Started By
Message
Ingram or McFadden?
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:51 am
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:51 am
Which one would you take?
17
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:53 am to MSTiger33
Ingram has the hardware. 
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:54 am to MSTiger33
D-Mac for the versatility. Ingram is a far stronger runner, but D-Mac was pure excitement with the ball in his hands.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:54 am to Roaad
McFadden and I wouldn't think twice.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:56 am to MSTiger33
Had mcfadden gone to bama they would say mcfadden.
Had ingram gone to arkansas they would say ingram.
Had ingram gone to arkansas they would say ingram.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:57 am to pioneerbasketball
McFadden and it's not really close imo.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:57 am to MSTiger33
d-mac in a heartbeat. without felix there, he would have smashed every record in the book
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:58 am to MSTiger33
right now, Darren McFadden.... but Ingram is just a Sophomore... that might change after next season.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 10:59 am to MSTiger33
The Arkansas offensive was actually better opening up holes in the running game then Alabama's. Hell, McFadden's backup averaged two to three more yards per carry then him. The Arkansas OL played a much bigger role in McFadden's success then Alabama's OL has for Ingram. It's funny how pedestrian McFadden has looked in the NFL without gigantic holes to run through. Give me Ingram for the win.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:00 am to Bench McElroy
McFadden the Sophomore:
Rushing: 1,647 -18 TD's
Receiving: 149 - 1 TD
Returning: 262 - 1 TD
Throwing: 69 - 3 TD's
2,127 APY for 23 TD's (2,038 & 23 TD's pre-bowl)
Soph year:
Doak Walker Winner, Jim Brown winner, SEC Offensive POY
Ingram the Sophomore
Rushing: 1,542 yards - 15 TD's
Receiving: 322 yards - 3 TD's
1,864 APY for 18 TD's
Soph year:
No Doak or SEC Offensive POY.....But now has a Heisman
Rushing: 1,647 -18 TD's
Receiving: 149 - 1 TD
Returning: 262 - 1 TD
Throwing: 69 - 3 TD's
2,127 APY for 23 TD's (2,038 & 23 TD's pre-bowl)
Soph year:
Doak Walker Winner, Jim Brown winner, SEC Offensive POY
Ingram the Sophomore
Rushing: 1,542 yards - 15 TD's
Receiving: 322 yards - 3 TD's
1,864 APY for 18 TD's
Soph year:
No Doak or SEC Offensive POY.....But now has a Heisman
This post was edited on 12/13/09 at 11:04 am
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:04 am to woopiginaustin
who won the heisman Mcfadden's sophomore year?
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:05 am to lowspark12
Troy Smith, and that's a shame.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:06 am to woopiginaustin
quote:
woopiginaustin
I guess this shows everyone how important a team plays as a whole. If the pigs went undefeated in D-Mac's year then he would have the hardware.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:07 am to pioneerbasketball
quote:
Had mcfadden gone to bama they would say mcfadden.
Had ingram gone to arkansas they would say ingram.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:08 am to MSTiger33
McFadden. But I can't wait to see what Ingram does.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:08 am to MSTiger33
His Junior campaign was even more even impressive than his Sophomore campaign, but the Tebow love-fest was too much to over come in his second attempt at the hardware.
Darren's teams having 8 and 10 wins didn't help much either.
Darren's teams having 8 and 10 wins didn't help much either.
This post was edited on 12/13/09 at 11:09 am
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:10 am to woopiginaustin
quote:Tebow scored 50 total TD's.
His Junior campaign was even more even impressive than his Sophomore campaign, but the Tebow love-fest was too much to over come in his
Hard to argue with that one.
D-Mac got jobbed by Troy Smith, though.
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:14 am to lowspark12
McFadden had more carries for less yards per carry. Both are excellent backs
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:25 am to Schwaaz
McFadden SEC Rankings:
Yards gained
Game: 321 --#1
Season: 1,830 --#2
Career: 4,590 --#2
Yards per Rush
Game: 9.44 --#3
All-Purpose:
Game: 355 --#4
Season: 2,310 --#1
Career: 5,881 --#2
Career Yards per Game:
154 --#3
Career Yards per Carry:
5.85 --#5
End of thread
Yards gained
Game: 321 --#1
Season: 1,830 --#2
Career: 4,590 --#2
Yards per Rush
Game: 9.44 --#3
All-Purpose:
Game: 355 --#4
Season: 2,310 --#1
Career: 5,881 --#2
Career Yards per Game:
154 --#3
Career Yards per Carry:
5.85 --#5
End of thread
Posted on 12/13/09 at 11:33 am to woopiginaustin
I prefer Ingram.
Mcfadden was faster, but Ingram leading the country with runs of 15+ yards shows he has plenty of big play ability. I just love Ingram's violent style and his ability to break tackles. Mcfadden's legs go dead on contact.
Mcfadden was faster, but Ingram leading the country with runs of 15+ yards shows he has plenty of big play ability. I just love Ingram's violent style and his ability to break tackles. Mcfadden's legs go dead on contact.
Page 1 of 3
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News