quote:No, it is cumulative.
This is supposed to be a week to week ranking
quote:The parameters have always been the same.
but WDE is coming up with new parameters every time.
quote:No, it is a list of the best RBs taking into account quality of opponent as it should be.
Now it's no longer a ranking of the best running backs, just ones who have played opponents that WDE deems acceptable.
This post was edited on 9/16/13 at 8:51 am
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:50 am to Stonehog
quote:
If this list was legit it would have Collins at #1 and Williams at #2.
lulz on lulz on lulz
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:54 am to WDE24
Yep, Mike Davis is crushing it.
He is a shifty back, but built like a bruiser. He'll be a good one.
He is a shifty back, but built like a bruiser. He'll be a good one.
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:54 am to WDE24
quote:
The parameters have always been the same.
Oh really? Did you read the first half of your own post?
quote:
I considered this, but decided I would allow it this week because of the unique situation that Arky has presented me with.
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:56 am to Stonehog
quote:Yes. You think having a tie changes the parameters for making the list? I hope you are trolling because if not, wow.
Oh really? Did you read the first half of your own post?
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:58 am to WDE24
What's your response to Collins doing something Dmac, Bo, and Herschel didn't?
Posted on 9/16/13 at 8:58 am to WDE24
You said the parameters have always been the same, but you decided to change them this week because of our schedule.
Collins leads the conference in rushing and you have him third, that alone makes the list invalid. Not just calling the list "Top 5 SEC RB's" when you have 6.
Collins leads the conference in rushing and you have him third, that alone makes the list invalid. Not just calling the list "Top 5 SEC RB's" when you have 6.
Back to top
