td01241
| Favorite team: | Georgia |
| Location: | Savannah |
| Biography: | |
| Interests: | |
| Occupation: | |
| Number of Posts: | 28009 |
| Registered on: | 11/20/2012 |
| Online Status: | Not Online |
Recent Posts
Message
re: Carson Beck can tell his grandchildren he threw the game winning touchdown pass
Posted by td01241 on 12/24/25 at 2:20 pm to Peter Buck
Completely agree.
I would also add he is far far better at the mental aspect of the game and processing
I would also add he is far far better at the mental aspect of the game and processing
Beck played a year with largely all of the top contributors on offense Stetson had, even though they were banged up a bit some of them.
If he’s soooo much better it should’ve evened out
If he’s soooo much better it should’ve evened out
re: Carson Beck can tell his grandchildren he threw the game winning touchdown pass
Posted by td01241 on 12/24/25 at 9:10 am to Peter Buck
Damn dude are you fricking the guy or something? Stetson is a far far far better football player and overall player of the QB position than Beck is and Beck has tremendously more raw talent,
At some point people should start asking themselves why this is
At some point people should start asking themselves why this is
Idk.
All I know is what I saw which was Reed was basically obnoxiously bad the entire 60 minutes. Beck was just as bad if not a slight bit better but Miami hid him as much as it’s possible to hide your starting QB. Yalls (as in yalls coaches) just kept allowing Reed to frick up everything and never made any attempts whatsoever to hide him in that same way.
All I know is what I saw which was Reed was basically obnoxiously bad the entire 60 minutes. Beck was just as bad if not a slight bit better but Miami hid him as much as it’s possible to hide your starting QB. Yalls (as in yalls coaches) just kept allowing Reed to frick up everything and never made any attempts whatsoever to hide him in that same way.
re: Time for a group of 5 playoff.
Posted by td01241 on 12/21/25 at 12:02 pm to jonnyanony
Yeah it’s a total mess. Since you’re the one who asked for examples specifically of what others arguments are vis a vi anti trust when I get home and post them I’ll reply to the post I’m replying to right now again with them no matter where the thread is at, so that you will be able to easily track it
re: Time for a group of 5 playoff.
Posted by td01241 on 12/21/25 at 11:57 am to jonnyanony
Me and my lady are at post church functions at the moment. In an hour or so when I get home and have access to my desktop I’ll post some in this thread even it if it has died down and you all can see their arguments and debate them if you wish.
re: Time for a group of 5 playoff.
Posted by td01241 on 12/21/25 at 11:53 am to jonnyanony
quote:
There's no antitrust case here. The NFL is not obliged to invite the CFL to the playoffs
I’m not a lawyer but many many lawyers have made the argument that there is an anti trust case, and that the g5 would 100% sue over it. Would they win? Who knows but I do know p4 doesn’t want that happening
re: Time for a group of 5 playoff.
Posted by td01241 on 12/21/25 at 11:52 am to Wolfhound45
:lol:
You can call them DEI if you like, and I’m a very right conservative on politics so I’m no fan of DEI, but I wouldn’t consider that in this situation. Maybe something that is in the spirit of it but they would be suing based on long and very established anti trust precedent not some bs leftist woke legal precedent and they would have a point and a case.
Which is why I say we (as in the the p4 and its fans) need to nudge them to their own playoff with a financial carrot and not the stick
You can call them DEI if you like, and I’m a very right conservative on politics so I’m no fan of DEI, but I wouldn’t consider that in this situation. Maybe something that is in the spirit of it but they would be suing based on long and very established anti trust precedent not some bs leftist woke legal precedent and they would have a point and a case.
Which is why I say we (as in the the p4 and its fans) need to nudge them to their own playoff with a financial carrot and not the stick
re: One and Done
Posted by td01241 on 12/21/25 at 11:49 am to hookem2522
I feel really really bad for Aggies this morning honestly. For real not trolling. If Marcel Reed hadn’t gone full retard from the opening whistle that easily win that game.
To be fair Beck went full retard most game as well. Miami went out of their way to hide Beck as much as possible though and A&M didn’t do the same for Reed
To be fair Beck went full retard most game as well. Miami went out of their way to hide Beck as much as possible though and A&M didn’t do the same for Reed
re: Time for a group of 5 playoff.
Posted by td01241 on 12/21/25 at 11:42 am to bamameister
I agree. I also don’t want to make this political but there is this attempt to make taboo things that are obvious in our feminized culture in certain things, one of those things being that “equality” actually exists and is a real thing.
It’s time we stop pretending Troy and Tulane are playing the same game as UGA and Ohio State
It’s time we stop pretending Troy and Tulane are playing the same game as UGA and Ohio State
re: Time for a group of 5 playoff.
Posted by td01241 on 12/21/25 at 11:36 am to Slums_Alum
They’ll never accept it for financial reasons and will have a case against the p4 reason to sue. See my post above.
There is no way to bully them out the playoff as it currently stands. Zero. The only way is to split the two playoffs and it must be done with a financial carrot
There is no way to bully them out the playoff as it currently stands. Zero. The only way is to split the two playoffs and it must be done with a financial carrot
re: Time for a group of 5 playoff.
Posted by td01241 on 12/21/25 at 11:28 am to bamabaseballsec
This is sort of hitting on the point. The one and only reason the g5 is allowed very limited access to the current playoff is to avoid anti trust lawsuits.
The best way forward imo is a g5 separate playoff subsidized by the p4. I think it’ll actually make money and people will watch it because it’ll be equal level competition and actually give those teams a trophy to compete for. I think it’ll actually make money and not be something like the WNBA is to the NBA. Then you can give the g5 the option to continue just accepting their subsidized playoff or to take complete control of it and all of the money it makes along with it, assuming it does turn profit
The best way forward imo is a g5 separate playoff subsidized by the p4. I think it’ll actually make money and people will watch it because it’ll be equal level competition and actually give those teams a trophy to compete for. I think it’ll actually make money and not be something like the WNBA is to the NBA. Then you can give the g5 the option to continue just accepting their subsidized playoff or to take complete control of it and all of the money it makes along with it, assuming it does turn profit
Either of these teams is going to lose to OSU by at least as bad as Oregon did last year. I think worse
re: Miami has owned A&M thru 3 quarters
Posted by td01241 on 12/20/25 at 1:58 pm to GambitAUfan
Carson Beck throwing the ball 20 yards over the head of two wide open receivers who would’ve walked in for touchdowns.
Twice.
Doesn’t fit into owning for me personally
Twice.
Doesn’t fit into owning for me personally
re: Miami fans are gonna be besides themselves after they lose this
Posted by td01241 on 12/20/25 at 1:43 pm to dallastiger55
Beck has sailed two definite TDs like 20 feet over the wide open receivers head
I have a suggestion where they can bring with their anger
I have a suggestion where they can bring with their anger
Their roster is so good they just need a guy who understands the assignment and gets it there. A game manager. Beck wants to be a gunslinger.
Which sure that works when you have one of the best TE in college football history and another 1st round receiver plus another starting TE in the nfl right now and 2 of his OL his first year at UGA are NFL starters.
So yeah as long as Beck has all that no worries :lol:
Which sure that works when you have one of the best TE in college football history and another 1st round receiver plus another starting TE in the nfl right now and 2 of his OL his first year at UGA are NFL starters.
So yeah as long as Beck has all that no worries :lol:
Yes Beck sucks too :lol:
Like how is Miami this retarded? Beck is a talented QB when it comes to arm talent but he melts like snowman in Georgia summer whenever he is even asked to carry the load a little bit. He must have a competent run game around him and apparently to be good judging off his 3 college starting seasons he needs 2 1st round nfl pick skill guys to catch for him
Like how is Miami this retarded? Beck is a talented QB when it comes to arm talent but he melts like snowman in Georgia summer whenever he is even asked to carry the load a little bit. He must have a competent run game around him and apparently to be good judging off his 3 college starting seasons he needs 2 1st round nfl pick skill guys to catch for him
And this is his third year as a full time starter in a major program stacked with talent
Also to be fair Bennet had roughly almost the exact same skill position and RB talent as well as an excellent OL his two NC years that Beck also had ALL OF his first year at UGA and he couldn’t even come close to accomplishing what Bennet did.
Then when the talent around him dipped and way more was asked of him he was seriously awful
Then when the talent around him dipped and way more was asked of him he was seriously awful
Bennet is likely going to be the Rams starter whenever Stafford hang it’s up.
I wouldn’t be too surprised if Beck never really gets much run in the nfl
I wouldn’t be too surprised if Beck never really gets much run in the nfl
re: Beck is atrocious
Posted by td01241 on 12/20/25 at 1:19 pm to BuzzSaw 12
He’s just a serviceable qb. He has stronger arm than say Stetson Bennet and has more arm talent to get it to certain spots like layering it over the middle or putting a frozen rope 30 yards down the seam but in pretty much all other aspects of playing the QB position he is definitely below Bennet.
So that’s about how good he is
So that’s about how good he is
Popular
0








