
Started By
Message
Making a murderer
Posted on 1/13/16 at 10:42 am
Posted on 1/13/16 at 10:42 am
Someone has probably already talked about this as I am just now watching it, but what do yall think about the documentary and then the actual case?
I do not know what to think of the Avery guy. My gut says he is guilty.
However, watching the interview with his nephew, there is no way that kid should have been interrogated without his lawyer. It is clear he has no clue what is going on. After basically admitting to murder, he asks if they will be done in time for him to turn in his sixth period project for school. When they ask him if he has any weapons, he tells them he has a cd player. When they telling him he is going to be put in jail he asks if he will get out the next day.
He took special ed classes at school. I am not trying to excuse anything, but he was a mentally impaired juvenile, you would think, at the least, an advocate would have been in the room with him.
Anyone else have any thoughts?
I do not know what to think of the Avery guy. My gut says he is guilty.
However, watching the interview with his nephew, there is no way that kid should have been interrogated without his lawyer. It is clear he has no clue what is going on. After basically admitting to murder, he asks if they will be done in time for him to turn in his sixth period project for school. When they ask him if he has any weapons, he tells them he has a cd player. When they telling him he is going to be put in jail he asks if he will get out the next day.
He took special ed classes at school. I am not trying to excuse anything, but he was a mentally impaired juvenile, you would think, at the least, an advocate would have been in the room with him.
Anyone else have any thoughts?
Posted on 1/13/16 at 10:56 am to higgs_boson
I want to think he killed her, but you must remember one of the slimeball deputies called in that tag BEFORE she was reported missing.
That's the only thing that makes me think he may be innocent. Either way, his trial was shite and it shows you how fricked up small town law enforcement can be.
Diversity inside police departments help dissolve this type of thing. Outside of work, different types of people have different social structures. In church, inside the community etc. If you have multiple or any different ethnicities inside the department you can't sell mass cover up like you can in pasty white Wisconsin crackerville that has only one social structure, shared by every member of the community. Cops at the top, Averys at the bottom..
That's the only thing that makes me think he may be innocent. Either way, his trial was shite and it shows you how fricked up small town law enforcement can be.
Diversity inside police departments help dissolve this type of thing. Outside of work, different types of people have different social structures. In church, inside the community etc. If you have multiple or any different ethnicities inside the department you can't sell mass cover up like you can in pasty white Wisconsin crackerville that has only one social structure, shared by every member of the community. Cops at the top, Averys at the bottom..
This post was edited on 1/13/16 at 10:58 am
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:08 am to Hardy_Har
I do not know about his innocence, but it really does make you question a lot of things.
Again, I am more shocked about the way they interrogated the special ed juvenile without his attorney.
I grew up in a small town, and I think there are certain things the documentary hints at but does not explore enough. Every small town knows "that family". They are considered dirty and trouble makers, usually involved in a alcohol or drugs and whenever a crime happens you are never surprised to hear they are involved.
My family was considered as such. As a kid, sometimes I was not let into someone's house because of my last name. I am kind of conflicted about it, because honestly, there was merit to the town's suspicions. But at the same time, I can see how that would lead people to prejudice their assumptions about a person accused.
Given his wrongful conviction before, you would have thought the local sheriff would have had nothing to do with the investigation as soon as Avery became the prime suspect.
Also, I can believe that some police would plant evidence to help convict someone they truly thought was guilty.
Again, I am more shocked about the way they interrogated the special ed juvenile without his attorney.
I grew up in a small town, and I think there are certain things the documentary hints at but does not explore enough. Every small town knows "that family". They are considered dirty and trouble makers, usually involved in a alcohol or drugs and whenever a crime happens you are never surprised to hear they are involved.
My family was considered as such. As a kid, sometimes I was not let into someone's house because of my last name. I am kind of conflicted about it, because honestly, there was merit to the town's suspicions. But at the same time, I can see how that would lead people to prejudice their assumptions about a person accused.
Given his wrongful conviction before, you would have thought the local sheriff would have had nothing to do with the investigation as soon as Avery became the prime suspect.
Also, I can believe that some police would plant evidence to help convict someone they truly thought was guilty.
This post was edited on 1/13/16 at 11:18 am
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:26 am to higgs_boson
His guilt or innocence is of little significance to me. I think it's possible he killed her, but I'm not convinced. Of importance is the gross misconduct by the sheriff's department and the DA's office, and even the judge.
That's not even to mention the behavior of Dassey's first public defender.
The whole thing illustrates how the presumption of innocence is thrown out the window in so many cases.
That's not even to mention the behavior of Dassey's first public defender.
The whole thing illustrates how the presumption of innocence is thrown out the window in so many cases.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:30 am to higgs_boson
quote:
Again, I am more shocked about the way they interrogated the special ed juvenile without his attorney.
agreed, regardless of guilt or innocence that kid has serious mental deficiencies and i feel sorry for him.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:31 am to higgs_boson
DO NOT CLICK THIS IF YOU HAVENT FINISHED THE SHOW
LINK
I always have a problem with documentaries showing you want they want you to see. I do think it is obvious that the county police did some really shady shite.
LINK
I always have a problem with documentaries showing you want they want you to see. I do think it is obvious that the county police did some really shady shite.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:32 am to The Spleen
quote:
The whole thing illustrates how the presumption of innocence is thrown out the window in so many cases.
It's even worse now, with social media news sites posting pictures of people right after they're picked up.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:33 am to piggilicious
quote:
agreed, regardless of guilt or innocence that kid has serious mental deficiencies and i feel sorry for him.
I am with you.
I cannot help but feel sorry for him. He seems barely functional. It was telling when he had no idea what inconsistent or coerced meant and was worried he would miss the next wrestlemania while sitting in jail facing life in prison. I spent a decade teaching kids his age and he seems to be very low level functioning.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:33 am to piggilicious
Dassey's favorite thing about his specifically assigned public defender was "they had the same favorite animal".
shite makes me sick.
shite makes me sick.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:35 am to Robert Goulet
quote:
DO NOT CLICK THIS IF YOU HAVENT FINISHED THE SHOW
Thanks.
Have not finished the show yet. Was just shocked after watching the recorded interrogation and phone calls with the nephew.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:36 am to higgs_boson
I think it's hilarious that HBO turned this down. Netflix is killing it.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:42 am to Robert Goulet
Some of those points in that link further illustrate the immoral behavior of the prosecutor. THere is no such thing as "sweat DNA", it's just DNA, so there's no way to know the DNA found was from sweat. Saying it was from his sweat though just sensationalizes the evidence.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:48 am to The Spleen
quote:
Some of those points in that link further illustrate the immoral behavior of the prosecutor. THere is no such thing as "sweat DNA", it's just DNA, so there's no way to know the DNA found was from sweat. Saying it was from his sweat though just sensationalizes the evidence.
I assumed that they could tell by the pH or chemical makeup or something as to the difference of origin. I know frick all about that stuff, though.
Either way, definitely some intriguing shite done by the prosecution and Steve Avery was no angel. I tend to lean towards him not doing it. I have read some other very interesting hypotheses but do not have a link to those.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:50 am to Robert Goulet
I am a little more than halfway through it and still have seen no viable alternative to him committing the murder.
Again, more so than him, I am stunned by the treatment of the nephew.
It was telling when Avery's defense lawyer talked about how unfairly the nephew was being treated. The difference in legal counsel was stunning.
Again, more so than him, I am stunned by the treatment of the nephew.
It was telling when Avery's defense lawyer talked about how unfairly the nephew was being treated. The difference in legal counsel was stunning.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 11:56 am to higgs_boson
quote:
Again, more so than him, I am stunned by the treatment of the nephew.
Yeah, that was quite shocking. I don't think I have ever seen someone that dumb who wasn't obviously retarded. He was railroaded into certain things but then that other side of you asks "why would he keep admitting to something he didn't do?".
quote:
I am a little more than halfway through it and still have seen no viable alternative to him committing the murder
There was never a point in that show to me that painted a clear picture of him committing that murder imo. Some of the stuff that was ruled inadmissible for the defense was unfortunate as well.
Avery had really good representation, I especially liked the Stang guy.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 12:03 pm to Robert Goulet
quote:
Yeah, that was quite shocking. I don't think I have ever seen someone that dumb who wasn't obviously retarded.
I think by definition he is retarded. His verbal IQ was 69. In old terms that qualify as moron. In today's terms he would be listed as mild mental retardation.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 12:21 pm to higgs_boson
I don't believe Avery (well our Avery) killed her. You're in a law suit that could have you come into millions of dollars after spending 18 years in jail. (Note: through ep6 for my perspective)
Also, he works in a salvage yard. Why not crush the car and throw the body in the smelter? I know he's not bright, but he also used those tools and know what they do. That's about all you need.
The police absolutely framed him, even if you debate if he did it or not.
Willfully ignoring best practices with evidence handling, tampering with the blood vial, digging through burned bones with a fricking shovel. The ridiculous length of the search. That's not to mention the confession of the slow kid.
It's a good reminder that if the system wants to frick you, best buy lube.
Also, he works in a salvage yard. Why not crush the car and throw the body in the smelter? I know he's not bright, but he also used those tools and know what they do. That's about all you need.
The police absolutely framed him, even if you debate if he did it or not.
Willfully ignoring best practices with evidence handling, tampering with the blood vial, digging through burned bones with a fricking shovel. The ridiculous length of the search. That's not to mention the confession of the slow kid.
It's a good reminder that if the system wants to frick you, best buy lube.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 5:03 pm to Robert Goulet
quote:
Robert Goulet
Thanks for sharing that. People are accepting this documentary as though it's the gospel truth.
Posted on 1/13/16 at 10:31 pm to higgs_boson
No doubt the Avery's aren't very bright, especially the kid. But, I was surprised to not hear the word 'motive' used. I guess no one else had a motive, but neither did any of the Avery's. That means if an Avery actually did kill her, that is beyond sick.
Posted on 1/14/16 at 9:23 am to TexAgChill
Okay.
I have one episode left and will probably watch it tonight.
I was hoping someone who had watched it or knew more than me could answer a few questions.
1. I heard the defense attorney say that seven of the jurors initially leaned to not guilty. How exactly would he know that? I thought deliberations were secret?
2. The MOST reliable witness I saw was the bus driver. She is not involved at all. I believe her timeline is correct. That does not clear Avery in any way, but the slow kid said he got off the bus, got some mail, went to the uncle's trailer and heard screaming. That seems patently false as the bus driver saw the woman taking pictures. Again, I feel his interrogation was disgraceful.
3. I have not read any additional information yet as I wanted to watch the documentary first. In my view, the documentary does not leave me with the impression that Avery is innocent, but it does indict the entire system. I found it telling that the DA suggested they just disregard the key. In my view, that almost confirms how weird that piece of evidence was.
4. I thought the DA was very smart if somewhat shady when he went on about how a not guilty verdict would indict the sheriff's department. In a small community, after this trial, I am sure everyone would know who was on the jury. You would have to go back to church, school, etc with the same people and families you just basically said were corrupt. It is unlikely you would run into the Avery's as they seem to be "that family". I doubt you would run into them at church, probably only at a shitty bar.
5. Finally, I think the defense attorney made the truest statement of the show when he commented how the system is extremely stacked against you when the government brings it's full resources to bear.
I am waiting until I am completely done until I click on the link Robert provided, but can someone help me out with question number 1?
I have one episode left and will probably watch it tonight.
I was hoping someone who had watched it or knew more than me could answer a few questions.
1. I heard the defense attorney say that seven of the jurors initially leaned to not guilty. How exactly would he know that? I thought deliberations were secret?
2. The MOST reliable witness I saw was the bus driver. She is not involved at all. I believe her timeline is correct. That does not clear Avery in any way, but the slow kid said he got off the bus, got some mail, went to the uncle's trailer and heard screaming. That seems patently false as the bus driver saw the woman taking pictures. Again, I feel his interrogation was disgraceful.
3. I have not read any additional information yet as I wanted to watch the documentary first. In my view, the documentary does not leave me with the impression that Avery is innocent, but it does indict the entire system. I found it telling that the DA suggested they just disregard the key. In my view, that almost confirms how weird that piece of evidence was.
4. I thought the DA was very smart if somewhat shady when he went on about how a not guilty verdict would indict the sheriff's department. In a small community, after this trial, I am sure everyone would know who was on the jury. You would have to go back to church, school, etc with the same people and families you just basically said were corrupt. It is unlikely you would run into the Avery's as they seem to be "that family". I doubt you would run into them at church, probably only at a shitty bar.
5. Finally, I think the defense attorney made the truest statement of the show when he commented how the system is extremely stacked against you when the government brings it's full resources to bear.
I am waiting until I am completely done until I click on the link Robert provided, but can someone help me out with question number 1?
This post was edited on 1/14/16 at 9:27 am

Popular
Back to top


7







