Started By
Message
1
Posted on 11/9/09 at 1:58 pm to TigerJeff
quote:
same ref that gave you an extra yard on the running into the punter penalty,
should have been 15 yds anyway, leg was in the air he was defenseless
Posted on 11/9/09 at 1:58 pm to Bryant34
I thought it was a catch too. He held onto the ball with one hand until he hit the ground. Since we won, I won't bitch about it too much, but LSU fans take note, missed calls go both ways.
What happened to the replay booth? Did Les Miles plug all their shite into one outlet or something?
What happened to the replay booth? Did Les Miles plug all their shite into one outlet or something?
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:00 pm to TheHat
quote:
I do not believe that the replay equipment worked throughout the entire game.
Cannot disagree. In fact, it's malfunctioned in several different stadiums all year (just ask MSU).
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:01 pm to Bryant34
There were several plays, both for bama and lsu, that were not looked at.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:03 pm to Bryant34
Too bad he got rock By Chad Jones and dropped the rock.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:04 pm to Louie T
quote:
if that's a catch then peteron's was a definite pick
they both were. Smelley caught that in bounds and dropped it after hitting the ground. we all know that was a pick, but I will say to the Op considering Maze caught the next pass for a first down the drive did continue and we were moving the ball until Ingram let the snap bounce off of his helmet and that killed the drive not the missed call.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:05 pm to labamafan
quote:
they both were. Smelley caught that in bounds and dropped it after hitting the ground. we all know that was a pick, but I will say to the Op considering Maze caught the next pass for a first down the drive did continue and we were moving the ball until Ingram let the snap bounce off of his helmet and that killed the drive not the missed call.
sshhhhhhh! The LSU fans aren't going to remember that. They're too distraught about their own missed calls.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:07 pm to Bryant34
quote:
Your quarterback inexplicably tried to avoid contact with the defender by backpedaling before being hit. The spot was correct.
Not a chance the spot was correct. Smelley dropped the ball too, not a catch.
LINK (0:09)
This post was edited on 11/9/09 at 2:09 pm
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:08 pm to bmy
quote:
Smelley dropped the ball too, not a catch.
disagree was a catch but see my post above it was a nonfactor.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:09 pm to labamafan
quote:
disagree was a catch but see my post above it was a nonfactor.
If the ball hadn't come out when he hit the ground, yeah it would have been a catch.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:13 pm to bmy
quote:
Not a chance the spot was correct. Smelley dropped the ball too, not a catch.
LINK (0:09)
Thanks for the link. Proves my point that he chickened out on the hit, thus losing valuable field position (and a possible first down).
This one was Jefferson's fault, not the refs.
And, YES, it was a catch... go back and watch. As for whether it was relevant, it would have moved us 15 yards further downfield, and the plays that followed may have put us into field goal range.
It is equally as speculative as LSU fans thinking that had a snowball's chance of scoring in the fourth quarter.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:16 pm to bmy
quote:
If the ball hadn't come out when he hit the ground
I am not arguing because the ball came out when he hit the ground but I thought the ground couldnt cause a fumble? Just asking I don tknow?
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:18 pm to Bryant34
quote:
It is equally as speculative as LSU fans thinking that had a snowball's chance of scoring in the fourth quarter.
Yes, that is speculative and I don't think we would've done it. HOWEVER, what is not speculative is the refs blew the INT call.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:18 pm to labamafan
quote:
I am not arguing because the ball came out when he hit the ground but I thought the ground couldnt cause a fumble? Just asking I don tknow?
It can't cause a fumble, that's right. But it can cause an incompletion. Happened to the Saints yesterday
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:18 pm to Bryant34
quote:
Your quarterback inexplicably tried to avoid contact with the defender by backpedaling before being hit. The spot was correct.
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:19 pm to Bryant34
quote:
Thanks for the link. Proves my point that he chickened out on the hit, thus losing valuable field position (and a possible first down).
This one was Jefferson's fault, not the refs.
His forward progress was stopped by the defender, he got the necessary yardage and then pulled up. That's not uncommon. Is a QB supposed to try and truck a freaking DB? Jefferson isn't Tebow.
So you think Jefferson stopped his forward progress on his own, and dove backwards to avoid the hit? Is that your claim? (It's the only way you could be correct)
This post was edited on 11/9/09 at 2:21 pm
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:21 pm to Bryant34
Just heard Finebaum say the excuse now (Monday from the SEC officials) is that Julio touched the ball while out of bounds and therefore the reception was OOB. 
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:22 pm to h0nkifuvcoached4bama
quote:
Just heard Finebaum say the excuse now (Monday from the SEC officials) is that Julio touched the ball while out of bounds and therefore the reception was OOB.
Would be legit.. but there's no way Julio could have touched the ball first.
This post was edited on 11/9/09 at 2:23 pm
Posted on 11/9/09 at 2:29 pm to bmy
quote:
It can't cause a fumble, that's right. But it can cause an incompletion. Happened to the Saints yesterday
The rule is different in the NFL.
Page 3 of 4
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News