re: All-Time Nick Saban team....

quote:

---

My fault for not stating this in the rules. Not changing the players positions. for example, if you like cyrus K and andre smith, you can't move cyrus to RT just to make room. Hightower was a MLB, so you cant move him to the outside

---

um, i may be wrong here but didnt upshaw and dickson play the exact same spot?

DJ Hall = locker room cancer therefore no accolades.

Another vote for Norwood over Maze, hands down.

Richardson and Lacey should be 1B to Ingram's 1A and I daresay Ingram doesn't win the Heisman if TR isn't spelling him and backing him up.

I like Peek at TE, but Brad Smelley should also be considered, certainly before Michael "Stone Hands" Williams.

I'd also nominate Javy for the Star position. Nobody could bring the corner blitz like he could.

And Vinnie Sunseri for the Nickel back.

Didn't Hightower play one of the OLB positions early in his career at Bama?

quote:

---

All-Time Nick Saban team....
quote:
Brad Smelley


I think by the end of his career, he was the best TE Alabama has had under Saban. By far.

---

I don't think he was a better blocker than Michael Williams, and I'm not sure he was a better receiver than Peek or Nick Walker. He spent a lot of time at Hback, and I would say Fowler has him there. Smelley could be the most well-rounded, though - definitely a fun debate.

quote:

---

My fault for not stating this in the rules. Not changing the players positions. for example, if you like cyrus K and andre smith, you can't move cyrus to RT just to make room. Hightower was a MLB, so you cant move him to the outside

---

Then you broke your own rule. Warmack played LG his entire time at Bama.

Yeah, either him or Carpenter. I'd say that it's a wash.

All of that doesn't really matter though, because it's quite obvious that Cam Robinson will be the best by the time he goes to the NFL.