Started By
Message
Kirby Smart vs Nick Saban
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:36 pm
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:36 pm
Compare and predict the future success of Alabama and Georgia under their current head coaches leadership: Justify your answer with precise skills and advantages Kirby Smart has over Nick Saban or vice-versa?
IMO - Kirby has no advantages over Nick Saban and Alabama will continue to dominate the SEC and Georgia. I don't think Kirby has 15% of Sabans coaching skills and as a result will achieve 15% of Sabans success. Interpret it this way: If Saban coached Alabama against Kirby & Georgia 100 times I think Saban would win 85 times.
IMO - Kirby has no advantages over Nick Saban and Alabama will continue to dominate the SEC and Georgia. I don't think Kirby has 15% of Sabans coaching skills and as a result will achieve 15% of Sabans success. Interpret it this way: If Saban coached Alabama against Kirby & Georgia 100 times I think Saban would win 85 times.
This post was edited on 5/12/18 at 12:26 am
17
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:41 pm to TrendingRight
quote:
15% of Sabans success.
So 1 national title and 1-2 SEC Titles?
Already halfway to #2. Impressive.
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:43 pm to TrendingRight
quote:
I don't think Kirby has 15% of Sabans coaching skills
That's just silly.
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:43 pm to TrendingRight
Kirby has Georgia...... a Legit coach that can lock down Georgia is a danger. Bama can’t win shite with just Alabama kids. That’s just the facts. Y’all have been blessed with Saban and national recruiting, but Urban, Herman, Fisher, and even O have hassled Saban out of Texas, y’all get 1or 2 from LA, but Georgia/Atlanta was your area. Ole Kirby knows this and has started to change that culture
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:46 pm to TrendingRight
In Kirby’s defense....he was kicking Bama’s arse late in the second half of the National Championship when Saban abandoned his starting QB, to save fate, and threw in a freshman and won in overtime against a second year head coach. Kirby’s out recruiting Saban...but Kirby is only 15%.
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:47 pm to ugastreaker
quote:
he was kicking Bama’s arse late in the second half of the National Championship
Erroneous
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:49 pm to ugastreaker
quote:
In Kirby’s defense....he was kicking Bama’s arse late in the second half of the National Championship when Saban abandoned his starting QB, to save fate, and threw in a freshman and won in overtime against a second year head coach. Kirby’s out recruiting Saban...but Kirby is only 15%.
Did...did you not watch the game? The freshman came out at the start of the 2nd half You hurt your argument when you say stuff like this.
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:52 pm to randomways
Was UGA still not in the lead late in the 2nd half?
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:54 pm to KSGamecock
quote:
That's just silly.
In a direct comparison of career achievements I don't believe Kirby will be in any way comparable to Nick Saban.
Kirby isn't a genius. Nick Saban is a football genius and among the one, two, or three greatest College Football coaches of all time. Kirby will never rank much higher than a slightly above average coach. Kirby may win a NC and he may win a few SEC Championships. He will not go on to win multiple NCs or be considered a "Great" coach. Kirby was in the right place at the right time. Kirby isn't the critical thinker Nick Saban is and I would defer to Sabans decisions 100% of the time.
This post was edited on 5/11/18 at 11:57 pm
Posted on 5/11/18 at 11:55 pm to ugastreaker
quote:
Was UGA still not in the lead late in the 2nd half?
Did you not get a Georgia education? I pointed out your mistake in very plain terms. It wasn't a complicated post. And Bama outscored UGA in the second half by as many points as UGA outscored Bama in the first. And outscored UGA over the course of the entire game.
Oh, and upvoting yourself is pathetic
Posted on 5/12/18 at 12:03 am to randomways
It was 20-10 going into the 4th quarter and I haven’t upvoted nor down voted anyone jackass. Sorry for ruining your night with facts.
Posted on 5/12/18 at 12:06 am to TrendingRight
quote:
IMO - Kirby has no advantages over Nick Saban and Alabama will continue to dominate the SEC and Georgia. I don't think Kirby has 15% of Sabans coaching skills and as a result will achieve 15% of Sabans success.
This is just idiotic.Bama had a big talent advantage on
both LOS's,WR and DB and needed an OT bomb to win the game. You had 12 guys drafted vs our 6 and the gap will be wider next year.
Nick wins because he signs the best talent every year and does a pretty good job developing them.Its pretty
simple.
Posted on 5/12/18 at 12:10 am to randomways
What makes a great coach is his gray matter. Brains are the tools of Champions and Alabama has had more football Head Coach geniuses than any other College football team. Alabama's current coach is an unqualified genius - maybe the GOAT. Kirby walked into a good program well stocked with athletes in a weak SEC Eastern Conference and got lucky in the SEC Championship and Playoff games. Georgia played well until faced with the Nick Saban's genius. Kirby wilted major league under Saban's mammoth brainpower.
This post was edited on 5/12/18 at 12:19 am
Posted on 5/12/18 at 12:18 am to TrendingRight
So a year 2 coach in a sub par division manages to get lucky in the SECCG, against a team that beat you, but wins by 20, Then goes across the country and wins a rose bowl against the highest scoring offense in the land, then leads the undeserving Dawgs to a late lead into the 4th quarter before the GOAT ties to go to OT and win....and wilted? frick you and the horse you rode in on. Saban knows he got lucky on a busted play in OT. If BAMA was so good, shouldn’t he Natty have played out a little different....like Bama leading most of the game?
Posted on 5/12/18 at 12:21 am to ugastreaker
quote:If that Fairy Tale helps you sleep at night - go ahead and believe it.
So a year 2 coach in a sub par division manages to get lucky in the SECCG, against a team that beat you, but wins by 20, Then goes across the country and wins a rose bowl against the highest scoring offense in the land, then leads the undeserving Dawgs to a late lead into the 4th quarter before the GOAT ties to go to OT and win....and wilted? frick you and the horse you rode in on. Saban knows he got lucky on a busted play in OT. If BAMA was so good, shouldn’t he Natty have played out a little different....like Bama leading most of the game?
Truth is Georgia got outcoached and physically beaten when the chips were down and a NC was on the line. That's all there is to say.
PS: And Alabama should have won it in regulation - the game should never have gone to OT and you know it.
This post was edited on 5/12/18 at 12:24 am
Posted on 5/12/18 at 12:29 am to TrendingRight
quote:
Alabama will continue to dominate the SEC
Didn’t even win the West last year. frick off dipshit
Posted on 5/12/18 at 12:34 am to craigbiggio
quote:What would you give to have Alabama's sh*tty team last year?
Didn’t even win the West last year. frick off dipshit
Posted on 5/12/18 at 12:36 am to TrendingRight
quote:
Brains are the tools of Champions
Clearly not one of your tools.
quote:
walked into a good program well stocked with athletes
Our talent level wasn't near Bama last season and wasn't close in '16 (not one Sr drafted and a Jr was the only player drafted in the 4th rd)
quote:
and got lucky in the SEC Championship
What?We out gained AU 421 to 259 and were knocking on the door to score another TD and outscored them 28-7.We also outgained OU and held their offense to 7pts in 2nd half while they also got a scoop and score on defense...nothing "lucky" about either outcome.This post was edited on 5/12/18 at 12:38 am
Posted on 5/12/18 at 1:01 am to TrendingRight
quote:
Truth is Georgia got outcoached and physically beaten when the chips were down and a NC was on the line. That's all there is to say.
Georgia lost for two reasons:
1. Kirby/Chaney forgot Sony Michel existed.
2. Da'Ron Payne and Dashawn Hand absolutely mutilated the inside of our OL and stuffed every Nick Chubb run up the middle.
Posted on 5/12/18 at 1:02 am to TrendingRight
quote:
I don't think
Should have ended your typing here.
Page 1 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News