Aaron Murray’s week 11 QB rankings

Marcel?

It only goes to number 10 which is George Macintire so Marcel would be somewhere after him.

He has actually been insanely good the last 4 games.

QBR in each is
UF- 87.8
Tenn- 79.2
OU- 96.1
A&M- 78.0

All in wins. Season totals 2100 yards on 63% completion. 17 passing TDs with 7 Ints. 637 rushing yards for 6.1 YPC with 7 TDs rushing.

I think the top 3 should be him, Stockton, and Russel and you are splitting hairs a bit between the three statistically as theyre all very close.

Keelon has been a bit better as a passer than Sellers with 18/5 TD/INT ratio and a higher completion % but his rushing numbers are significantly worse with 276 yards and only 3.7 YPC just as an example.

See my post right above you. I think you can make a totally reasonable argument for Keelon or Stockton at number 1 as well. Really its Sellers Russel and Gunner all pretty closely tied for number 1, depending on what exactly you value most out of your QB as theyre all pretty close stats wise

Laugh at Arch but how many SEC QBs have as many wins against ranked teams as Arch ? Would be interesting to know.

quote:

---

QBR in each is
UF- 87.8
Tenn- 79.2
OU- 96.1
A&M- 78.0 <----

---

A game in which he was hurt and could barely walk at times. He just refused to quit. Most people didn't see it because of Bama vs LSU.

Oh I totally agree on that.

Russell will have a higher NFL draft grade than Gunner when he leaves because he has to come back for at least one more year. Which is why I think it’s pretty possible Gunner returns for another year at UGA depending on his draft grade. Unless he gets a top 2 round grade (which he won’t imo) he probably comes back

Again, I agree I think with you.

We were only talking about NFL grades on KR and Stockton comparatively.

Including sellers I think the nfl would see them in this order

Sellers
KR
Stockton

quote:

---

Laugh at Arch but how many SEC QBs have as many wins against ranked teams as Arch ? Would be interesting to know

---

I was being a bit tongue in cheek.

Arch being 8th makes sense when taking his season in total, but he has been the best version of himself in his most recent games. The game against Mizzou was probably the best game I’ve seen him have in a Texas uniform

Cool write up.

Most of it if not all of it is basically totally irrelevant to this thread though.

For some reason you’re choosing to compare QBs against Arch in games they played head to head, rather than looking at a QBs entire seasons worth of body of work and merit.

It is an extremely twisted and contorted view of trying to gas up Arch, and it doesn’t even do the job well at all. There are a number of reasons for this but one of the biggest is that Texas has one of the best defenses in the country, so you’re baking into your very very very odd way of trying to make Archie look better a massive handicap against other QBs who unless they also play UGA or maybe Indiana are playing the best defense they will see all year by far, whereas arch is getting to play against one of the worst defenses in the country in one of your 4 cherry picked teams (ole miss,) a defense that has proven over the season it is a at worse than expected (Ohio state,) a defense that is middle of the road in the SEC (Mizzou) and one good defense you chose to include (Tennessee)

You went through all of this effort for no reason, or worse a dumb one. The SEC has a bunch of very good QBs in it this year.

Instead of making one of the weirdest arguments as a justification I have ever seen; watch the video and explain why he should be above any of the 7 QBs ahead of him based on his seasons body of work. And I just made a post before yours acknowledging Arch has gotten markedly better recently than he was early in the year and probably just played his best game I’ve seen him have at Texas against Zou