re: Is anybody else satisfied with this outcome?

I think the NCAA was going to get involved once a dealer pointed to a bunch of autographs he had for sale and said "I paid Todd Gurley for those".

Your complaints seem to be directed at UGA for following the rules. That is the way that Georgia does things and you might want to accept that reality. Some of us actually like it that way. Additionally, it was by far the prudent course of action in this case involving potentially hostile witness(es) and a player who had been imprudent over an extended period. Rolling the dice with probation would have been a bad choice, and fortunately Greg McGarity and UGA administration handled this correctly.