Started By
Message
0
Posted on 8/4/26 at 8:21 am to Diego Ricardo
quote:
quote:
No True Scotsman fallacy. Got it.
Non sequitur!
STRAW MAN!
I would say it was more of a false equivalence. He didn't engage with your assertion that "true fans" do such and such, but rather overapplied the rules of "No true Scotsman."
Posted on 8/4/26 at 9:07 am to crimsoncoded94
quote:
Ty was rewarded for his ability to not turn the ball over more than anything.
Are you referring to his injury or suggesting both Mack and Russell were just better capable of running the offense more effectively last year and the coaches refused to play them?
Because while I hope you’re right that we have two guys who are apparently top 10 NFL draft picks, somehow I doubt they were outplaying Ty in practice and we just didn’t hear about it.
What I suspect is that Mack has Ty level knowledge of the offense (awareness) and one of the best deep balls since Mac/Tua, but lacks consistency in the short and intermediate accuracy department and that KR potentially can be BY level good in terms of accuracy and improvisation but is still coming along in other areas leaving the coaches to decide which gives us a better shot to win this year.
Posted on 8/4/26 at 12:10 pm to tide06
Very well stated.
Posted on 8/4/26 at 1:23 pm to tattoo
I also just don’t think Mack was clearly getting beaten out in practice or why would he have gotten the snaps in the Rose Bowl and then stuck around going into the spring?
What I suspect is the two were close with KR trailing or roughly tied going into A-Day and we saw a peak KR day and Mack was either hurt or just not sharp.
I just can’t believe Mack would’ve been around or be talked about by the coaches the way he is if KR was consistently beating him out and that’s coming from someone who thinks KR has a superstar ceiling.
What I suspect is the two were close with KR trailing or roughly tied going into A-Day and we saw a peak KR day and Mack was either hurt or just not sharp.
I just can’t believe Mack would’ve been around or be talked about by the coaches the way he is if KR was consistently beating him out and that’s coming from someone who thinks KR has a superstar ceiling.
Posted on 8/4/26 at 6:33 pm to tide06
Mack was hurt during the spring camp, Coaches said that.
Posted on 8/4/26 at 9:31 pm to Panthers4life
Posted on 8/4/26 at 10:57 pm to Panthers4life
quote:
Mack was hurt during the spring camp, Coaches said that.
Coaches said that after A-Day was over. We didn't hear anything beforehand that he was hurt. I'm not 100% convinced it wasn't KDB giving Mack an out for playing bad for his loyalty.
Page 3 of 3
Latest Alabama News
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News