Started By
Message

Nick Saban's 50 Best Players
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:06 pm
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:06 pm
The criteria used by the article:
1. College performance under Saban (NOTE: players who reached peak performance after Saban left Michigan State or LSU — ex. Charles Rogers, LaRon Landry and Dwayne Bowe — do not qualify)
2. Big-game moments/winning pedigree
3. All-conference and All-American recognition
4. Trophies and awards
5. NFL draft position
Here is the list:
#50 - Derrick Mason, Michigan State (1996)
#49 - Domanick Davis, LSU (2002)
#48 - Ike Reese, Michigan State (1997)
#47 - Amp Campbell, Michigan State (1999)
#46 - Eddie Lacy, Alabama (2012)
#45 - James Carpenter, Alabama (2010)
#44 - Greg McElroy, Alabama (2010)
#43 - Robaire Smith, Michigan State (1999)
#42 - Skyler Green, LSU (2004)
#41 - Javier Arenas, Alabama (2009)
#40 - T.J. Yeldon, Alabama (2014)
#39 - Cyrus Kouandjio, Alabama (2013)
#38 - Antoine Caldwell, Alabama (2008)
#37 - Landon Collins, Alabama (2014)
#36 - Stephen Peterman, LSU (2003)
#35 - Marcell Dareus, Alabama (2010)
#34 - A'Shawn Robinson, Alabama (2015)
#33 - Dre Kirkpatrick, Alabama (2011)
#32 - D.J. Fluker, Alabama (2012)
#31 - Michael Clayton, LSU (2003)
#30 - Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, Alabama (2013)
#29 - Rashad Johnson, Alabama (2008)
#28 - Mike Johnson, Alabama (2009)
#27 - Chad Lavalais, LSU (2003)
#26 - Ryan Kelly, Alabama (2015)
#25 - Courtney Upshaw, Alabama (2011)
#24 - Flozell Adams, Michigan State (1997)
#23 - Chance Warmack, Alabama (2012)
#22 - Dee Milliner, Alabama (2012)
#21 - Ben Wilkerson, LSU (2004)
#20 - Bradie James, LSU (2002)
#19 - Reggie Ragland, Alabama (2015)
#18 - Julio Jones, Alabama (2010)
#17 - Dont'a Hightower, Alabama (2011)
#16 - Julian Peterson, Michigan State (1999)
#15 - Plaxico Burress, Michigan State (1999)
#14 - Corey Webster, LSU (2004)
#13 - Andre Smith, Alabama (2008)
#12 - Marcus Spears, LSU (2004)
#11 - AJ McCarron, Alabama (2013)
#10 - Mark Barron, Alabama (2011)
#09 - Josh Reed, LSU (2001)
#08 - Barrett Jones, Alabama (2012)
#07 - Mark Ingram, Alabama (2010)
#06 - Terrence Cody, Alabama (2009)
#05 - Trent Richardson, Alabama (2011)
#04 - Rolando McClain, Alabama (2009)
#03 - C.J. Mosley, Alabama (2013)
#02 - Derrick Henry, Alabama (2015)
#01 - Amari Cooper, Alabama (2014)
BONUS: All-Saban Team:
QB
AJ McCarron, Alabama (starter)
Greg McElroy, Alabama
RB
Derrick Henry, Alabama (starter)
Trent Richardson, Alabama
Mark Ingram, Alabama
WR
Amari Cooper, Alabama (starter)
Josh Reed, LSU (starter)
Plaxico Burress, Michigan State (starter)
Julio Jones, Alabama
Michael Clayton, LSU
TE
O.J. Howard, Alabama (starter)
Robert Royal, LSU
OT
Andre Smith, Alabama (starter)
Flozell Adams, Michigan State (starter)
D.J. Fluker, Alabama
OG
Chance Warmack, Alabama (starter)
Mike Johnson, Alabama (starter)
Stephen Peterman, LSU
C
Barrett Jones, Alabama (starter)
Ben Wilkerson, LSU
NT
Terrence Cody, Alabama (starter)
Chad Lavalais, LSU
Marcell Dareus, Alabama
DE
Marcus Spears, LSU (starter)
Julian Peterman, Michigan State (starter)
Courtney Upshaw, Alabama
A'Shawn Robinson, Alabama
ILB
C.J. Mosley, Alabama (starter)
Rolando McClain, Alabama (starter)
Reggie Ragland, Alabama
Ike Reese, Michigan State
OLB
Dont'a Hightower, Alabama (starter)
Bradie James, LSU (starter)
Robaire Smith, Michigan State
CB
Corey Webster, LSU (starter)
Dee Milliner, Alabama (starter)
Dre Kirkpatrick, Alabama
Amp Campbell, Michigan State
S
Mark Barron, Alabama (starter)
Rashad Johnson, Alabama (starter)
Landon Collins, Alabama
Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, Alabama
K
Paul Edinger, Michigan State (starter)
Leigh Tiffin, Alabama
P
JK Scott, Alabama (starter)
Donnie Jones, LSU
RS
Skyler Green, LSU (starter)
Javier Arenas, Alabama (starter)
Domanick Davis, LSU
Derrick Mason, Michigan State
LINK
1. College performance under Saban (NOTE: players who reached peak performance after Saban left Michigan State or LSU — ex. Charles Rogers, LaRon Landry and Dwayne Bowe — do not qualify)
2. Big-game moments/winning pedigree
3. All-conference and All-American recognition
4. Trophies and awards
5. NFL draft position
Here is the list:
#50 - Derrick Mason, Michigan State (1996)
#49 - Domanick Davis, LSU (2002)
#48 - Ike Reese, Michigan State (1997)
#47 - Amp Campbell, Michigan State (1999)
#46 - Eddie Lacy, Alabama (2012)
#45 - James Carpenter, Alabama (2010)
#44 - Greg McElroy, Alabama (2010)
#43 - Robaire Smith, Michigan State (1999)
#42 - Skyler Green, LSU (2004)
#41 - Javier Arenas, Alabama (2009)
#40 - T.J. Yeldon, Alabama (2014)
#39 - Cyrus Kouandjio, Alabama (2013)
#38 - Antoine Caldwell, Alabama (2008)
#37 - Landon Collins, Alabama (2014)
#36 - Stephen Peterman, LSU (2003)
#35 - Marcell Dareus, Alabama (2010)
#34 - A'Shawn Robinson, Alabama (2015)
#33 - Dre Kirkpatrick, Alabama (2011)
#32 - D.J. Fluker, Alabama (2012)
#31 - Michael Clayton, LSU (2003)
#30 - Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, Alabama (2013)
#29 - Rashad Johnson, Alabama (2008)
#28 - Mike Johnson, Alabama (2009)
#27 - Chad Lavalais, LSU (2003)
#26 - Ryan Kelly, Alabama (2015)
#25 - Courtney Upshaw, Alabama (2011)
#24 - Flozell Adams, Michigan State (1997)
#23 - Chance Warmack, Alabama (2012)
#22 - Dee Milliner, Alabama (2012)
#21 - Ben Wilkerson, LSU (2004)
#20 - Bradie James, LSU (2002)
#19 - Reggie Ragland, Alabama (2015)
#18 - Julio Jones, Alabama (2010)
#17 - Dont'a Hightower, Alabama (2011)
#16 - Julian Peterson, Michigan State (1999)
#15 - Plaxico Burress, Michigan State (1999)
#14 - Corey Webster, LSU (2004)
#13 - Andre Smith, Alabama (2008)
#12 - Marcus Spears, LSU (2004)
#11 - AJ McCarron, Alabama (2013)
#10 - Mark Barron, Alabama (2011)
#09 - Josh Reed, LSU (2001)
#08 - Barrett Jones, Alabama (2012)
#07 - Mark Ingram, Alabama (2010)
#06 - Terrence Cody, Alabama (2009)
#05 - Trent Richardson, Alabama (2011)
#04 - Rolando McClain, Alabama (2009)
#03 - C.J. Mosley, Alabama (2013)
#02 - Derrick Henry, Alabama (2015)
#01 - Amari Cooper, Alabama (2014)
BONUS: All-Saban Team:
QB
AJ McCarron, Alabama (starter)
Greg McElroy, Alabama
RB
Derrick Henry, Alabama (starter)
Trent Richardson, Alabama
Mark Ingram, Alabama
WR
Amari Cooper, Alabama (starter)
Josh Reed, LSU (starter)
Plaxico Burress, Michigan State (starter)
Julio Jones, Alabama
Michael Clayton, LSU
TE
O.J. Howard, Alabama (starter)
Robert Royal, LSU
OT
Andre Smith, Alabama (starter)
Flozell Adams, Michigan State (starter)
D.J. Fluker, Alabama
OG
Chance Warmack, Alabama (starter)
Mike Johnson, Alabama (starter)
Stephen Peterman, LSU
C
Barrett Jones, Alabama (starter)
Ben Wilkerson, LSU
NT
Terrence Cody, Alabama (starter)
Chad Lavalais, LSU
Marcell Dareus, Alabama
DE
Marcus Spears, LSU (starter)
Julian Peterman, Michigan State (starter)
Courtney Upshaw, Alabama
A'Shawn Robinson, Alabama
ILB
C.J. Mosley, Alabama (starter)
Rolando McClain, Alabama (starter)
Reggie Ragland, Alabama
Ike Reese, Michigan State
OLB
Dont'a Hightower, Alabama (starter)
Bradie James, LSU (starter)
Robaire Smith, Michigan State
CB
Corey Webster, LSU (starter)
Dee Milliner, Alabama (starter)
Dre Kirkpatrick, Alabama
Amp Campbell, Michigan State
S
Mark Barron, Alabama (starter)
Rashad Johnson, Alabama (starter)
Landon Collins, Alabama
Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, Alabama
K
Paul Edinger, Michigan State (starter)
Leigh Tiffin, Alabama
P
JK Scott, Alabama (starter)
Donnie Jones, LSU
RS
Skyler Green, LSU (starter)
Javier Arenas, Alabama (starter)
Domanick Davis, LSU
Derrick Mason, Michigan State
LINK
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:11 pm to RollTide1987
Blah blah blah blah blah ... Bama Board, use it.
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:11 pm to RollTide1987
#50 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#49 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#48 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#47 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#46 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#45 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#44 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#43 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#42 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#41 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#40 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#39 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#38 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#37 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#36 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#35 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#34 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#33 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#32 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#31 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#30 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#29 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#28 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#27 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#26 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#25 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#24 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#23 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#22 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#21 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#20 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#19 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#18 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#17 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#16 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#15 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#14 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#13 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#12 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#11 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#10 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#09 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#08 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#07 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#06 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#05 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#04 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#03 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#02 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#01 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#49 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#48 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#47 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#46 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#45 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#44 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#43 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#42 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#41 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#40 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#39 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#38 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#37 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#36 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#35 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#34 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#33 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#32 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#31 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#30 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#29 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#28 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#27 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#26 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#25 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#24 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#23 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#22 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#21 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#20 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#19 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#18 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#17 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#16 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#15 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#14 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#13 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#12 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#11 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#10 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#09 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#08 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#07 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#06 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#05 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#04 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#03 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#02 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
#01 - AJ McCtattoo, Alabama (2013)
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:15 pm to scrooster
quote:
Blah blah blah blah blah ... Bama Board, use it.
I guess you failed to notice the number of LSU and Michigan State players that dot the list.
1. It's not my list
2. It encompasses Saban's entire coaching career
Next time read before you post. But as South Carolina went for Trump, I can see how that is a little difficult for you.
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:18 pm to RollTide1987
Alabama went for trump too 

Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:19 pm to FiddleHead
I don't live in Alabama so I don't really care.
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:27 pm to RollTide1987
quote:
#09 - Josh Reed, LSU (2001)
top 5 easily
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:31 pm to RollTide1987
Eddy Lacy at 46 is ridiculous. He's the best RB Saban has ever had.
Dre ahead of A'Shawn? What?
Dre ahead of A'Shawn? What?
This post was edited on 3/14/16 at 11:36 pm
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:42 pm to RollTide1987
Stats or not(mostly utilized as a blocking back)..Nick Saban and LSU fans sure loved some Joe Addai!
Posted on 3/14/16 at 11:59 pm to TheRoarRestoredInBR
Addai was a hell of a player.
Posted on 3/15/16 at 12:14 am to RollTide1987
Courtney Upshaw was a downright monster at OLB- one of the best performances by a single player I've seen was Upshaw at the Citrus Bowl against MSU. Not to mention the entire 2011 season
Posted on 3/15/16 at 12:14 am to RollTide1987
Dude's coached half the NFL
Posted on 3/15/16 at 1:00 am to RollTide1987
That might be one of the worst lists I've ever seen. Derrick Henry is NOT even close to being the second best player to play for Saban. How does Greg McElroy make the top 50 players list but not Rohan Davey? Hell, Matt Mauck should be ranked ahead of him as well. Andre Smith, Javier Arenas, Eddie Lacy and Josh Reed should all be ranked higher.
Posted on 3/15/16 at 1:15 am to Bench McElroy
quote:
How does Greg McElroy make the top 50 players list but not Rohan Davey?
Rohan Davey career stats:
286-478 (59.8%) 4,415 yards 29 TDs 15 INTs
10-4 as a starter; 1 SEC Championship
Greg McElroy career stats:
436-658 (66.3%) 5,691 yards 39 TDs 10 INTs
24-3 as a starter; 1 BCS Championship, 1 SEC Championship
Want to ask that question again?
Posted on 3/15/16 at 1:19 am to RollTide1987
100% this is a Bama board op.
But Rohan is better than Aj college wise honestly.
Plus Lavilaisse(sp?) is above Cody. Dude was a beast
But Rohan is better than Aj college wise honestly.
Plus Lavilaisse(sp?) is above Cody. Dude was a beast
Posted on 3/15/16 at 1:28 am to RollTide1987
quote:
Want to ask that question again?



Posted on 3/15/16 at 1:31 am to Bench McElroy
Honestly, anyone who would rather have McElroy over Davey is an idiot.
This post was edited on 3/15/16 at 1:32 am
Posted on 3/15/16 at 1:38 am to Bench McElroy
quote:
If you want to compare players by win-loss record, Greg McElroy lost three games on a team starting ten future first round draft picks.
And in those three losses he was as follows:
@ South Carolina: 27-34 (79.4%) 315 yards 2 TDs 0 INTs
@ LSU: 21-34 (61.8%) 223 yards 2 TDs 1 INT
vs. Auburn: 27-37 (73%) 377 yards 2 TDs 0 INTs
So it's pretty obvious those 3 losses weren't on him.
Popular
Back to top
