
Started By
Message
re: Making a murderer
Posted on 1/15/16 at 10:48 am to Robert Goulet
Posted on 1/15/16 at 10:48 am to Robert Goulet
quote:
DO NOT CLICK THIS IF YOU HAVENT FINISHED THE SHOW
Okay watched the show and now read your link.
LINK
Thanks for that!
I further makes me think Avery is guilty. Again, though, there is very little to indict the nephew in any of that information.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 10:52 am to AUbagman
quote:
Why would Avery do it?
The link provided by another poster helps with motive, imo.
He called to request her specifically, did not use his name and used *67 to hide his phone number. He did order shackles and handcuffs online.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 10:54 am to higgs_boson
I have read a few other links with some interesting info as well. I definitely think there is a lot more to the story than is known, just too much weird stuff that went on from both sides.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 10:55 am to higgs_boson
Personally, I think the brother-in-law should have been looked into.
Regardless, where was the murder scene? Why was her body put into the vehicle to be taken to the fire pit beside his house? Why wasn't her DNA on the keys? Where was her blood? What happened to her voicemails? Why was his blood vial tampered with?
She had been there before, she knew where she was going, so *67 means absolutely nothing. It's not like she was tricked to come out there. And since when did shakles mean you've got criminal intent? Couples use that quite often, and his GF was about to get out of jail.
Regardless, where was the murder scene? Why was her body put into the vehicle to be taken to the fire pit beside his house? Why wasn't her DNA on the keys? Where was her blood? What happened to her voicemails? Why was his blood vial tampered with?
She had been there before, she knew where she was going, so *67 means absolutely nothing. It's not like she was tricked to come out there. And since when did shakles mean you've got criminal intent? Couples use that quite often, and his GF was about to get out of jail.
This post was edited on 1/15/16 at 11:03 am
Posted on 1/15/16 at 10:56 am to Robert Goulet
quote:
I have read a few other links with some interesting info as well. I definitely think there is a lot more to the story than is known, just too much weird stuff that went on from both sides.
Yeah, I think he is guilty, that does not mean it was fairly proven in a court of law, though.
Again, I am much more bothered by what happened to the Nephew. Hope he gets a new trial.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:01 am to higgs_boson
quote:
I am pretty sure that the main guy Steven Avery is guilty.
He absolutely killed her. Also, research the case outside the Netflix series. To say it has an advocacy POV is being generous.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:02 am to JustGetItRight
quote:
quote:
I am pretty sure that the main guy Steven Avery is guilty.
He absolutely killed her. Also, research the case outside the Netflix series. To say it has an advocacy POV is being generous.
What about the nephew though?
That conviction seems to rest on the confession of a retarded juvenile.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:04 am to JustGetItRight
quote:
He absolutely killed her. Also, research the case outside the Netflix series. To say it has an advocacy POV is being generous.
What are the highlights of what you find? I'm interested to know.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:15 am to higgs_boson
quote:
What about the nephew though?
That conviction seems to rest on the confession of a retarded juvenile.
My gut feeling is that he was involved but having said that, he's got a legitimate ineffective counsel claim. He's probably going to get a retrial (and should).
Oh, further as to Avery, this girl would not have been the last victim. His later proven wrong rape conviction and imprisonment was the only thing that kept someone other than her from being the first. His entire history was that of a textbook sexual predator in training (which was really the basis for that first conviction).
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:20 am to JustGetItRight
quote:
he's got a legitimate ineffective counsel claim.
What his defense did was criminal.
quote:
This is truly where the devil resides in comfort. I can find no good in any member. These people are pure evil. This is where one would eat their young to satisty/justity a control issue where none previously existed.
"Brendan needs to be alone. When he sees me this Friday I will be a source of relief. He and I can begin to bond. He needs to trust me and the direction that I steer him into."
I could see that coming from the DA, but THAT was an email from his defense investigator.
Also, I am reading the transcript of the police interview on 2-27-06.
Reading it just pisses me off more.
LINK
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:24 am to JustGetItRight
He fits the profile! Convict his arse!
Thank God most trials are done off evidence presented in court, or there'd be even more wrongful convictions. Public sex/masturbation = Murdering rapist? Got it.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:30 am to AUbagman
I have read the first two confessions of the nephew. Both times he changed his account as investigators asked him to.
In neither does he mention anything about a gun or someone being shot. He never mentions it all until they lead him to talk about a gun.
The statement that this kid voluntarily waived his rights is laughable. He did not have a clue what was going on let alone what his rights were.
In neither does he mention anything about a gun or someone being shot. He never mentions it all until they lead him to talk about a gun.
The statement that this kid voluntarily waived his rights is laughable. He did not have a clue what was going on let alone what his rights were.
This post was edited on 1/15/16 at 11:34 am
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:31 am to JustGetItRight
quote:
He absolutely killed her
I think there's a good chance he killed, but I fail to see how you could say he did with such certainty. And yes, I've read many additional articles written on the case, in addition to watching the documentary.
Dude was a weirdo and a creep, but that doesn't mean he killed her.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:46 am to AUbagman
quote:
What are the highlights of what you find?
The body being on his place and him being the last person to see her alive is pretty big. Throw in that:
He had a history of calling, requesting her, and coming out wearing nothing but a towel. She'd tried to get out of going to his place any more.
The DNA, particularly her DNA on the .22 round (which was the murder weapon) that had passed through something that was found in his garage.
His DNA in her car (IIRC, in some places the documentary did not mention). His blood in her car - which the defense claims was planted.
Her camera and PDA were in his burn barrel.
The nephew told his mother in a recorded phone call that Avery did it. And yes, even though they tell you those lines are recorded dumbasses confess stuff to friends and family over them all the time. He also told her Avery had molested him - which further cements the sexual predator profile.
His fiancee thinks he did it and even the attorney that represented him at trail is not convinced of his innocence. He only thinks there wasn't the evidence needed to convict and/or it should be tossed because of prosecution issues.
You've either got to believe that (a) this small local jurisdiction had to create a conspiracy and put the pieces in place to make it convincing, and do it in a fashion that would include nobody likely to get cold feet and tell - all on the fly - or you've got to accept that (b) Avery did it. Avery did it. The question of whether or not the prosecutor crossed lines is one for the appellate courts, but I have no doubt at Avery is the murderer.
As I said earlier, I THINK the nephew was involved. He's retarded and Avery no doubt wielded a massive amount of influence over him. His level of involvement may have been none, it may have been complete, or it may have been somewhere in between (getting rid of the body and such). Where his case is different is that it is pretty clear that he had terribly ineffective representation at trial.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:50 am to The Spleen
Regardless of our feelings to how weird the guy is, I fail to see how there was sufficient certainty/evidence for murder 1.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:52 am to JustGetItRight
quote:
His level of involvement may have been none, it may have been complete, or it may have been somewhere in between (getting rid of the body and such). Where his case is different is that it is pretty clear that he had terribly ineffective representation at trial.
Definitely.
quote:
The nephew told his mother in a recorded phone call that Avery did it.
Again though, this kid is slow. He was told to call his mom and confess before the investigators told her. This all rests on the defense attorney. Other recorded conversations with his mother show him completely contradicting what he said then. It just sounds a lot like a slow person trying to give the "right" answers.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 11:59 am to JustGetItRight
I don't see a smoking gun there. Yes, a bullet with her dna was found after multiple searches, but where was the blood? Do you believe a guy as reckless as murdering someone at his house on appointment would have the aptitude to stage a clean crime scene only to leave his blood smeared in her vehicle while leaving it on his property?
This post was edited on 1/15/16 at 12:00 pm
Posted on 1/15/16 at 12:01 pm to The Spleen
quote:
I think there's a good chance he killed, but I fail to see how you could say he did with such certainty.
Put simply, because the evidence I've seen in all the stories convince me beyond a reasonable doubt.
The things that must have happened for him to be innocent are in my opinion simply beyond a realistic possibility, which leads to one conclusion: He is guilty.
Most trials come down to this type of decision. Only a few have the proverbial 'smoking gun'.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 12:04 pm to The Spleen
I still say that Mike Halbach, the brother of Teresa Halbach, killed her and this is why.
Naturally, brothers are predisposed to kill their sisters, this is basic biology and a scientific fact. So the inclination to commit the crime is already naturally present in Mike Halbach. If you review Mike's past criminal records, you'll notice that for the most part, he seems pretty clean; this is usual for criminals who commit crimes of sexual violence.
In mid-western states such as Wisconsin(where these events take place), inbreeding is not only very common but is often encouraged(though secretly) to preserve lineages and "common blood". Though not publicly stated, it can be assumed that like most brother-sister relationships in Wisconsin, the two were romantically involved.
However, Teresa, upon prior visits as a photographer for autotrader to the Avery compound, had subsequently been woo'd by charm of Steven Avery. Steven Avery was going through a significant shakeup with her current girlfriend because of her drunk driving arrests. Steven Avery and Teresa thus began a romantic relationship.
Mike Halbach, catching onto this fact, essentially unleashed the hidden desire to kill his sister and drove it into action. The rest is covered significantly in the documentary. Don't be surprised when I'm right.
Naturally, brothers are predisposed to kill their sisters, this is basic biology and a scientific fact. So the inclination to commit the crime is already naturally present in Mike Halbach. If you review Mike's past criminal records, you'll notice that for the most part, he seems pretty clean; this is usual for criminals who commit crimes of sexual violence.
In mid-western states such as Wisconsin(where these events take place), inbreeding is not only very common but is often encouraged(though secretly) to preserve lineages and "common blood". Though not publicly stated, it can be assumed that like most brother-sister relationships in Wisconsin, the two were romantically involved.
However, Teresa, upon prior visits as a photographer for autotrader to the Avery compound, had subsequently been woo'd by charm of Steven Avery. Steven Avery was going through a significant shakeup with her current girlfriend because of her drunk driving arrests. Steven Avery and Teresa thus began a romantic relationship.
Mike Halbach, catching onto this fact, essentially unleashed the hidden desire to kill his sister and drove it into action. The rest is covered significantly in the documentary. Don't be surprised when I'm right.
Posted on 1/15/16 at 12:10 pm to AUbagman
quote:
I don't see a smoking gun there. Yes, a bullet with her dna was found after multiple searches, but where was the blood? Do you believe a guy as reckless as murdering someone at his house on appointment would have the aptitude to stage a clean crime scene only to leave his blood smeared in her vehicle while leaving it on his property?
See my last post. A smoking gun isn't needed. The standard is 'beyond a reasonable doubt', not 'beyond all doubt'.
As to the blood, she was killed with a .22. I don't know if you've got much experience with weapons but that's a very small and relatively low velocity round. In a nutshell, there likely wasn't much to clean. I've been a a vollie EMT for over 17 years. During that time I've been to probably 20-30 shootings with several of them involving a .22 or .25. Unlike shotguns or bigger rounds, these often don't exit the body and don't bleed a lot. In one particular case, the guy shot himself in the head, was sitting there talking to us, and had nothing more than a small trickle of blood no worse than a shaving cut showing. We almost missed the entrance wound (which would have been not so good upon arrival at the ER).

Popular
Back to top



1





