Started By
Message

re: Making a murderer

Posted on 1/14/16 at 9:30 am to
Posted by The Spleen
Member since Dec 2010
38865 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 9:30 am to
quote:

1. I heard the defense attorney say that seven of the jurors initially leaned to not guilty. How exactly would he know that? I thought deliberations were secret?



If I remember that scene right, he had papers with him which led me to believe it was some type of written report on jury deliberations. I've never made it to deliberations on a jury so I'm not sure how it works, and it probably varies by state. But I do know once the trial is over, the jury can talk about all they want with whomever they want.

My guess is the defense attorneys interviewed some of them.
Posted by higgs_boson
State College, PA
Member since Sep 2014
23756 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 9:36 am to
ok
Thanks!
Posted by scrooster
Resident Ethicist
Member since Jul 2012
44433 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 11:35 am to
quote:

I think it's hilarious that HBO turned this down. Netflix is killing it.


I agree ... but you've gotta remember that HBO is very very liberal progressive and anti-white redneck, while NetFlix is far more balanced.

It has definitely been a coup for Netflix. I read this morning where their numbers are up 4% and that's pretty big over a short time.
Posted by CtotheVrzrbck
WeWaCo
Member since Dec 2007
37538 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 12:30 pm to
quote:

ut can someone help me out with question number 1?



Jury transcripts are available to the attorneys and are sometimes made public by the DA's office.
Posted by FlatwoodsForester
Member since Jul 2012
2583 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 2:55 pm to
quote:

You would have to go back to church, school, etc with the same people and families you just basically said were corrupt. It is unlikely you would run into the Avery's as they seem to be "that family". I doubt you would run into them at church, probably only at a shitty bar.


I also read where one of the jurors was the husband of one of the women in the county clerk's office and another was the wife of one of the deputy's. It's crazy that his attorneys did not advocate to have the trial moved.
Posted by The Spleen
Member since Dec 2010
38865 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 3:23 pm to
I think 3 of the jurors had ties to the Sheriff's Department or County government.

I thought they did request a venue change but were denied.
Posted by higgs_boson
State College, PA
Member since Sep 2014
23756 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 3:29 pm to
The whole county has less than a 100,000 people, I think. Hard to not have ties with the department in some form.

Also, if I am not mistaken, both the Prosecutor and defense get a limited number of "strikes" they can use to eliminate a potential juror.

I am a little unclear on the trial in that it seems it physically took place in another county, but all the jurors were bused in, I guess?
Posted by CockInYourEar
Charlotte
Member since Sep 2012
22458 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 4:05 pm to
***SPOILER ALERT in my post below****

If OJ got off, I have no idea how these two guys didn't get off as well. Although, OJ had much better lawyers, that's for damn sure.

I think it is hard to convict him on several 'key' pieces.

- Where did that key come from? It wasn't there initially, and then all the sudden it was there on the ground.

- If he slit her throat and shot her on the bed in his trailer, where is the DNA evidence from that. Neck and head wounds bleed like crazy. Are they going to tell me there was no blood on that mattress, floor, bed posts, or walls or no evidence of it all being bleached?

- The same sheriff office he was suing was handling the investigation and walking or controlling the crime scene? That's fricked up beyond belief. The cops from the other county were supposed to be doing everything, why were they there?

- The appellate court judge was the same as the judge who handled his first case...that doesn't seem right to me.

- They could never find the bullet or pinpoint the location where she was murdered.

Some other questions I have: What did Avery say about the car being in the yard? If he did it, why didn't he destroy the car? Why didn't they test the other blood samples at the FBI lab, there were 3 they never tested.

As far as the kid. His lawyer should have been disbarred. You don't let your minor client go into a room for questioning without you being present. That kid also is a Special Needs student, he could be coerced into saying anything.
Posted by higgs_boson
State College, PA
Member since Sep 2014
23756 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 4:11 pm to
quote:

As far as the kid. His lawyer should have been disbarred


Agree completely. The system certainly failed him.
Posted by JustGetItRight
Member since Jan 2012
16187 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 5:02 pm to
quote:

Also, if I am not mistaken, both the Prosecutor and defense get a limited number of "strikes" they can use to eliminate a potential juror.


The process varies a bit depending on the state, but it goes something like this:

1) The judge will address the jury and question them about their eligibility to serve. Things like 'do you live in the county', 'are you under indictment', etc. People who aren't eligible (most common reason - recently moved and whatever record is used to draw the pool hasn't caught up) are dismissed.

2) People who think they have another reason to not serve get a chance to present it to the judge. The ones he buys as legit are dismissed.

3) Prosecutors and defense attorneys question the pool as a group. Things 'do you know x, y, z', 'do you work in law enforcement', etc. Those that respond positively may get more detailed questions. At the end of this period, each side has a list of jurors they want to strike for cause. Like the other steps, the ones the judge buys as legit are dismissed.

Now that the pool is whittled down, it turns into something akin to a reverse playground team draft. Each side alternates striking a potential juror until only the number needed for the trial is left. In this phase, they don't give a reason. It is literally a back and forth 'state strikes juror 49', 'defense strikes juror 31'.

The only real no-no in this process is Batson. If either side appears to be striking in a racially biased fashion then the other can object. Most people associate this with a prosecution tactic, but defense attorneys can be guilty of it too.

Assuming no Batson issue arises, you've now got your jury.

Just a couple more notes on the process. During the questioning (called Voir Dire), each side categorizes jurors in roughly three groups: like, don't like, meh. Since strikes are alternated, you usually end up with jurors that made both side's meh group. Also, in a high profile capital case like this one, if the prosecutor and defense attorneys were doing their jobs, they'd researched every person on that list before they ever entered the courtroom.

No, I'm not a lawyer or a cop, but I've got a job that's given me the chance to attend a pile of criminal trials over the years.
Posted by higgs_boson
State College, PA
Member since Sep 2014
23756 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 8:07 pm to
Great summary!

Thanks.

I just finished watching it...

I do not know what to think about the main guy but there is no way the nephew does not deserve a new trial.

His own lawyer conspired against him. He was told that by admitting to guilt he might one day have a family. I have never heard of a defendant being coerced by his own lawyer and investigator before.

Short of the confession, was there any evidence at all of him being involved in the crime. Every time I heard him speak, he had a different answer, usually trying to appease whoever he was talking to.

Again an IQ of 69 would rank him as mildy mentally retarded. And he was 16.

His lawyer should be disbarred.
Posted by RedMustang
Member since Oct 2011
6958 posts
Posted on 1/14/16 at 9:25 pm to
It's been stated that the kid's IQ is 69. In one of the first episodes, didn't they estimate Avery's IQ to be 70?
Posted by higgs_boson
State College, PA
Member since Sep 2014
23756 posts
Posted on 1/15/16 at 9:28 am to
The whole thing just makes me sick.

They interrogated a slow, juvenile without his attorney present.

The kid's own investigator pressured him to write out a confession and made him re-write it until he fit the narrative.

He may well be guilty, but that confession should not be worth anything --- given the way he was interrogated and his last comment on the tape was where he denied what he just said, stating that got into his head.

Also, unless it was mentioned earlier (possible as I have not looked it up), the whole gunshot to the head was clearly initiated by the investigators, not the suspect. If that was the secret information that confirmed his account, it should have had no bearing.

It speaks volumes they did not use this "confession" in the Steven Avery trial --- where I think the clearly superior lawyers would have completely discredited it.
Posted by LanierSpots
Gulf of America / Sarasota FL
Member since Sep 2010
72586 posts
Posted on 1/15/16 at 9:33 am to
I read where his X=Girlfriend said he was a monster and she thinks he killed her

Posted by The Spleen
Member since Dec 2010
38865 posts
Posted on 1/15/16 at 9:37 am to
quote:

It speaks volumes they did not use this "confession" in the Steven Avery trial



That's one of the things I just can't shake. They acted like the entire case against Avery swung their way when Dassey confessed, but then didn't even use it in Avery's trial. It tells me they knew they didn't have a case.


I think the entire mystery could be solved if Colburn came clean on why he called in those plates 2-3 days before the car was found. His explanation made no sense, and he came across as a less than credible witness.
Posted by higgs_boson
State College, PA
Member since Sep 2014
23756 posts
Posted on 1/15/16 at 9:39 am to
quote:

I read where his X=Girlfriend said he was a monster and she thinks he killed her



I am pretty sure that the main guy Steven Avery is guilty.

It does look like the investigators took some questionable approaches that may have jeopardized or tainted some of the evidence.

The nephew though, there is really nothing that links him. No DNA evidence or anything. Only a coerced confession. Again 16 and mildly retarded and giving answers he felt people wanted. His confession does not add up to the one credible witness I saw. The bus driver clearly stated she saw the victim taking pictures when she dropped the kid off. The kid says no one was taking pictures and he heard her screaming only when he went to take the mail to the Uncle's house.

Lanier, not sure if you have seen it yet but it is worth watching. It is clear the doc has an advocacy POV --- but even then it never convinced me Avery is innocent, rather that the process was flawed.

The nephew's investigator wrote in emails that it was his opinion the entire family was the definition of evil and the bloodline should be eradicated. THAT is not the person who should have been advocating for this sixteen year old.

Posted by DanMullins4Life
Member since Oct 2012
3168 posts
Posted on 1/15/16 at 9:43 am to
I think the girl's brother actually killed her.
Posted by higgs_boson
State College, PA
Member since Sep 2014
23756 posts
Posted on 1/15/16 at 9:51 am to
Why?

Why would he kill her then burn the body on someone else's property?

The documentary never provided any viable alternative theories.

Some facts seem pretty damning. The last known place she visited was the Avery junkyard. Her phone calls stop there. Her car is found on the property. Her body is found burned on the property. Steven Avery had called her multiple times.

Again, what bothers me is that I think the police felt he was guilty and may have tainted evidence to assure that outcome. The key thing will always bother me.

More than that though, I feel the nephew's confession was all about getting the Avery conviction. Again, the fact they did not even use it in his trial tells me they knew it was flawed. If he had the hundreds of thousands of dollars Avery did, I am pretty sure that confession would have never been allowed.

I just think the nephew deserves a retrial --- not a pardon but a fair trial in a different venue without the tainted confession.
Posted by AUbagman
LA
Member since Jun 2014
11214 posts
Posted on 1/15/16 at 10:38 am to
There's is definitely a reasonable doubt, hence he shouldn't have been convicted on the charges brought up by the prosecutor. It just goes to show you, jurors don't really want to be there, as they aren't compensated worth a damn, so there is always a very unfair advantage against the defendants. Sprinkle in some local bias brought on by the prosecutor during news conferences, the guy never had a shot at a fair trial.
Posted by AUbagman
LA
Member since Jun 2014
11214 posts
Posted on 1/15/16 at 10:42 am to
quote:

Why?

Why would he kill her then burn the body on someone else's property?



Why would Avery do it? Why would he leave the vehicle untouched without wiping it clean of blood, all while having a spotless "murder scene"? If someone wanted her killed, especially someone close that knew about Avery's history, it was the perfect opportunity to pin it on him. I don't think the police were involved initially, they just helped it along by planting other evidence in the house/garage. Everything else could have been placed in the several days before the search by the murderer, as it was outside.

Avery did not have motive and he was about to be paid a lot of money.
This post was edited on 1/15/16 at 10:43 am
first pageprev pagePage 2 of 4Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on X and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•Twitter