Started By
Message
re: One last Guice vs Chubb thread- Career
Posted on 1/16/18 at 12:54 pm to PorkRoast
Posted on 1/16/18 at 12:54 pm to PorkRoast
I'm not going to look at those stats, but truthfully and not trolling, I don't think Chubb ever fully recovered from the PCL injury.
This year when Georgia met their match up front or it came close, which was not very often but did happen, Chubb would get locked up while Michel would still be playing well.
I don't think Chubb has much of a chance in the NFL anymore truthfully if the eye and stats don't lie. Michel does though, when he became the #1 as a sophomore he wasn't ready to play the physical game and hit a wall due to it, but he became an absolute complete player after that. Still at his best in a stretch/outside run role, but can be an all around back.
This year when Georgia met their match up front or it came close, which was not very often but did happen, Chubb would get locked up while Michel would still be playing well.
I don't think Chubb has much of a chance in the NFL anymore truthfully if the eye and stats don't lie. Michel does though, when he became the #1 as a sophomore he wasn't ready to play the physical game and hit a wall due to it, but he became an absolute complete player after that. Still at his best in a stretch/outside run role, but can be an all around back.
This post was edited on 1/16/18 at 12:56 pm
Posted on 1/16/18 at 12:56 pm to RMFT15
quote:No you wouldnt
I'd take Chubb over Guice every time
Posted on 1/16/18 at 12:57 pm to SECFan1995
quote:I agree with all of this.
I'm not going to look at those stats, but truthfully and not trolling, I don't think Chubb ever fully recovered from the PCL injury.
This year when Georgia met their match up front or it came close, which was not very often but did happen, Chubb would get locked up while Michel would still be playing well.
I don't think Chubb has much of a chance in the NFL anymore truthfully if the eye and stats don't lie. Michel does though, when he became the #1 as a sophomore he wasn't ready to play the physical game and hit a wall due to it, but he became an absolute complete player after that. Still at his best in a stretch/outside run role, but can be an all around back
It really sucks, but Chubb looks so different now than pre-injury.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 12:59 pm to deeprig9
quote:
You're an odd little corndog.
You had to know the piper would call...do you remember how you bloviated all year long about weekly YPC?
Do you really find it odd that someone would remember on a cold January snow day, and decide to see if you would man-up and pay the piper.
Are you ready to admit that Guice is better than Chubb and EVERY RB from UGA....EVER?
If you do I will logoff now and go to the gym and stop playing around with you kids.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 12:59 pm to BlackCloud
quote:
Actually, I had fun in a few of those threads.
I don't care for comparison threads personally. I mean, I get why y'all started this one, but the goal posts start moving around, and really....there are just too many variables to say definitively. Injuries, OLine, offensive style, other players at same position on same team, opponents.....I mean it just goes on and on and on. I prefer to just sit back and watch them and enjoy them. If I'm thinking about who I think is better, I start missing/enjoying what they are doing.
Guice and Chubb will both do well, and unless one decides to become a Buddhist Monk instead of going to the NFL, they will make more money in a year than i will make in a lifetime.
quote:
But you do know that the piper has to be paid when you put yourself out there like that. Do you not?
Oh yeah. Crap, Auburn started a dozen threads trolling Georgia before the SECCG and after the national Championship game and they act completely surprised when they get rolled back.
In fairness, we had some newer posters that got a bit out of hand, but what can you do?
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:01 pm to lsupride87
quote:
It really sucks, but Chubb looks so different now than pre-injury.
He looked much better this year, but still seems to have lost just a touch of speed. However, I thought he had a little more power. It's hard to tell, really.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:01 pm to DawgsLife
quote:
Guice and Chubb will both do well, and unless one decides to become a Buddhist Monk instead of going to the NFL,
Neither will go the Ricky Williams route, but Guice "Booga" might have problems with money and end up in prison very soon doing thug things.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:03 pm to deeprig9
quote:Well, someone woke up on the racist side of the bed this morning
but Guice "Booga" might have problems with money and end up in prison very soon doing thug things.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:04 pm to DawgsLife
quote:
In fairness, we had some newer posters that got a bit out of hand, but what can you do?
Have a little fun with it.
It's snowing here and I am just hunkered down having a little fun with the kids of tRant.
I need to get my arse to the gym before the basketball game against UGA tonight.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:04 pm to lsupride87
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:07 pm to deeprig9
quote:Please explain why you think Guice or LF will end up with no money and in prison Mr. Grand Wizard.
Crap the Buga thing was LF, not Guice. My bad.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:29 pm to lsupride87
Guice's 2016 season was nearly identical to Michel's 2017. I think they'll both be great pros.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:53 pm to BlackCloud
guice is probably better than post-injury chubb
but, every lsu fan in this thread that agrees with the premise of the OP knows what this means, right?
every one of you who is arguing guice over chubb is simultaneously arguing gurley over fournette without even knowing it
but, every lsu fan in this thread that agrees with the premise of the OP knows what this means, right?
every one of you who is arguing guice over chubb is simultaneously arguing gurley over fournette without even knowing it
Posted on 1/16/18 at 1:55 pm to Killean
quote:
Felix Jones had a career 7.7 ypc.
I'm guessing he's better than Guice by a frickload right?
oh boy....
Posted on 1/16/18 at 2:05 pm to BlackCloud
Thread summary
LSU fans: Here are Guice's career stats compared to Chubb. Looks like Guice was the better RB.
UGA fans: THAT WAS BEFORE THE INJURRY RUFF RUFF
LSU fans: Here are Guice and Chubb stats before the injury. He's still better
UGA fans: BUT COMMON OPPONENTS
LSU fans: Here are Guice and Chubb stats against common opponents. He's still better
UGA fans: IRRELEVANT CUZ LSU SUCKS AND WERE BETTER AND WE'RE GONNA BEAT U NEXT YEAR HAHAHA ROH ROH RUFF
Arkansas fans: FELIX JONES MUTHAfrickAS
LSU fans: Sure, we can say he's better than Guice if you concede Guice is better than Dmac
Arkansas fans:...
LSU fans: Here are Guice's career stats compared to Chubb. Looks like Guice was the better RB.
UGA fans: THAT WAS BEFORE THE INJURRY RUFF RUFF
LSU fans: Here are Guice and Chubb stats before the injury. He's still better
UGA fans: BUT COMMON OPPONENTS
LSU fans: Here are Guice and Chubb stats against common opponents. He's still better
UGA fans: IRRELEVANT CUZ LSU SUCKS AND WERE BETTER AND WE'RE GONNA BEAT U NEXT YEAR HAHAHA ROH ROH RUFF
Arkansas fans: FELIX JONES MUTHAfrickAS
LSU fans: Sure, we can say he's better than Guice if you concede Guice is better than Dmac
Arkansas fans:...
Posted on 1/16/18 at 2:09 pm to geauxtigahs87
quote:
Arkansas fans: FELIX JONES MUTHAfrickAS
LSU fans: Sure, we can say he's better than Guice if you concede Guice is better than Dmac
Arkansas fans:...
Interesting Spin
Posted on 1/16/18 at 2:19 pm to rockiee
quote:
Interesting Spin
I missed their response, I got it now.
When comparing Guice and Felix, arkansas fans use YPC. But when comparing Guice and Dmac, arkansas fans want to use total yardage.
Makes sense.
Posted on 1/16/18 at 2:28 pm to geauxtigahs87
quote:
When comparing Guice and Felix, arkansas fans use YPC. But when comparing Guice and Dmac, arkansas fans want to use total yardage.
Another interesting spin
Posted on 1/16/18 at 3:09 pm to lsupride87
quote:
Please explain why you think Guice or LF will end up with no money and in prison Mr. Grand Wizard.
I can't answer for him, but it certainly wouldn't be based upon race. Michel and Chubb are black, too. You knew this, right?
Posted on 1/16/18 at 3:11 pm to DawgsLife
quote:Please dont go with this angle
I can't answer for him, but it certainly wouldn't be based upon race. Michel and Chubb are black, too. You knew this, right?
I know plenty of racist mother freaking LSU fans that cheer their arse off for "our blacks"
Now, I dont think deeprig was being racist, just extremely ignorant
This post was edited on 1/16/18 at 3:12 pm
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News