
Started By
Message
Questions for those who have experienced low back pain
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:23 am
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:23 am
Do you recommend seeing a primary care physician or should I go see a chiropractor? I'm in decent shape, do not carry any extra weight, but believe I've either had some wear and tear over the years or tweaked it a while ago and never let it heal. Either way, I hooped last night and I can barely walk today. It is significantly worse than ever before. Low back and a little pain on one side of my buttocks.
Not asking for actual medical advice, but I have an HSA, so I don't want to waste the $ seeing a PCP if he's going to recommend a specialist or chiropractor anyways. Pls halp.
Not asking for actual medical advice, but I have an HSA, so I don't want to waste the $ seeing a PCP if he's going to recommend a specialist or chiropractor anyways. Pls halp.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:29 am to cas4t
I dealt with lower back pain for years. I didn't have much luck with chiropractors. Physical therapy helped more than anything in the early stages of it. Lie on your back on a hard floor, legs straight out, and arms straight back above your head. Keep that position for a few minutes and you'll get a little relief. Also helps to lie in that position and pull your knees up into your chest and hold that position. Then twisting from side to side with your knees in your chest helps as well.
It probably wouldn't hurt to go see your doctor, but he'll just send you for an MRI. There's not much he can do without knowing the underlying cause. He may give you some mild pain relievers and some muscle relaxers.
Neither really helped mine though.
I finally had to have surgery.
It probably wouldn't hurt to go see your doctor, but he'll just send you for an MRI. There's not much he can do without knowing the underlying cause. He may give you some mild pain relievers and some muscle relaxers.
Neither really helped mine though.
I finally had to have surgery.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:31 am to cas4t
You need to stretch your hamstrings, quads, and glutes
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:31 am to cas4t
A PCP is NEVER going to recommend a chiropractor.
Personally, I recommend a chiropractor. I'm not a doctor, but I play one on TV
Personally, I recommend a chiropractor. I'm not a doctor, but I play one on TV
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:33 am to cas4t
You should see a neurosurgeon and have a MRI. 99% chance he will go conservative with physical therapy...good. You'll know what you are truly dealing with and approaching it slowly. If it gets bad enough, you'll both agree on surgery. Do not use an orthopedic doc for your back even if he specializes. You need a nerve guy.
Chiro can do very little and sometimes do more damage. This just happened to a friend of mine a month ago.
I have 40 years of back probs. Three surgeries and waiting on the fourth.
***Get a back compression belt. Wear it when moving.***
Chiro can do very little and sometimes do more damage. This just happened to a friend of mine a month ago.
I have 40 years of back probs. Three surgeries and waiting on the fourth.
***Get a back compression belt. Wear it when moving.***
This post was edited on 3/9/16 at 8:45 am
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:39 am to Mizzou Mule
Thanks everyone. I have Teledoc as an option. Basically they call you and walk through problems over the phone. Obviously he can't do anything over the phone regarding low back pain but maybe the doc can push me through to physical therapy?
I know I need an MRI. I'm going to have to get rid of this HSA come September when I get married. I've officially out-aged it.
I know I need an MRI. I'm going to have to get rid of this HSA come September when I get married. I've officially out-aged it.
This post was edited on 3/9/16 at 8:52 am
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:41 am to The Spleen
Thanks for the tips. I'm familiar with those stretches and will do them much more. I don't want surgery, but it seems to be common for these things.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:43 am to Mizzou Mule
Getting a neurosurgeons opinion is not a bad idea. I had ongoing neck problems for years, when I finally decided to see one. Thankfully he was honest and told me he could do surgery but one would more than likely lead to more. He recommended PT which I did for about three months with no relief. Finally in desperation I tried a Chiropractor, he worked on me for about a month along with some stretches I did on my own, been pain free for about five years now.
I would recommend doing your homework on picking one tho.
I would recommend doing your homework on picking one tho.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:45 am to Person of interest
Find a GOOD neurosurgeon...do your homework. Only about 25% qualify as good. Ask other docs, pharmacist, nurses and other people in health care biz. I have a friend in medical sales...he knows the scoop or can find out.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 8:51 am to Mizzou Mule
Fortunately I work on large market insurance in Nashville and we have a number of healthcare clients. One being Vanderbilt. So I believe I will start there. Thanks again. Neurosurgeon route it is.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 9:16 am to cas4t
I have had lower back pain that escalated eventually to a buttcheek and down a leg. Means that a nerve is getting abused in some way. Could be discs, inflammation, lotta things. The chiropractor can't fix all of those things so technically you should at least see a doc. The chiro might provide temporary relief.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 9:19 am to Mizzou Mule
quote:
99% chance he will go conservative with physical therapy
This is my experience.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 9:29 am to cas4t
I put off surgery for 5 or 6 years and just did physical therapy, a few nerve blocks, and lots of lortabs. Somehow I didn't get addicted to lortabs, and I was taking a LOT of them at one point. Like up to 10 a day on really bad days. When I finally went to a orthopedic surgeon, and he looked at my MRI, he asked how in the hell I was even walking. He said the herniation on my disc was one of the worst ones he had seen.
I'm glad I did surgery though. Looking back, I was a pretty miserable person to be around, with both the pain and all those lortabs impacting my mood. I'm not 100% pain free, but it's much more manageable and simple stretches and core strengthening exercises help a lot more than they did before. And the recovery wasn't bad at all. I had my surgery on a Tuesday and was back at work the following Monday.
I'm glad I did surgery though. Looking back, I was a pretty miserable person to be around, with both the pain and all those lortabs impacting my mood. I'm not 100% pain free, but it's much more manageable and simple stretches and core strengthening exercises help a lot more than they did before. And the recovery wasn't bad at all. I had my surgery on a Tuesday and was back at work the following Monday.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 9:32 am to cas4t
Good suggestions here, although the neurosurgeon would be way down my list if he pushed for surgical option.
You really want surgery to be the last option.
I ruptured a disk in my back about 6 years ago. The simple description, the fluid between 2 vertebrae leaked out a little and disc was pushed out and the 2 bones collaspsed on a nerve (sciatica). The pain shot down my left glute and back of the leg to the ankle.
PCP just offered pain meds, so went to an ortho (Mom is a nurse and her idea). Better pain meds and phys-therapy. In about a month I was back to a decent level. The point of the physical therapy is to break up tissue and stretch you out so the disk will pop back in.
There is no quick fix to these injuries and unless you have chronic issues that keep happening, stay away from surgery.
The worse part if the ordeal was the MRI, I hate those machines
A few months ago I tweaked it pretty bad again, not as bad as before and used a chiropractor. It worked, but I preferred the physical therapy.
You really want surgery to be the last option.
I ruptured a disk in my back about 6 years ago. The simple description, the fluid between 2 vertebrae leaked out a little and disc was pushed out and the 2 bones collaspsed on a nerve (sciatica). The pain shot down my left glute and back of the leg to the ankle.
PCP just offered pain meds, so went to an ortho (Mom is a nurse and her idea). Better pain meds and phys-therapy. In about a month I was back to a decent level. The point of the physical therapy is to break up tissue and stretch you out so the disk will pop back in.
There is no quick fix to these injuries and unless you have chronic issues that keep happening, stay away from surgery.
The worse part if the ordeal was the MRI, I hate those machines
A few months ago I tweaked it pretty bad again, not as bad as before and used a chiropractor. It worked, but I preferred the physical therapy.
This post was edited on 3/9/16 at 9:36 am
Posted on 3/9/16 at 9:58 am to cas4t
I have had different kinds of back issues for over 20 years. Most of the time it was related to a weird movement that would send into spasm.
However, my latest bout was different and much more extended. I have come to believe that this latest time was more related to my hip than my back. Your hip structure extends further into your back than most people realize and this can make it seem like lower back pain due to a spine issue.
Ultimately this last issue was finally alleviated by walking more. If you have a fairly sedentary job make sure that your are getting up and moving around more.
Someone in this thread suggested stretching the backside of your legs. Walking serves to do some of that.
However, my latest bout was different and much more extended. I have come to believe that this latest time was more related to my hip than my back. Your hip structure extends further into your back than most people realize and this can make it seem like lower back pain due to a spine issue.
Ultimately this last issue was finally alleviated by walking more. If you have a fairly sedentary job make sure that your are getting up and moving around more.
Someone in this thread suggested stretching the backside of your legs. Walking serves to do some of that.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 10:08 am to Rounder1
quote:
Ultimately this last issue was finally alleviated by walking more. If you have a fairly sedentary job make sure that your are getting up and moving around more.
This too. I set a timer on my desk and make it a point to get up once an hour and just walk around for 5 or so minutes.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 11:05 am to The Spleen
I have an appointment with my PCP for April 21st. After looking into the cost of the MRI, and my current insurance being an HSA, I opted to go to him first.
Telefaw, thanks for the video. Guy in my office said once he began a routine and strengthened his back it helped him a lot. He had the exact pain as I do in low back and the outer side of the buttocks. I am going to let it rest for a few days, begin the routine you just posted, do some yoga, and hope it feels a little better between now and April 21st so I can tell the doc I've been proactive. And so my back doesn't make me want to cry.
Also, I drive a 2010 Honda Accord EX-L and frankly, these issues began once I had it a few months. It has the most uncomfortable seats known to man and according to a quick google search, it's been an issue for a lot of people. I've had the car about a year now.
Telefaw, thanks for the video. Guy in my office said once he began a routine and strengthened his back it helped him a lot. He had the exact pain as I do in low back and the outer side of the buttocks. I am going to let it rest for a few days, begin the routine you just posted, do some yoga, and hope it feels a little better between now and April 21st so I can tell the doc I've been proactive. And so my back doesn't make me want to cry.
Also, I drive a 2010 Honda Accord EX-L and frankly, these issues began once I had it a few months. It has the most uncomfortable seats known to man and according to a quick google search, it's been an issue for a lot of people. I've had the car about a year now.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 11:09 am to cas4t
That's funny. My back problems really escalated when I got a new car that was a manual transmission. The seats weren't all that uncomfortable, but all that clutch action must have aggravated something.
Posted on 3/9/16 at 11:17 am to cas4t
Chiropractors are quacks. They can give great massages but that's about it. Don't depend on them for help with non-muscular problems.
Is your pain chronic? You may have a sciatica issue.
I had a "slipped disc" in my lower back years ago and my doctor had me do a series of exercises that corrected bad posture. The pain went away and has never returned.

Is your pain chronic? You may have a sciatica issue.
I had a "slipped disc" in my lower back years ago and my doctor had me do a series of exercises that corrected bad posture. The pain went away and has never returned.


Popular
Back to top


14








